TLDR
Criminal psychologist Julia Shaw discusses the psychology of evil as a continuum of traits rather than a binary label, emphasizing that all humans have capacity for harmful behavior. She covers false memory research showing how easily memories can be distorted, the psychology of serial killers and environmental criminals, bisexuality and relationship structures, and how technology like AI can both threaten and protect memory integrity. Shaw advocates for 'evil empathy' to understand and prevent harm, and promotes cognitive restructuring to improve wellbeing.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
70% of men and over 50% of women have fantasized about killing someone — murder fantasies are normal and adaptive for rehearsing consequences.
The bystander effect is largely a myth: research shows most bystanders DO intervene; non-intervention occurs mainly when a crowd has already formed.
Alfred Kinsey found ~50% of men had bisexual tendencies in the 1940s — bisexuality was more common in men historically, not women.
Julia Shaw has aphantasia (cannot visualize mental images), making standard memory techniques like memory palaces ineffective for her.
Volkswagen's Dieselgate involved engineers creating 'defeat device' software to cheat emissions tests for 10 years — clever people doing harm through conformity and rationalization.
Therapy can inadvertently implant false memories using techniques similar to false memory research, complicating legal cases.
Key takeaways
Evil is a continuum of dark tetrad traits (psychopathy, sadism, narcissism, Machiavellianism) present in everyone to varying degrees, not a binary monster/non-monster distinction.
Most murders result from fights gone wrong over trivial matters, not premeditation; homicide recidivism is only 1-3%.
False memories are a feature of healthy brains — 70% of study participants developed false memories of committing crimes after three suggestive interviews.
Memory is reconstructive (like a Wikipedia page), not reproductive; contemporaneous written records are essential for accuracy.
Empathy for perpetrators ('evil empathy') is crucial for prevention, not endorsement — understanding psychological levers helps make society safer.
Bisexuality is often misunderstood as a phase; the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid reveals past/present/ideal discrepancies across multiple dimensions.
Environmental crime involves ordinary people conforming to harmful norms through rationalization, not inherent evil — corporate fraud like Dieselgate exemplifies this.
AI systems can amplify false memory formation through leading interactions; social science integration is needed in AI development.
Cognitive restructuring (deliberately reframing negative memories) effectively improves wellbeing and resilience.
Heroic imagination — mentally rehearsing intervention — counters bystander effect and promotes prosocial action.
Notable quotes
“The question is why we don't do those things rather than why we do do those things quite often.”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:50“Evil is a label we place onto others. There's nothing inherent to anything that makes it evil.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:56“If we're saying that this is the worst kind of act... the only way we're going to do that is if we understand what led that person to come to that situation.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:51“Most of the time it's a fight that gets out of control... it's these really stupid reasons and it is just this bad decision in the moment.”
▸ Notable quotes · 44:25“Basically every single autobiographical memory you have is false. The question isn't whether it's false. The question is how false.”
▸ Notable quotes · 105:44“We have created a tailored experience of something that is most of the time telling you what it thinks you want to hear... the ultimate false memory machine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 102:00“The purpose of what I do isn't just to go, oh, this is curious... The point is to then prevent it and to prevent it in ourselves.”
▸ Notable quotes · 41:08“I think all of us are capable of doing basically the worst things we can imagine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:54Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Sponsors: Lex Fridman introduces Julia Shaw, criminal psychologist and author of Evil, The Memory Illusion, Bi, and Green Crime. Sponsor reads for Shopify, BetterHelp, Element, AG1.
8:16 — Evil as a Continuum: Shaw explains the dark tetrad traits (psychopathy, sadism, narcissism, Machiavellianism) as continua, not binary categories. Discusses the 'baby Hitler' thought experiment and why labeling people 'evil' prevents understanding.
14:16 — Empathy for Perpetrators: Advocates 'evil empathy' to understand psychological levers of harmful behavior for prevention. Discusses interviewing criminals, rationalization, and the danger of dehumanization in war.
30:00 — Serial Killers and Loneliness: Covers Robert Pickton case, loneliness as factor in serial killing, reality monitoring deficits, and radicalization parallels. Mentions Stephen Hart and Elizabeth Loftus as expert witnesses.
44:00 — Murder Psychology and Recidivism: Most murders are unplanned fights over trivial matters; homicide recidivism is 1-3%. Discusses victimization gap, intimate partner homicide, and justice system misalignment.
49:40 — Incels, Fraud, and Relationships: Incels' entitlement and online radicalization; Tinder Swindler case showing how fraud exploits desire for love; jealousy as control not love; polyamory and bisexuality discussions.
99:10 — False Memory Research: Shaw's PhD work implanting false memories of crimes (70% success rate). Explains methodology: true memory priming, imagination exercises, social reinforcement. Discusses memory as reconstructive Wikipedia page.
101:00 — AI and Memory Distortion: AI as 'ultimate false memory machine' — leading interactions distort human memory bidirectionally. Need for social scientists in AI development. Spot tool for cognitive interview administration.
145:00 — Green Crime and Environmental Criminals: Environmental crime psychology: conformity, rationalization, corporate fraud (Dieselgate), poaching gangs. Multi-level criminal structures. Hope from researchers and enforcers fighting these crimes.
165:00 — Personal Reflections and Hope: Shaw's path from art to psychology via father's schizophrenia. Aphantasia discovery. Cognitive restructuring for wellbeing. Technology's potential to support memory and humanity.
Speakers
Lex Fridman — Host
Julia Shaw — Guest