Michael Kratsios: Trump's Science Agenda, Anti-Science Claims, Fauci's Damage, DEI & China

Original Media · 56m · English · Podcast · All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg

TLDR

Michael Kratsios, Director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, discusses the administration's 'Science: A New Golden Age' report, arguing that U.S. science has stagnated due to politicization, inefficient funding, and a collapsing domestic talent pipeline. He outlines reforms including meta-science experiments to improve grant-making, a strategic pivot to basic research the private sector won't fund, and bold 'moonshot' initiatives in fusion, quantum, and AI-driven discovery to counter China's rising scientific output.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The median age of NIH intramural researchers is 71 years old.

•

NSF allocated roughly 25% of grants to DEI-related initiatives during the Biden administration (~$8B over four years).

•

The IPCC quietly dropped the extreme RCP 8.5 climate scenario for lacking scientific integrity, yet it drove media narratives and funding for decades.

•

U.S.-born PhDs in computer science have inverted from ~70% to ~30% over 30 years.

•

The Vannevar Bush model (government funds basic research at universities) was designed when government funded 70% of R&D; now the private sector funds 70%, but the model hasn't adapted.

Key takeaways

•

The administration rejects the 'anti-science' label, attributing low scientist approval to the politicization of science (e.g., DEI mandates in grants, COVID-era dogma) rather than funding levels.

•

U.S. scientific productivity per dollar has plummeted (Eroom's Law), prompting 'meta-science' experiments like 'golden tickets' for high-risk grants and variable grant durations to mimic venture-style risk-taking.

•

A critical talent crisis exists: the median age of NIH intramural researchers is 71, and foreign-born students now dominate STEM PhDs while domestic pipeline programs were defunded.

•

China's R&D efficiency (estimated 2-10x per dollar) and publication volume (50% more papers) threaten U.S. leadership, but the administration favors a decentralized, market-driven innovation ecosystem over centralized planning.

•

The 'New Golden Age' strategy aims to double scientific output via AI, win bold bets (fusion by 2035, quantum computer by 2028, Moon base by 2030), and refocus federal funds on pre-competitive basic research.

Notable quotes

“We want to essentially double the scientific output of the United States.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:02

“I think the scientific community has lost its way over the last few decades.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:59

“The median age of an intramural researcher at NIH is 71 years old.”

▸ Notable quotes · 49:43

“We have to return the primary focus of government funded research on basic early stage pre-competitive R&D, this discovery science.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:50

“If you question some of the conclusions in the IPCC reports on climate change... if you don't agree with it all, you're anti-science.”

▸ Notable quotes · 48:34

Chapters

•

0:30 — Introduction & OSTP Role: Kratsios explains the Office of Science and Technology Policy coordinates S&T across agencies (NSF, DOE, DARPA, etc.) to set and implement the national agenda.

•

1:55 — Anti-Science Perception & Politicization: Kratsios argues the 'anti-science' label stems from the scientific community's politicization (DEI mandates, COVID dogma), not funding cuts, and that questioning consensus was wrongly labeled anti-science.

•

7:00 — NSF Funding & DEI Grants: Cites a Senate analysis showing ~25% of NSF grants under Biden went to DEI-related 'science' (~$8B), calling it a manifestation of politicization that diverts funds from gold-standard research.

•

8:10 — Climate Science & RCP 8.5: Administration acknowledges human-caused climate change but rejects 'climate emergency' narrative; notes IPCC dropped extreme RCP 8.5 scenario for lacking integrity, yet it drove media/funding for years.

•

13:30 — NIH Stagnation & Meta-Science: NIH budget tripled since 1998 but breakthroughs per dollar fell 80-fold (Eroom's Law). Proposes 'meta-science' units to experiment with grant mechanisms (golden tickets, variable durations) to restore risk-taking.

•

21:00 — Funding Models: Individuals vs. Big Projects: Advocates funding people (portable fellowships) not just projects, alongside centralized 'moonshots' (Apollo-style) for fusion, quantum, space, and AI-for-science (Genesis mission).

•

24:00 — China Competition & R&D Efficiency: China spends near parity but achieves 2-10x output per dollar via lower costs/automation; publishes 50% more papers. U.S. advantage remains decentralized innovation ecosystem and talent attraction.

•

30:00 — University Funding & Vannevar Bush Model: Critiques 70-year-old Bush model (govt funds universities) as outdated now that private sector funds 70% of R&D; pushes for funding best scientists anywhere (FROs, garages, industry).

•

35:00 — STEM Talent Crisis & Immigration: Median NIH researcher age is 71; US-born CS PhDs dropped from 70% to 30%. Calls for restoring gifted programs and legal pathways to retain foreign talent, prioritizing domestic pipeline first.

•

45:00 — Anti-Science Sentiment & Populism: Links populist distrust to COVID-era overreach (Fauci, masking, protest vs. hospital rules) where dissent was crushed; argues healing requires returning to inquiry-based scientific method.

•

51:00 — Basic Research vs. AI Focus: Insists federal R&D must prioritize pre-competitive basic research (physics, math, astronomy) that private capital ignores, while leveraging AI (Genesis mission) to accelerate discovery across fields.

•

52:00 — Implementation & Congressional Dynamics: R&D priorities memo directs top agencies to report implementation in 90 days; early actions include NSF XLABS and 4-year industry PhDs. Optimistic bipartisan support for nonpartisan reforms.

Speakers

•

Host — Interviewer (All In Podcast)

•

Michael Kratsios — Director, White House Office of Science and Technology Policy

⋮