#487 – Irving Finkel: Deciphering Secrets of Ancient Civilizations & Flood Myths

Original Media · 2h 14m · English · Podcast · Lex Fridman Podcast

TLDR

Irving Finkel, British Museum curator and cuneiform expert, discusses the origins of writing in Mesopotamia (~3500 BC), the structure and decipherment of cuneiform, controversial evidence for much earlier writing at Göbekli Tepe (~9000 BC), the Babylonian flood myth that predates Noah's Ark by a millennium (featuring a round coracle boat), the Royal Game of Ur that spread across the ancient world for 3000 years, and the philosophical role of the British Museum as a repository of human achievement. He argues ancient humans had identical cognitive abilities to moderns, critiques monotheism as a source of conflict, and laments the degradation of language by modern electronic communication. Finkel's infectious enthusiasm and Sherlock Holmes-style reasoning illuminate how fragmentary clay tablets reveal vast lost civilizations. The conversation spans linguistics, archaeology, board games, religion, and the nature of human wisdom across millennia. Finkel's controversial theories challenge mainstream Assyriology while his deep humanity makes ancient voices feel startlingly present.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A single green stone seal from Göbekli Tepe (~9000 BC) with carved hieroglyphic signs implies writing existed 5,500 years before Sumerian cuneiform — a 'raindrop' inferring a 'Niagara Falls' of lost literacy.

•

Henry Rawlinson, celebrated as 'father of Assyriology,' wrote a book on cuneiform that was 'almost entirely wrong'; the real decipherment genius was Edward Hincks, an Irish clergyman with five daughters.

•

The Ark was round (a giant coracle), not boat-shaped — coracles never sink and were used on Mesopotamian rivers; the biblical rectangular ark reflects a later literary transformation.

•

Cuneiform signs are multivalent: the same wedge cluster can represent multiple syllables (e.g., 'bar' has 3+ values) AND multiple meanings, requiring context to disambiguate — and they wrote without spaces between words.

•

Sumerian grammar uses agglutination (prefixes/suffixes on roots) to express complex modalities like 'he would have done it if he could but he couldn't' in a single verb form — yet lacks grammatical markers for 'could/might/should' that Akkadian also lacks, though the concepts clearly existed.

•

The flood myth's 'noisy humans' motive is a euphemism: before the flood, gods hadn't created death, so overpopulation was the real problem; post-flood, they instituted barren women and celibate priests as population control — a Malthusian solution.

•

Finkel feels no grief at death, calling it 'infantile' to whine about inevitable mortality — a Stoic perspective he traces to ancient acceptance of finitude.

Key takeaways

•

Cuneiform originated in Mesopotamia around 3500 BC as pictographic accounting, then evolved into a syllabic system capable of recording any spoken language, lasting over 3000 years through rigorous standardization and scribal inertia.

•

The Babylonian flood myth (Atrahasis, ~1700 BC) predates the biblical Noah by 1000+ years and describes a round coracle ark — not a rectangular boat — built to precise mathematical specifications that Finkel successfully reconstructed at 1/3 scale.

•

Writing may have existed millennia earlier than 3500 BC: a seal from Göbekli Tepe (~9000 BC) bears pictographic signs, suggesting complex organization required record-keeping long before Sumer.

•

Cuneiform decipherment relied on the trilingual Behistun inscription (Old Persian, Elamite, Babylonian); Edward Hincks, not Henry Rawlinson, was the true genius who cracked the multivalent sign system.

•

Sumerian is a language isolate with no known relatives — its entire language family vanished, leaving only this one recorded representative, preserved just in time by writing's invention.

•

The Royal Game of Ur (20-square race game with strategy/chance balance) spread from Mesopotamia to Egypt, Crete, and beyond for nearly 3000 years without written rules, transmitted through merchants and travelers.

•

Ancient Mesopotamians didn't 'believe in' gods or ghosts — they took them for granted as practical realities; monotheism introduced religious exclusivity and conflict absent in polytheistic systems.

