Sandra Birchmore: Cop’s Alter Ego ‘Joey’, Mistresses, & Bombshell DNA

Original Media · 55m · English · YouTube · Ashleigh Banfield x Drop Dead Serious

TLDR

This episode covers the federal murder trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, accused of killing Sandra Birchmore — a young woman he groomed from age 12 in the Police Explorers program and began a sexual relationship with at 15. New courtroom revelations include DNA evidence linking Farwell to the ligature used in her staged hanging, testimony from the baby's biological father (who knew of the underage relationship but stayed silent), three other mistresses detailing Farwell's pattern of affairs, and disturbing text messages revealing rape fantasies and role-play. The original investigation ruled her death a suicide despite anomalous crime scene details.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The biological father (Jason Picard) knew Birchmore was a minor when the relationship with Farwell began but did not report it, citing fear for his marriage and career.

•

Farwell and Birchmore engaged in a role-play where he pretended to be a character named 'Joey' and she had to beg 'Joey' not to tell 'Matt' — effectively role-playing concealment of their own relationship.

•

Multiple Stoughton police officers testified they knew Birchmore well from the station but claimed no knowledge of any inappropriate relationships until after her death.

•

The crime scene necklace (flamingo pendant) was found clumped on the floor weeks later by family, with hair clumps in it — suggesting a struggle, but it was not preserved by investigators.

•

Farwell's wife has not appeared in court despite her name being mentioned repeatedly; no divorce records found.

•

The seated, hands-free hanging from a door handle — 18 inches off the ground — was initially ruled a suicide by local police, despite being highly atypical.

Key takeaways

•

Matthew Farwell met Sandra Birchmore at 12 through the Police Explorers program; sexual relationship began when she was 15 (he was 24).

•

Farwell is charged with killing a witness (statutory rape victim), not the statutory rape itself — federal prosecutors allege he murdered her to silence her.

•

DNA testing found Farwell's DNA on the ligature strap around Birchmore's neck; both Farwell's and Jason Picard's (biological father) DNA were in her underwear.

•

Birchmore's hyoid bone was broken — a finding more consistent with manual strangulation than hanging, per prosecution's upcoming expert.

•

Jason Picard (Army recruiter, married) testified under immunity that Birchmore told him the relationship started when she was a minor; he did not report it.

•

Three other mistresses testified: none experienced masks, disguises, or requests to delete messages — contradicting Farwell's behavior with Birchmore.

•

Initial responding officers (including a school resource officer) treated the seated, hands-free hanging as suicide; critical evidence (closet doorknob, carabiner, hair/fibers) was never tested.

•

Farwell texted colleagues 'anything going on at the station?' while stuck at hospital during wife's C-section the day after Birchmore died — prosecution suggests he was checking if body was found.

•

Farwell's twin brother Billy (also a Stoughton officer) allegedly had a sexual relationship with Birchmore and is set to testify next week.

•

Federal conviction rate exceeds 95%; host assesses case against Farwell as extremely strong despite defense arguments about DNA transfer and rough sex.

Notable quotes

“this little kid, an honest-to-god baby-faced little cherub kid, was so targeted by adult men for so long”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:16

“he is accused of murdering Sandra Birchmore cuz she was pregnant, and he figured it was his baby”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:42

“Sandra told him that her sexual relationship with Matthew Farwell began when she was a kid. A minor. And he didn't report it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:48

“That originally Matthew Farwell's police colleague said, 'Nothing to see here. It's just a suicide.' Yeah, well, Matthew Farwell's DNA is on the strap.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:33

“Often, they would talk about rape fantasy sex and um like there were many multiple texts where Matthew Farwell was like, 'Can we do that again? That was so great. It felt like the R word.' The R word being rape.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:54

“where Farwell would be a character named Joey and he would like enter her apartment as Joey and make her call him Joey and they would have these sexual interactions as Joey and she would like have to beg Joey not to tell Matt”

▸ Notable quotes · 15:38

“multiple discussions about how they both wished they had done it sooner... Matthew Farwell says to her on multiple occasions I wish we had started this back at the library which is when he was tutoring her when she was a student in the Stoughton Police Explorers program before they began that sexual relationship so maybe she was 15 maybe she was 14 at the time”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:40

“he's not just flat out charged with the murder. He's charged with killing a witness and the witness the theory is that Sandra Birchmore is a witness to his crimes of statutory rape.”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:26

“I audibly gasped. And then I like looked around because I was like, did I just like did I just imagine that?”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:51

“their argument is not going to be necessarily that, you know, he was so covered up his DNA didn't get on her, it's that they had rough sex all the time... And if they had this kind of interaction where maybe he was choking her and it was part of a sexual encounter, she wouldn't find it unusual and it only takes 8 seconds for someone to pass out, so maybe she wouldn't have fought back. That's their theory of the case.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:06

“her never doing anything to suggest a sign of life after he leaves her apartment.”

▸ Notable quotes · 39:24

“And her hyoid bone was broken?”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:30

“as soon as many of them heard about this relationship, the alarm bells went off.”

