1929 vs 2025: Andrew Ross Sorkin on Crashes, Bubbles & Lessons Learned

Original Media · 51m · English · Podcast · All-In with Chamath, Jason, Sacks & Friedberg

TLDR

Andrew Ross Sorkin discusses his new book '1929,' a character-driven history of the 1929 stock market crash. He explains how consumer credit, 10:1 margin lending, zero regulation, and technological hype (radio/RCA) created a speculative frenzy, drawing parallels to today's AI boom, private credit leverage, and regulatory challenges. The conversation covers the Mitchell vs. Glass rivalry, the lobbying-driven origins of Glass-Steagall, and whether current fiscal and monetary conditions rhyme with 1929.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Glass-Steagall was driven more by banking lobbying (Chase/Rockefellers targeting JP Morgan) than consumer protection — Carter Glass himself complained the bill was hijacked by bankers.

•

Roosevelt won the 1932 election largely over Prohibition, not the economy — the socialist vs. capitalist debate didn't ignite until 1932, years after the crash.

•

Sorkin, a financial journalist, is barred from investing in individual stocks and holds only index funds — he regrets not buying Bitcoin early despite Chamath's urging.

Key takeaways

•

The 1929 crash was fueled by a consumer credit revolution (GM, Sears, National City Bank), 10:1 margin lending with no risk underwriting, and a total absence of regulation — no SEC, no prospectuses.

Notable quotes

“you could put a buck down, and they would literally loan you $10 off of your dollar. I mean, that's how insane things were.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:53

“RCA was like the NVIDIA of its time.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:56

“Speculation is the twin of innovation. It's putting your capital at risk. There is no innovation without some speculation.”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:00

“It almost has nothing to do... it actually has to do with business reasons, meaning there was like some major bank money and lobbying going on behind the scenes to F over JP Morgan.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:49

“I think we're still in the novelty slopware phase of AI where most of it is about speed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:45

“They're always higher because they're measured in human lives.”

▸ Notable quotes · 46:43

Chapters

•

0:00 — Origin of the Book: Sorkin explains he wrote '1929' because existing histories lacked a character-driven narrative like 'Den of Thieves' or 'Barbarians at the Gate.' He discovered rich primary sources (Thomas Lamont's call transcripts with Hoover/FDR) at Harvard's Baker Library.

•

3:00 — The 1929 Economic Setup: Pre-1919, borrowing was a moral sin. GM introduced auto loans in 1919; Sears followed for appliances. Charlie Mitchell at National City Bank (Citi) applied this to stocks — brokerage houses proliferated like Starbucks, offering 10:1 margin with zero risk underwriting, no SEC, no prospectuses. In 1928 the market rose 48%.

•

8:00 — Social Contagion & Democratization of Finance: Urbanization brought farm workers to cities where they saw elite wealth. Media (Time, Forbes) made CEOs celebrities. John Raskob (GM credit architect, Empire State builder) pushed 'Everyone Ought to Be Rich' — shifting the American Dream from Horatio Alger to a lottery. Radio amplified stories like Instagram today.

•

12:00 — Key Characters: Charlie Mitchell vs. Carter Glass: Mitchell ('Sunshine Charlie,' Jamie Dimon/Michael Milken of his era) ran National City, sat on NY Fed board, pushed low rates, lent to speculators and brokerages. Glass (Elizabeth Warren/AOC of his time, but racist) railed against 'Mitchellism' for years. Mitchell defied Fed's 'stop lending to speculators' letter, leading to Congressional hearings and arrest.

•

22:00 — Glass-Steagall's Surprising Origins: The separation of commercial/investment banking and creation of FDIC was driven by Chase/Rockefeller lobbying to marginalize JP Morgan, not consumer protection. Carter Glass was unhappy the bill was hijacked by bankers — ironic given Elizabeth Warren cites it as a panacea.

•

23:00 — Parallels to Today: Leverage, Regulation & AI: Sorkin sees rhymes not clones: leverage exists but differs (private credit, real estate, energy plays around AI). Regulations (SEC, accredited investor rules) create regulatory capture — 'path of least resistance' drives froth (crypto, NFTs, SPACs). Speculation is necessary for innovation (Elon/Tesla), but the challenge is containing it.

•

30:00 — Current Market Puzzles: Debt, Dollar & AI: Equities, gold, and Treasuries all high simultaneously — classically inconsistent. US runs 7% debt/GDP in peacetime expansion, yet dollar remains 'prettiest girl at the dance.' AI data center spending adds 100-200bps to GDP; ex-AI, economy looks flat. Private equity resists AI adoption due to psychological insecurity.

•

33:20 — 1929 Aftermath: Slow Roll, Hoover's Errors, New Deal: Crash didn't immediately spark socialism debate — market down only 17% by end of '29, seemed to recover. Hoover raised taxes, signed Smoot-Hawley tariffs, Fed didn't flood system. Hoovervilles appeared in '32. Roosevelt won on Prohibition, not economy. New Deal shut 9,000 banks; capitalism vs. socialism debate erupted then.

•

41:00 — Fiscal Crisis, Social Compact & Tariffs: Government overpromising (education, housing, healthcare) distorted markets via 'buy-only' force, inflating costs. Dalio/Ferguson see empire end ~2040 when defense spending/GDP hits breaking point. Smoot-Hawley parallels: tariffs for national security (auto resilience) may mean paying more for worse cars — the cost of strategic optionality.

•

47:00 — Movie Rights, Audiobook & Closing: Sorkin hasn't sold film rights yet; wrote book cinematically with 100+ pages of endnotes. He narrated the 13-hour audiobook himself (30 hours recording). Hosts praise the book as a gripping, underappreciated period of history.

Speakers

•

Andrew Ross Sorkin — Guest, author of '1929' and 'Too Big to Fail', CNBC journalist

•

Chamath Palihapitiya — Host, investor

•

David Sacks — Host, investor

⋮