TLDR
Nate Silver joins the All-In Interview to discuss the Knicks' playoff run, California's election system, and the 2026/2028 electoral landscape. He argues partisanship is the dominant force in US politics — 43 of 50 states are predictable with 97% confidence for 2028 — and that California's slow vote counting creates appearances of impropriety without evidence of fraud. Silver breaks down the Democratic Party into three factions (left, abundance libs, resistance libs), predicts Democrats are 85-90% favorites to take the House in 2026 but only 40-45% for the Senate, and sees Gavin Newsom fading while AOC emerges as a potential 2028 outsider candidate.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Silver is not a registered Democrat despite being perceived as liberal-leaning.
The biggest Democratic vote losses in 2024 came from Hispanic and Asian American voters — the most entrepreneurial demographic groups who fled socialist systems.
Silver believes the 'abundance liberal' faction (pro-housing, pro-growth, anti-culture-war) is the most electorally viable but the 'resistance liberal' faction (Newsom) currently controls party machinery.
Social media algorithms (especially X/Twitter's 'For You' feed) are a 'very effective mechanism' for forcing complex political views into a single left-right dimension, reinforcing partisan sorting.
Key takeaways
Partisanship is the 'gravity' dictating US elections: 43 of 50 states are predictable with 97% confidence for 2028, driven by polarization not rigging.
California's month-long vote counting creates perception of fraud but reflects systematic differences in when Democratic vs Republican voters cast ballots (mail-in vs in-person, early vs late).
Voter ID laws historically helped Democrats by increasing turnout among non-college voters, but the coalition shift (Democrats now winning college-educated, Republicans winning non-college) has reversed this dynamic.
The Democratic Party has three factions: the left (AOC/Bernie), abundance liberals (Ezra Klein, pro-market, anti-gerrymandering), and resistance liberals (Newsom, partisan fighters who deny Biden's unpopularity).
2026 midterms: Democrats ~85-90% to win House, ~40-45% to win Senate (correlated outcomes); 2028: Democrats slight favorites but Newsom falling (25%→15% in primary polls), AOC seen as potential outsider nominee.
Notable quotes
“Partisanship is the gravity that dictates every election in the US... 43 of the 50 states stated, we could probably predict right now with 97% confidence who they'll vote for in 2028. And it's not because of rigging, it's because polarization and partisanship are very powerful forces that we can't seem to escape from.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“I think there's no evidence of fraud is the short summary version. The mistake that can be made is to assume that each ballot like comes in independently when there are systematic differences between groups and when they tend to cast their ballots.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:48“Prediction markets say Democrats are around, I think, 80 or 85% to take the House and 40 or 45% to take the Senate. Those both seem pretty reasonable to me. I think if anything, it's a little bit low on the House. I think it might be more like 85 or 90.”
▸ Notable quotes · 50:02“Newsom has fallen in democratic primary polls from around 25% to 15%. He's fallen on poly market from like 33% to 22% or something. I think he was benefiting from some degree of name recognition. Whereas now Democrats see a candidate like John Ossoff in Georgia, another good looking young guy, but like actually has a credential, which Newsom will never have of having won an election in a purple state.”
▸ Notable quotes · 55:33Chapters
0:00 — Knicks Playoff Run & Sports Betting: Discussion of Knicks' Eastern Conference Finals run, Nate's betting on Knicks futures, Mike Brown's defensive system, Karl-Anthony Towns' impact, and playoff experience as an edge.
9:38 — California Elections & Mail-In Voting: Analysis of LA mayoral race counting delays, mail-in vs in-person ballot differences, ballot harvesting allegations, and why California's slow count creates appearance of impropriety without evidence of fraud.
15:15 — Voter ID Laws & Partisan Coalitions: How voter ID impact has flipped: used to help Democrats (higher turnout), now may help Republicans due to coalition realignment (Democrats = college-educated, Republicans = non-college).
21:30 — Partisanship as Political Gravity: 43 of 50 states predictable with 97% confidence for 2028; California as a 'machine state' vs New England's cross-partisan governors; gerrymandering war to the bottom.
26:10 — Democratic Party's Three Factions: Left (AOC/Bernie), Abundance Liberals (Ezra Klein, pro-market, pro-housing), Resistance Liberals (Newsom, partisan fighters). Newsom's embrace of Biden legacy seen as failed strategy.
32:35 — Generational Divide on Socialism vs Capitalism: Under-40 voters more favorable to socialism (Cold War memory absent, student debt burden); over-40 more pro-capitalist. Hispanic/Asian entrepreneurial voters shifting away from Democrats.
44:00 — Social Media Algorithms & Polarization: Algorithmic feeds (TikTok, X, YouTube) force complex views into single left-right dimension; Twitter's 'For You' feed reinforces partisan sorting; Silver criticizes loss of chronological/follow-based feeds.
49:45 — 2026 Midterms & 2028 Presidential Outlook: House: Dems 85-90% favorites; Senate: 40-45% (correlated outcomes). 2028: Dems slight favorites but Newsom fading (25%→15%), AOC mentioned as potential outsider nominee; Ossoff seen as most electable.
Speakers
Nate Silver — Guest - Statistician, election forecaster, Silver Bulletin founder
Jason Calacanis — Host - All-In Interview Show
Other Hosts — Co-hosts (Jake, Dave referenced but not clearly distinguished in transcript)