▸ Notable quotes · 41:19

“he's texting them like, 'Hey man, anything going on at the station? Like anything going on? I'm just so bored here. I'm stuck here because of COVID.'”

▸ Notable quotes · 47:30

“These feds never lose. I mean, I think they got like a 95% conviction rate.”

▸ Notable quotes · 51:13

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Case Overview: Host Ashley Banfield introduces the Sandra Birchmore case: a young woman groomed from age 12 in the Stoughton Police Explorers program, sexually involved with Officer Matthew Farwell from 15, found dead in a staged hanging while pregnant. Farwell now on federal trial for murder.

•

3:39 — Jason Picard Testimony & Paternity Revelation: Biological father Jason Picard (Army recruiter, married) testifies under immunity: Birchmore told him relationship with Farwell began when she was a minor; he did not report it. DNA confirmed Picard, not Farwell, was the baby's father — but Farwell believed it was his, providing motive.

•

5:17 — Three Mistresses Testify About Affairs: Three women who had affairs with Farwell testify: none experienced masks, disguises, or requests to delete messages — contrasting with Farwell's behavior with Birchmore (wore mask night she died, asked her to delete messages). One mistress was a former Explorer.

•

6:18 — DNA Evidence on Ligature & Underwear: Forensic scientist testifies: Farwell's DNA on ligature strap around Birchmore's neck; both Farwell's and Picard's DNA in her underwear. No Farwell DNA under her fingernails (defense point). Defense argues DNA transfer from consensual contact; cannot determine timing.

•

8:14 — Crime Scene Investigation Failures: Critical evidence untested: closet doorknob, carabiner, hair/fibers from strap. Initial responders (school resource officer) ruled suicide despite anomalous seated, hands-free hanging. Two officers raised concerns but were overruled.

•

9:43 — Interview with Christina Rex Begins: WBZ reporter Christina Rex joins — the only media eyes in the federal courtroom (no cameras). Describes case as showing a vulnerable woman targeted by powerful men who abused authority or turned blind eye.

•

10:45 — Courtroom Dynamics & Farwell's Demeanor: Farwell sits between lawyers, 6-8 feet from witnesses. Shows minimal reaction: head down, pen in hand, rarely looks at witnesses. Wife not present; no family support visible. Jury: 10 men, 6 women, mostly white, wide age range, highly engaged.

•

13:46 — Disturbing Text Messages Revealed: Years of explicit texts read in court: rape fantasies, choking discussions, role-play where Farwell becomes 'Joey' and Birchmore must beg 'Joey' not to tell 'Matt.' Messages too graphic for TV broadcast.

•

16:13 — Underage Relationship & Statutory Rape Context: Texts reveal both wished they'd started sexual relationship sooner — back when Farwell tutored her at 14-15 in Explorers program. Farwell not charged with statutory rape (state didn't pursue; federal case supersedes), but it underlies witness-killing charge.

•

22:02 — Crime Scene Photos & Hanging Anomalies: Accidental flash of extreme close-up of Birchmore's face during cross-examination shocks courtroom. Jury will see photos in deliberations. Seated hanging with hands free, shirt raised — highly inconsistent with suicide.

•

30:58 — Necklace Evidence & Hyoid Bone: Flamingo necklace found clumped on floor weeks later by family with hair in it — suggests struggle. Medical examiner and independent expert to testify: hyoid bone broken (more consistent with strangulation than hanging in young person).

•

36:10 — Farwell's Behavior Before/After Death: Birchmore texted Farwell he'd done a '180' — brought ginger ale, acted nice but weirdly searched her bathroom and closet (possibly assessing hanging points). Day after her death, Farwell texted colleagues from wife's C-section: 'anything going on at the station?' — prosecution suggests checking if body found.

•

41:59 — Billy Farwell & Other Officers: Farwell's twin brother Billy (also Stoughton officer) allegedly had sexual relationship with Birchmore; set to testify next week. Multiple Stoughton officers testify they knew Birchmore but claim no knowledge of relationships until after death — 'greatest kept secret or not a secret.'

•

45:16 — Mistresses' Testimony Details: Three mistresses: one worked at Stoughton PD, one lifelong friend of Farwell and wife, one former Explorer (affair at 22). All consenting adults but carry shame. Host suggests more victims likely given pattern starting with minor.

•

46:58 — Farwell's Texts During Wife's C-Section: Farwell stuck at hospital due to COVID during wife's scheduled C-section (day after Birchmore died, body not yet found). Texted colleagues about station activity, not baby — prosecution argues he was monitoring for discovery of his crime.

•

49:26 — Jury Observations & Case Assessment: Jury highly engaged, taking notes, no visible emotional reactions. Federal trial run with high efficiency. Host predicts conviction: 95%+ federal conviction rate, overwhelming evidence. Farwell didn't plea — likely no deal acceptable given severity.

Speakers

•

Ashley Banfield — Host

•

Christina Rex — Guest Reporter

•

Matthew Farwell — Defendant

•

Sandra Birchmore — Victim

•

Jason Picard — Witness

•

Billy Farwell — Upcoming Witness

⋮