TLDR
The Daily examines how the Trump administration has turned the presidential pardon power into a transactional 'pardon industry,' where wealthy individuals and allies pay lobbyists and make donations to secure clemency, bypassing the traditional Justice Department review process. The episode traces the evolution from criminal justice reform in Trump's first term to a system that now favors connections and payments over remorse, with examples like the Fago family, Joseph Schwartz, and Alina Haba's $50 million contract.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The White House created a new 'pardon czar' position for Alice Johnson, a former recipient, to run a parallel clemency process outside the Justice Department.
At Mar-a-Lago 'candlelight dinners,' donors sit around a table with Trump and explicitly ask for pardons in a format resembling a transactional marketplace.
Lobbyist Josh Nass was arrested for allegedly trying to violently extort $500,000 from the Schwartz family after they paid him $100,000 for pardon lobbying.
Alina Haba's $50 million contract was with a company formed days earlier with no public operations, raising questions about what legal services could justify the fee.
Key takeaways
Trump has largely abandoned the standard DOJ clemency review process, instead granting pardons based on personal connections, political loyalty, and appeals to his grievances about the justice system.
A network of lobbyists and lawyers with ties to Trump's inner circle charges high fees to wealthy petitioners, creating a 'pardon economy' that includes Mar-a-Lago dinners where supplicants directly pitch the president.
High-profile cases illustrate the pattern: Elizabeth Fago secured a pardon for her son after a $1 million Mar-a-Lago dinner; Joseph Schwartz paid nearly $1 million to lobbyists linked to Laura Loomer and was pardoned after three weeks; Alina Haba signed a $50 million contract with a billionaire's family weeks before his pardon.
The transactional use of clemency undermines justice by wiping away convictions and restitution for victims, and some recipients have reoffended after release.
Democrats plan to investigate the pardon industry if they gain congressional majorities, but oversight is limited without subpoena power.
Notable quotes
“He's largely disregarded this Justice Department process that has been set up in order to identify and vet worthy recipients who meet certain criteria, like in the case of pardons, having served their sentence and actually shown remorse, shown an unlikelihood to recidivate, paid back the victims of their crimes.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:36“It's a little like, Oprah, you get a pardon, you get a pardon, you don't get a pardon. A little bit of monarchy, a little bit of Oprah.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:46“And less than three weeks after she attended that dinner, Trump signed a full and unconditional pardon for Paul Walzak.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:35“It is a symptom of the transactionalism of the Trump administration that has created this entire economy around it. And the goal of the economy is to essentially negate results of the justice system.”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:59Chapters
0:47 — Corruption as a Top Midterm Issue: Polls show government corruption is voters' top concern, with 66% believing Trump uses the presidency to enrich himself. Ken Vogel introduces the 'pardon industry' as a key driver of this perception.
2:43 — Defining the Pardon Industry: Vogel describes a network of lobbyists and lawyers with ties to Trump who charge large fees to wealthy individuals seeking clemency, operating outside the traditional DOJ vetting process.
5:02 — First Term: Criminal Justice Reform and the Kushner Influence: Trump's early clemency grants were influenced by Jared Kushner's personal experience with his father's conviction, leading to the First Step Act and sympathetic pardons like Alice Johnson's.
9:23 — Post-2020 Shift: Pardons for Allies and Family: After losing re-election, Trump granted clemency to political allies (Bannon, Stone, Manafort) and Charles Kushner, signaling a move toward personal and political favoritism.
12:39 — Second Term: Blanket Clemency and a New Pardon Process: Trump issued blanket clemency for January 6 defendants, installed Alice Johnson as 'pardon czar,' and created a White House-run process that invited direct lobbying and donations.
17:34 — Case Study: The Fago Family and Mar-a-Lago Access: Elizabeth Fago, a donor with Trump family ties, attended a $1 million Mar-a-Lago dinner and secured a pardon for her son Paul Walzak within three weeks, wiping out his prison sentence and $4.4 million restitution.
20:00 — Case Study: Joseph Schwartz and the Lobbyist Network: Schwartz paid nearly $1 million to lobbyists connected to Laura Loomer and Josh Nass, was pardoned after three weeks of a three-year sentence, and the case became a 'blueprint' for other inmates.
23:26 — Case Study: Alina Haba and the $50 Million Contract: While serving as a special government employee, Alina Haba signed a $50 million contract with a company linked to billionaire Julio Herrera-Vellatini, whose family donated millions to Trump entities; a pardon followed weeks later.
27:48 — Broader Implications and Political Fallout: The pardon industry subverts justice, eliminates victim restitution, and enables recidivism. Democrats plan investigations if they win Congress, but the White House denies any quid pro quo.
Speakers
Natalie Kitroeff — Host
Ken Vogel — Guest, New York Times reporter covering money and politics