TLDR
At Davos, Undersecretary for Public Diplomacy Sarah Rogers discusses the growing divergence between U.S. free speech protections and European regulatory regimes like the UK's Online Safety Act and EU's Digital Services Act. She details how these laws enable mass arrests for speech in the UK, disproportionate fines on American platforms, and a 'censorship industrial complex' of government-funded NGOs pressuring intermediaries to suppress disfavored viewpoints — an end-run around the First Amendment. Rogers argues the U.S. must push back using diplomatic and trade tools to defend American speech standards abroad.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
UK speech prosecutions exceed those in authoritarian states like Russia and China, yet receive little international scrutiny.
Ofcom pursues U.S. websites that geofence UK users, arguing VPN access by UK citizens gives them jurisdiction.
Leaked emails show NGOs explicitly plotting to 'kill Musk's Twitter' and instigate EU/UK regulatory action against U.S. companies.
A UK mother received a 31-month sentence for an inflammatory but deleted tweet about migration, while child sex offenders often receive lighter sentences.
Key takeaways
The UK arrested over 12,000 people for speech acts in 2023 alone — more than Russia, China, or Turkey — often for criticizing migration policy or gender ideology.
The EU's Digital Services Act functions as a 'censorship tariff,' imposing vague hate-speech rules and massive fines (e.g., €140M on X) that disproportionately target U.S. platforms.
Government-funded NGOs (e.g., Center for Countering Digital Hate) coordinate with U.S. and European officials to pressure platforms and financial intermediaries to debank and deplatform disfavored speakers.
The Biden administration pressured social media companies to censor true information (lab-leak theory, vaccine limitations) under the guise of fighting 'disinformation.'
Decentralized solutions like X's Community Notes — which require consensus among ideological rivals — and AI fact-checking (Grok) are outperforming top-down regulatory approaches.
Notable quotes
“Public diplomacy addresses the relationship between the American government and foreign publics, and this has become a very important Undersecretariat with the rise of the Internet, and then during the Biden administration especially, these mushrooming concerns about so-called disinformation.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:34“We're saying, hey, these are our platforms, this is our standard, and we don't want our users or our platforms to be receiving fines. That's our position.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:10“If you arrest 12,000 people a year for speech and you're raising children in an ecosystem where you can be dragged out of the airport for offending the dogmas of transgender activism, then you might not have a different culture than China for long.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:23“We have emails that have leaked from some of these NGOs... our number one priority should be to kill Musk's Twitter, so kill an American company, right, in order to suppress American political speech, and our second priority is to instigate U.K. and EU regulatory action.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:25“The community note only gets promoted if users who usually disagree agree that that note is correct. They look for consensus amongst rivals, which is a fascinating...”
▸ Notable quotes · 44:02Chapters
0:00 — Introduction: Sarah Rogers' Role and Public Diplomacy: Hosts introduce Sarah Rogers, Undersecretary for Public Diplomacy, who explains her portfolio: managing the U.S. government's relationship with foreign publics, countering disinformation, and overseeing soft power programs like Fulbright, World Cup, and Olympics.
2:10 — U.S. vs. Europe: Free Speech Divergence: Rogers outlines the core tension: the U.S. First Amendment tradition vs. European technocratic regulation (UK Online Safety Act, EU Digital Services Act) that impose vague speech restrictions and extraterritorial fines on American platforms.
9:40 — UK Online Safety Act: Mass Arrests for Speech: Over 12,000 Britons arrested in 2023 for speech acts — including comedians and critics of migration policy — under laws applied via the Online Safety Act. Rogers contrasts this with U.S. standards and questions shared values with allies.
16:00 — EU Digital Services Act: Censorship Tariff on U.S. Tech: The DSA imposes vague hate-speech rules and massive fines (e.g., €140M on X) that disproportionately hit U.S. companies. Rogers argues it functions as a protectionist revenue tool and a 'censorship tariff' targeting American platforms.
34:40 — Censorship Industrial Complex: NGOs as Government Proxies: Leaked emails reveal government-funded NGOs (e.g., Center for Countering Digital Hate) coordinating with U.S. and EU officials to pressure platforms, payment processors, and banks to debank and deplatform disfavored speakers — circumventing the First Amendment.
38:40 — Debanking, Deplatforming, and Intermediary Pressure: Rogers details her Supreme Court win in NRA v. Vulo against viewpoint-based debanking, explaining how regulators use 'reputational risk' to coerce financial intermediaries into cutting off legal but disfavored speech.
23:40 — AI, Deepfakes, and Existing Legal Remedies: On deepfakes, Rogers argues existing defamation, fraud, and child protection laws suffice; new AI-specific regulations risk stifling innovation and ceding ground to rivals like China. The impulse to over-regulate new tech has historically been wrong.
43:40 — Bottom-Up Solutions: Community Notes and AI Fact-Checking: Rogers praises X's Community Notes (consensus among ideological rivals) and Grok AI fact-checking as effective, decentralized alternatives to bureaucratic censorship — noting they correct misinformation faster than legacy media corrections.
Speakers
Jason — Host
David — Host / Public Servant
Sarah Rogers — Undersecretary for Public Diplomacy, U.S. State Department