GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen's $56B Plan to Take Over eBay

Original Media · 1h 04m · English · Podcast · All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg

TLDR

Ryan Cohen, founder of Chewy and CEO of GameStop, discusses his entrepreneurial journey from building Chewy into a $3.35B exit to his activist investment in GameStop and current hostile bid to acquire eBay. He outlines his management philosophy of extreme cost discipline, hiring for 'will over skill,' and focusing on seller/customer experience, while arguing that eBay's stagnation under professional management creates an opportunity for founder-led operational improvement in live commerce and digital collectibles.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Cohen admits applying the Chewy playbook to GameStop was 'really, really stupid' — it took him over a year to realize physical retail requires a completely different model than recurring-revenue pet food.

•

He reveals the eBay acquisition idea came to him 'on the toilet' after studying the collectibles overlap, not from a formal strategic review.

•

Cohen claims eBay's live commerce platform has 'at max a few hundred people watching' despite a $400B TAM, and that sellers must use third-party tools because eBay's own Seller Central is incomplete.

•

He plans to build a marketplace for in-game digital items (skins, weapons) on eBay, arguing they have real utility unlike NFTs and represent a larger addressable market than physical collectibles.

Key takeaways

•

Cohen's management philosophy centers on hands-on operational intensity: negotiating supplier contracts personally, optimizing for pennies, and hiring relentless 'diehards' over credentialed executives.

•

GameStop's turnaround came from abandoning the Chewy e-commerce playbook and doubling down on physical retail strengths — particularly pre-owned and collectibles — after realizing low-margin commodity retail couldn't compete with Amazon.

•

Cohen sees eBay as a complementary fit with GameStop (collectibles, refurbished tech, authentication) and believes its stagnation stems from bloated costs (opex >50% of revenue), seller alienation, and failure to capitalize on live commerce and digital collectibles.

•

His eBay bid is 50% cash/50% GameStop stock with $500M of his own capital; he argues the combined entity can cut $2B in costs immediately and build a digital marketplace for in-game items — a market he believes could exceed physical collectibles.

•

Cohen frames the hostile bid as a clash between founder-operators with skin in the game versus entrenched boards/management with no ownership, criticizing media bias that dismisses GameStop as a 'meme stock' despite fundamental improvements.

Notable quotes

“The difference between failure and success was, you know, pennies in the red is failure and pennies in the black is success. So we had to operate hyper efficiently.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:18

“I look for will over skill... she kept on applying. She was relentless. On paper, she didn't necessarily have the right experience, but she had drive. She ended up being incredible.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:46

“There's nothing more American than basically risking your own capital. So why does everyone want us to fail?”

▸ Notable quotes · 56:04

“eBay could have been Amazon... by doing nothing, has basically carved out a niche in certain categories where Amazon isn't strong.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:01

Chapters

•

1:56 — Chewy Origin and Early Lessons: Cohen recounts pivoting from jewelry to pet food after recognizing recurring revenue potential and fragmented market, applying Amazon's supply chain discipline to achieve negative working capital and rapid growth.

•

8:00 — Management Philosophy: Will Over Skill: Details hiring for relentless drive over credentials, personal involvement in supplier negotiations and ad campaigns, and creating a culture of 'fellow psychopaths' focused on penny-level efficiency.

•

13:20 — GameStop: From Passive Investor to CEO: Describes initial console-cycle thesis, board seat rejection, activist turn during COVID, and the painful realization that Chewy's e-commerce playbook failed in physical retail — leading to a collectibles-focused turnaround.

•

27:26 — eBay Acquisition Thesis: Explains strategic rationale: complementary collectibles/refurbished businesses, global scale, and three value-creation levers — immediate $2B cost cuts, live commerce leadership, and a digital marketplace for in-game items.

•

49:33 — Hostile Bid Dynamics and Media Bias: Details board rejection, lack of engagement, 50/50 cash-stock offer with $500M personal capital, and Cohen's frustration with media/establishment bias against founder-operators versus professional managers with no skin in the game.

Speakers

•

David Friedberg — Host/Interviewer

•

Ryan Cohen — Founder of Chewy, CEO of GameStop, Bidder for eBay

⋮