Can Israel’s Opposition Unseat Netanyahu?

Original Media · 33m · English · Podcast · The Daily

TLDR

More than two weeks after Israel's November 2022 election, opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot faces a near-impossible task: cobbling together a 61-seat majority from ideologically warring parties to unseat Benjamin Netanyahu. His only viable partners — ultra-Orthodox parties demanding draft exemptions and subsidies, and Arab parties whose inclusion triggers deep Jewish voter anxiety — each demand concessions that would fracture his existing coalition or betray his core campaign promises. If Eisenkot fails within six weeks, Netanyahu likely returns as caretaker with a structural advantage in new elections.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The Islamist Ra'am party under Mansour Abbas has moved further toward integration into Zionist governance than the secular Joint List, recognizing Israel as a Jewish state and condemning October 7.

•

Netanyahu's political incentive is to do nothing: if Eisenkot fails, Netanyahu remains caretaker prime minister during new elections, which incumbency advantages make him likelier to win.

•

Eisenkot left deliberate wiggle room on ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions during his campaign — phasing in core curriculum, allowing a small number of exemptions — signaling he prioritized ousting Netanyahu over his signature issue.

Key takeaways

•

Eisenkot's bloc holds only 48 of 120 Knesset seats and must recruit parties that fundamentally oppose each other — ultra-Orthodox parties that reject military service and Arab parties that many Jewish voters view as security risks.

•

A unity government with Netanyahu is effectively dead: Eisenkot campaigned explicitly to oust him, Netanyahu previously reneged on a rotation agreement, and Netanyahu benefits politically from letting coalition talks collapse and triggering new elections.

•

The ultra-Orthodox parties demand permanent draft exemptions for yeshiva students and generous state subsidies; Eisenkot, a former military chief who lost a son in Gaza, built his campaign on equal burden-sharing, making any deal a personal and political betrayal.

•

Mansour Abbas's Islamist Ra'am party has made unprecedented overtures — recognizing Israel as a Jewish state, condemning Hamas, seeking ministerial roles — but Eisenkot's added demand that partners declare Hamas a terrorist group to be destroyed creates a loyalty-oath dynamic Arab leaders resist.

•

Avigdor Lieberman, whose Yisrael Beiteinu party is essential to Eisenkot's bloc, has categorically ruled out sitting with any Arab party, meaning Abbas's inclusion would likely cost Eisenkot Lieberman's seats.

•

Jewish voter opposition to Arab parties in government stems not only from racism but from fear that Arab lawmakers could become swing votes on security decisions and Palestinian policy, a scenario Netanyahu exploited in campaign ads.

•

If Eisenkot excludes Arab parties despite their record 19 seats, it undermines Israel's long-standing defense against apartheid accusations — that Arab citizens can vote and govern — raising existential questions about the state's democratic character.

•

A minority government of 48 seats is technically possible but viewed as inherently unstable; Eisenkot must choose the least objectionable among a menu of bad options, each risking Netanyahu's return.

Notable quotes

“Imagine herding lions or tigers. That's what we're talking about. These are people who are, in some ways, fundamentally at each other's throats.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:09

“He's in this campaign, he says, to save Israel. And it seems to suggest that he believes that the priority now to save Israel is get Netanyahu out at all costs.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:24

“It's almost like one more step down a very, you know, I'd say it's a slippery slope, but it's a painful slope. And what you hear people say in explaining why they resist this is the feeling that they're being called upon to take a kind of loyalty oath with every one of these questions.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:28

“He did an AI video showing a future government led by Eisenhower, and he had all the parties around the table. And at the end of the table was Mansour Abbas with his feet up and basically saying no, no, no, over and over again in Arabic to all the proposals to crack down on the Palestinians in one way or the other.”

▸ Notable quotes · 25:50

“So what happens when they get 19 seats and could, you know, make a government, but the government doesn't form because they're afraid to?”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:24

“Eisencott has to figure out which of all of these bad options is least objectionable to the largest number of Israelis. And answering that question really comes down to what you think Israel should be and who it should be for.”

▸ Notable quotes · 29:38

Chapters

•

2:30 — Post-election deadlock: Two weeks after the election, no clear winner has emerged. Eisenkot leads the largest bloc with 48 seats but needs 61 for a majority, and the potential coalition partners are ideologically incompatible.

•

5:57 — Unity government with Netanyahu ruled out: A Netanyahu-Eisenkot unity government is a non-starter: Eisenkot campaigned to oust Netanyahu, Netanyahu previously broke a rotation deal, and Netanyahu benefits from letting talks fail to trigger new elections.

•

8:06 — Ultra-Orthodox demands vs. Eisenkot's core promise: Ultra-Orthodox parties demand draft exemptions and subsidies for yeshiva students; Eisenkot, a former military chief who lost a son in Gaza, campaigned on equal burden-sharing, making any deal a betrayal of his central platform.

•

13:33 — Arab parties as potential kingmakers: Arab parties won a record 19 seats. The secular Joint List focuses on protest; the Islamist Ra'am party under Mansour Abbas has actively sought government entry, recognizing Israel as a Jewish state and condemning Hamas.

•

20:08 — Loyalty oath dynamics and Lieberman's veto: Eisenkot added a requirement that partners declare Hamas a terrorist group to be destroyed, which Arab leaders view as an escalating loyalty oath. Lieberman categorically refuses to sit with any Arab party, threatening to bolt the coalition.

•

24:03 — Jewish voter fears and democratic implications: Jewish voters fear Arab lawmakers as swing votes on security and Palestinian policy — a fear Netanyahu exploited in AI-generated campaign ads. Excluding Arab parties despite their 19 seats undermines Israel's defense against apartheid accusations.

•

28:44 — Minority government and the least-bad option: A 48-seat minority government is possible but seen as unstable. Eisenkot must choose the least objectionable among bad options, with the outcome defining what Israel should be and who it is for.

Speakers

•

Andrew Ross-Sorkin — DealBook newsletter author, New York Times

•

Rachel Abrams — Host, The Daily

•

David Hauptfinger — Jerusalem Bureau Chief, New York Times

⋮