New Zealand's most famous disappearance

Original Media · 27m · English · YouTube · MrBallen

TLDR

This episode recounts three workplace-related tragedies where ordinary days turned catastrophic. Jim Donnelly vanished from a New Zealand steel mill in 2004, his belongings later found staged in an acid vat too weak to dissolve a body. In 1904, four soap factory workers survived an elevator plunge only to be killed by hydrochloric acid from shattered jars. In 2001, DEA agent Mike Labazzo died in a backyard sinkhole caused by a collapsed sewage tank, not the criminal retaliation he feared. All three cases subvert initial assumptions about what happened.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The acid vat where Jim Donnelly's belongings were found had been searched multiple times by teams and was in a high-traffic area, yet his bright yellow named hard hat appeared there days later as if placed deliberately.

•

The hydrochloric acid that killed the soap factory workers was being transported in glass jars — not modern safety containers — on an open elevator with no shaft enclosure.

•

Mike Labazzo, a federal agent trained to anticipate threats, died from a mundane infrastructure failure (a sewage tank collapse) rather than the criminal retaliation he constantly feared.

•

In all three stories, the initial theories (Jim fell in acid, elevator fall killed workers, Mike was targeted by criminals) were proven wrong by evidence discovered afterward.

Key takeaways

•

Jim Donnelly arrived at work normally but missed a 9:00 a.m. meeting; his car remained in the lot but he was nowhere in the 2-square-mile mill, and his wife noted he had been sleep-deprived and acting strangely after a secretive meeting days earlier.

•

Five days after Jim's disappearance, a supervisor found his named hard hat floating conspicuously atop an acid vat in a heavily trafficked area that had been searched repeatedly, suggesting the items were staged after the initial searches.

•

The acid in the vat was too weak to dissolve a human body — only strong enough to remove rust — and no human remains were found, contradicting the theory that Jim fell in and dissolved.

•

At the Babbitt Soap Factory in 1904, an open elevator car carrying four workers and 200 gallons of hydrochloric acid in glass jars plummeted five stories; the men survived the impact but the jars shattered, spraying acid that melted their skin and eyes as they lay trapped in rubble.

•

The elevator had no enclosed shaft or safety mechanisms that functioned; the accident occurred in plain view of the entire factory floor, and the victims' screams alerted everyone to the horror unfolding in the basement.

•

Mike Labazzo, a DEA agent accustomed to danger, heard a groaning sound from his backyard on Labor Day 2001 and went to investigate, fearing retaliation from criminals he had prosecuted.

•

The sound came from a massive sinkhole formed when a sewage tank drainage the day before caused the aged tank to collapse, creating a 25-foot-deep pit; the grass crust gave way under Mike's weight, dropping him into concrete and sewage.

•

Mike's body took 18 hours to recover; his wife found their children unattended on the couch, unaware their father had stepped outside moments earlier and never returned.

Notable quotes

“where is Jim?”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:14

“they experienced a far worse fate than anyone could have imagined after the crash stopped”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:31

“their skin is being melted off the bone”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:47

“he would die from this accident. It would take 18 hours for rescue workers to finally recover his body”

▸ Notable quotes · 26:37

“the acid that had been in there was relatively weak and couldn't actually dissolve much of anything aside from rust”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:51

“somebody would have noticed it. So, now it seemed entirely possible that someone had actually staged the hard hat”

▸ Notable quotes · 12:47

Chapters

•

0:55 — Jim Donnelly's Disappearance: Jim Donnelly vanishes from Glenbrook Steel Mill in New Zealand after arriving normally; his car stays parked but he misses a meeting. Days later, his hard hat and belongings are found in an acid vat in a heavily searched area, but the acid is too weak to dissolve a body, suggesting staging.

•

15:21 — SNHU Advertisement: Sponsor message for Southern New Hampshire University promoting online degree programs.

•

16:05 — Babbitt Soap Factory Elevator Disaster: In 1904, an open elevator carrying four workers and 200 gallons of hydrochloric acid in glass jars plunges five stories at a NYC soap factory. The men survive the fall but die agonizingly from acid burns while trapped in the basement rubble.

•

21:37 — Mike Labazzo's Sinkhole Death: DEA agent Mike Labazzo hears a strange sound in his backyard on Labor Day 2001 and goes to investigate, fearing criminal retaliation. He falls into a 25-foot sinkhole caused by a collapsed sewage tank drained the day before; his body is recovered 18 hours later.

Speakers

•

Narrator — Host

⋮