A Plan for Two Dans: How Democrats Manipulated Alaska’s Ballot

Original Media · 29m · English · Podcast · The Daily

TLDR

The Daily investigates how two candidates named Dan Sullivan ended up on Alaska's U.S. Senate ballot, revealing that Democrats secretly recruited Dan J. Sullivan to split the Republican vote and help Democrat Mary Peltola, despite months of public denials.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Democrats maintained emphatic public denials for months while privately executing the recruitment plan.

•

The scheme was exposed only because Peltola fired her own campaign manager, who then became the whistleblower.

•

Both parties have used similar ballot-stacking tactics in Alaska recently, including Republicans boosting Democratic primary candidates.

Key takeaways

•

Democrats orchestrated a secret ballot-stacking scheme to recruit Dan J. Sullivan as a spoiler candidate against incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan.

•

The plot involved Democratic operative Jared Kurtz using pseudonyms to recruit candidates, including Dan J. Sullivan, who was nudged into running to help Mary Peltola.

•

Mary Peltola's campaign fired veteran staffers (including campaign manager Elisa Rios) who then exposed the scheme to reporters.

•

The Trump administration filed a lawsuit challenging election certification, calling the recruitment 'illegal,' though legal experts say the case is weak and ballot stacking is a bipartisan tactic.

•

Alaska's ranked-choice voting system may mitigate voter confusion, as Republican voters can rank the incumbent Sullivan second after the spoiler candidate.

Notable quotes

“I'm talking about the real Dan Sullivan, not the fake Dan Sullivan. Not the Dan Sullivan put up by the Democrats. This fake Dan Sullivan guy is not in it to win it. He's in it to rig it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:27

“Instead, my reporting found that's simply not true. In fact, Democrats with the Mary Peltola campaign and with the National Party engaged in an audacious, secretive plan dating back to last year designed to help Mary Peltola win by stacking the ballot in her favor.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:53

“They came up with a plan to recruit other candidates onto the Senate ballot. And the goal was to divide Republican voters and hope that some of them would vote for these alternative candidates on the ballot, depriving Senator Sullivan of a vote and indirectly benefiting Mary Peltola, the Democrat.”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:12

“President Trump posted on Truth Social saying that it had been determined that Democrats in Alaska, he says, quote, illegally searched for and recruited a man named Dan Sullivan to run against our distinguished Republican senator.”

▸ Notable quotes · 23:47

Chapters

•

0:47 — The Two Dan Sullivans: Introduction to the Alaska Senate race with incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan and a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot, sparking Republican accusations of a Democratic dirty trick.

•

5:30 — On the Ground in Petersburg: Reporter Kellen Browning travels to Alaska to interview Dan J. Sullivan, who claims he ran independently but avoids discussing his connections to Democratic operative Amber Lee.

•

12:30 — The Peltola Campaign Implosion: Mary Peltola fires her campaign manager and senior staff weeks before the election; former aides allege abusive management, leading to leaks about the Dan Sullivan recruitment.

•

14:30 — The Secret Recruitment Scheme: Fired campaign manager Elisa Rios reveals Democrats hired operative Jared Kurtz to recruit spoiler candidates using pseudonyms, successfully placing Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot.

•

20:00 — Legal Fallout and Ethical Questions: Trump DOJ sues to block certification; Alaska Supreme Court allows both candidates; ranked-choice voting may reduce confusion; the episode raises ethics concerns about deception in a U.S. Senate race.

Speakers

•

Michael Barbaro — Host of The Daily

•

Kellen Browning — Political reporter, The New York Times

⋮