TLDR
This episode recounts three workplace-related tragedies where ordinary days turned catastrophic. Jim Donnelly vanished from a New Zealand steel mill in 2004, his belongings later found staged in an acid vat too weak to dissolve a body. In 1904, four soap factory workers survived an elevator plunge only to be killed by hydrochloric acid from shattered jars. In 2001, DEA agent Mike Labazzo died in a backyard sinkhole caused by a collapsed sewage tank, not the criminal retaliation he feared. All three cases subvert initial assumptions about what happened.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The acid vat where Jim Donnelly's belongings were found had been searched multiple times by teams and was in a high-traffic area, yet his bright yellow named hard hat appeared there days later as if placed deliberately.
The hydrochloric acid that killed the soap factory workers was being transported in glass jars — not modern safety containers — on an open elevator with no shaft enclosure.
Mike Labazzo, a federal agent trained to anticipate threats, died from a mundane infrastructure failure (a sewage tank collapse) rather than the criminal retaliation he constantly feared.
In all three stories, the initial theories (Jim fell in acid, elevator fall killed workers, Mike was targeted by criminals) were proven wrong by evidence discovered afterward.
Key takeaways
Jim Donnelly arrived at work normally but missed a 9:00 a.m. meeting; his car remained in the lot but he was nowhere in the 2-square-mile mill, and his wife noted he had been sleep-deprived and acting strangely after a secretive meeting days earlier.
Five days after Jim's disappearance, a supervisor found his named hard hat floating conspicuously atop an acid vat in a heavily trafficked area that had been searched repeatedly, suggesting the items were staged after the initial searches.
The acid in the vat was too weak to dissolve a human body — only strong enough to remove rust — and no human remains were found, contradicting the theory that Jim fell in and dissolved.
At the Babbitt Soap Factory in 1904, an open elevator car carrying four workers and 200 gallons of hydrochloric acid in glass jars plummeted five stories; the men survived the impact but the jars shattered, spraying acid that melted their skin and eyes as they lay trapped in rubble.
The elevator had no enclosed shaft or safety mechanisms that functioned; the accident occurred in plain view of the entire factory floor, and the victims' screams alerted everyone to the horror unfolding in the basement.
Mike Labazzo, a DEA agent accustomed to danger, heard a groaning sound from his backyard on Labor Day 2001 and went to investigate, fearing retaliation from criminals he had prosecuted.
The sound came from a massive sinkhole formed when a sewage tank drainage the day before caused the aged tank to collapse, creating a 25-foot-deep pit; the grass crust gave way under Mike's weight, dropping him into concrete and sewage.
Mike's body took 18 hours to recover; his wife found their children unattended on the couch, unaware their father had stepped outside moments earlier and never returned.
Notable quotes
“where is Jim?”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:14“they experienced a far worse fate than anyone could have imagined after the crash stopped”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:31“their skin is being melted off the bone”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:47“he would die from this accident. It would take 18 hours for rescue workers to finally recover his body”
▸ Notable quotes · 26:37“the acid that had been in there was relatively weak and couldn't actually dissolve much of anything aside from rust”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:51“somebody would have noticed it. So, now it seemed entirely possible that someone had actually staged the hard hat”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:47Chapters
0:55 — Jim Donnelly's Disappearance: Jim Donnelly vanishes from Glenbrook Steel Mill in New Zealand after arriving normally; his car stays parked but he misses a meeting. Days later, his hard hat and belongings are found in an acid vat in a heavily searched area, but the acid is too weak to dissolve a body, suggesting staging.
15:21 — SNHU Advertisement: Sponsor message for Southern New Hampshire University promoting online degree programs.
16:05 — Babbitt Soap Factory Elevator Disaster: In 1904, an open elevator carrying four workers and 200 gallons of hydrochloric acid in glass jars plunges five stories at a NYC soap factory. The men survive the fall but die agonizingly from acid burns while trapped in the basement rubble.
21:37 — Mike Labazzo's Sinkhole Death: DEA agent Mike Labazzo hears a strange sound in his backyard on Labor Day 2001 and goes to investigate, fearing criminal retaliation. He falls into a 25-foot sinkhole caused by a collapsed sewage tank drained the day before; his body is recovered 18 hours later.
Speakers
Narrator — Host