•

The British Museum's mission is to represent the entire human narrative through objects, serving both the global present and the unborn future, not merely displaying art but preserving the 'raindrops' from which future scholars will infer 'waterfalls' of history.

•

Modern electronic communication degrades language richness; English's vast vocabulary (most words in OED are unknown to average speakers) enables precise thought that emojis and shorthand erode.

•

Ancient humans had identical cognitive capacities to moderns — cave art shows 'Rembrandts' existed 40,000 years ago; the difference is environmental, not biological.

Notable quotes

“It is theoretically possible to infer the Niagara Falls from a raindrop.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:40

“They didn't believe in ghosts. They took them for granted. And they didn't believe in the gods. They took them for granted.”

▸ Notable quotes · 69:55

“I think the big mistake for mankind was the creation of monotheistic religions, because they brought evil into the world.”

▸ Notable quotes · 73:07

“The British Museum is a kind of lighthouse in a universe where we are surrounded by darkness, ignorance, stupidity, uninterest, disinterest, skepticism, ignorance, and so forth.”

▸ Notable quotes · 117:44

“English is unimaginably rich. You take a volume off the shelf and you run your forefinger down the various columns of writing. You might have to turn several pages before you find a single word you've ever heard before.”

▸ Notable quotes · 128:07

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction and Sponsors: Lex Fridman introduces Irving Finkel, curator at the British Museum for 45+ years, world expert on cuneiform, ancient Mesopotamian languages, board games, magic, and medicine. Sponsor reads follow.

•

9:36 — Origin of Writing and Cuneiform: Writing emerged in Mesopotamia ~3500 BC using clay tablets. Pictographic signs evolved into syllabic cuneiform when scribes realized pictures could represent sounds. This breakthrough allowed recording of grammar, literature, and any spoken language. Cuneiform lasted 3000+ years due to early lexicographic standardization.

•

16:00 — Cuneiform Structure and Decipherment: Cuneiform writes in syllables (not alphabetic letters), with multivalent signs requiring context. Decipherment used the trilingual Behistun inscription (Old Persian, Elamite, Babylonian). Edward Hincks, not Henry Rawlinson, was the true decipherment genius who cracked the sign system.

•

38:00 — Sumerian Language and Language Isolates: Sumerian is a language isolate with no known relatives — its entire family vanished. It uses agglutination (prefixes/suffixes) for complex grammar. Akkadian/Babylonian is Semitic, related to Hebrew/Arabic. The Chicago Assyrian Dictionary is a monumental scholarly achievement.

•

23:00 — Göbekli Tepe and Early Writing Controversy: Finkel argues writing existed at Göbekli Tepe (~9000 BC) based on a seal with pictographic signs. Complex architecture implies organization requiring record-keeping. This challenges the mainstream view that writing emerged only with Sumerian city-states.

•

80:00 — Flood Myth and the Ark Tablet: Finkel decoded a 1700 BC tablet (Atrahasis) describing a round coracle ark built to precise specs — predating biblical Noah by 1000+ years. He built a 1/3 scale replica in Kerala. The flood was likely a local Mesopotamian catastrophe, not global. The 'noisy humans' motive masks a Malthusian overpopulation theme.

•

101:00 — Royal Game of Ur: The 20-square race game (2600 BC) spread across the Middle East for 3000 years without written rules. A late Babylonian tablet (2nd century BC) allowed Finkel to reconstruct rules balancing chance and strategy. It provoked 'benevolent fury' in modern players.

•

114:00 — British Museum Philosophy: The Museum represents the entire human narrative through objects, serving both present humanity and the unborn future. It's not an art museum but a 'lighthouse' preserving truth, beauty, and intelligence. Objects in storage are 'stockpiled for future examination' — significance shifts with temporal distance.

•

122:00 — Modern Language, Wisdom, and Mortality: Ancient humans had identical cognition to moderns; cave art proves 'Rembrandts' existed 40,000 years ago. Modern electronic communication degrades language richness. Finkel critiques monotheism as source of religious conflict, and views grief at death as 'infantile' given mortality's inevitability.

Speakers

•

Lex Fridman — Host

•

Irving Finkel — Guest

⋮