TLDR
David Marchese interviews filmmaker Martin McDonough about his new film 'Wild Horse Nine,' which dramatizes CIA involvement in Chile's 1973 coup. The conversation spans McDonough's views on American foreign policy, his approach to provocation versus offense in art, criticism around race and language in his work, the influence of punk rock on his worldview, his partnership with Phoebe Waller-Bridge, and whether art can meaningfully change the world.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
McDonough reveals he has been asked in the last decade to change words in plays written 25–30 years ago due to newly taken offense — a practice he finds troubling and refuses.
Despite his reputation for dark, violent work, McDonough describes himself as fundamentally happy and joyful while writing, finding beauty in performances and cinematic craft.
He argues that male friendships in his films reflect his own deep, gentle, emotionally open relationships — a dynamic he feels is rarely depicted authentically on screen.
Key takeaways
McDonough distinguishes between being outrageous (delighting in the unexpected) and offensive (deliberately hurting an audience), arguing his work aims for the former.
He believes making art is inherently hopeful, even when the work is dark, and that art changes the world simply by existing — though he concedes violence has historically changed more.
McDonough takes seriously criticism from Black critics like Hilton Als and Wesley Morris about racial language in his work, but ultimately disagrees with some interpretations, feeling his intent was to portray racism's stupidity.
His teenage discovery of The Clash and punk rock directly shaped his political consciousness and led to 'Wild Horse Nine,' the first film where he channels that youthful anger at U.S. foreign policy.
He finds awards season enjoyable precisely because it was unimaginable for a working-class kid from London, but insists he would never alter his work to chase accolades.
Notable quotes
“making art at all is always hopeful, I think, even if it's dark art”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:31“I think one is deliberately trying to hurt or attack an audience. Whereas the other is to almost delight in something you haven't heard before or you might not have thought of.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:12“I think it's gotten worse, especially in the last 10 years. Like only in the last 10 years have I been asked to change words in plays from 25, 30 years ago because of offense taken by certain words that weren't there 25 years ago.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:22“I think art has changed things, but I think murder has probably changed a lot more things.”
▸ Notable quotes · 48:14“All of the art we've seen, all the films we've loved, all the paintings, they have changed the world because they're in it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 49:38Chapters
2:14 — Introduction and 'Wild Horse Nine' Premise: Marchese introduces McDonough and his new film about CIA agents destabilizing Chile after Allende's election, framing it within debates about America's global role.
3:05 — America, the CIA, and Moral Complexity: McDonough discusses growing up believing the CIA were 'the good guys,' then learning through research — and The Clash — about U.S. involvement in Chile and Congo, which shattered that narrative.
7:00 — Characters as Mouthpieces vs. Autonomous Voices: McDonough explains his characters are never political mouthpieces; he lets them speak authentically, even when their views oppose his own, finding dramatic excitement in their danger.
7:10 — Darkness, Hope, and the Purpose of Art: Marchese probes the bleakness of McDonough's work; McDonough counters that writing is joyful, art-making is inherently hopeful, and cites Leonard Cohen as dark-yet-uplifting.
10:00 — Provocation vs. Offense: The 'Cheeses' Scene: McDonough defines the line between outrageous (delighting in the unheard) and offensive (attacking the audience), using a scene where Malkovich's character links gay countries to good cheese and democracy.
14:22 — Evolving Standards of Offense and Race Criticism: McDonough says offense-taking has worsened in the last decade, with requests to alter old plays. He reflects seriously on critiques from Hilton Als and Wesley Morris but disagrees with some readings.
18:50 — Violence in His Work: Gratuitous or Moral?: McDonough acknowledges criticism of violence but argues it stems from rejecting staid English theater; he believes his violence always carries moral weight and has decreased over time.
21:00 — Legacy, Plays vs. Films, and Male Friendship: He discusses moving from ephemeral plays to permanent films for legacy, and explores deep, gentle male friendships — rare on screen — as central to 'Banshees' and 'Wild Horse Nine.'
27:00 — Punk Rock, Catholicism, and Early Struggle: McDonough recounts losing his Catholic faith at 12 via The Clash, leaving school at 16, years on the dole writing plays, and sudden success with a Broadway run at 24.
33:00 — Teenage Self vs. Current Self: Pride and Complicity: His younger self would be proud of 'Wild Horse Nine' for its political anger inspired by Joe Strummer, but might critique his current complacency and wealth.
37:00 — Part Two: Titles, Dialogue Style, and Tarantino: McDonough discusses his idiosyncratic titles, theatrical dialogue rhythms (influenced by Pinter and Mamet), and pushes back on Tarantino comparisons, noting divergent approaches to violence.
43:00 — Phoebe Waller-Bridge and Mutual Influence: He praises 'Fleabag' as game-changing, saying it taught him about feminism and love, while acknowledging his own squirminess discussing romance.
44:40 — Awards Season: Punk Rock at the Oscars: McDonough enjoys the Oscar race as a surreal, fun game for someone from his background, but insists he would never make 'Oscar-bait' — joking an example would star Timothée Chalamet.
48:00 — Art vs. Violence: Can Art Change the World?: Marchese challenges McDonough's pessimism with Victor Jara's enduring songs; McDonough concedes art changes the world by enriching it, even if not politically, calling that hope.
Speakers
David Marchese — Interviewer, The New York Times
Martin McDonough — Academy Award-winning filmmaker, playwright