TLDR
A measles outbreak in Pennsylvania's Lancaster County has caused over 1,500 cases and six deaths, including two babies, making it the nation's worst in decades. Vaccination rates have fallen to 87.6%, below the 95% herd immunity threshold, and midwife Deborah Devers has seen dozens of pregnant women infected with several miscarriages. State law bars traditional midwives from administering vaccines despite Amish families now seeking them, while misinformation from a 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. speech fueled hesitancy; the U.S. may lose its measles elimination status this week. Three-quarters of U.S. counties now fall below the 95% vaccination threshold needed to prevent outbreaks. Pediatricians describe devastating, entirely preventable cases of babies gasping for air and on ventilators.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Midwives who have trusted, long-term relationships with Amish families and make house calls — "boots on the ground" — are legally barred from administering vaccines even during a deadly outbreak.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. gave a speech in the exact area now hardest hit by measles in 2021, claiming without evidence that vaccines are harmful, directly influencing vaccine hesitancy in the community.
After experiencing the outbreak firsthand, some Amish community members are now actively seeking vaccination from their midwife, reversing previous refusal.
The U.S. could lose its measles elimination status this week, a reversal of a public health achievement that stood for over two decades.
Pennsylvania's health department acknowledges it lacks authority to allow midwives to vaccinate, yet has distributed over 10,000 doses — highlighting a systemic mismatch between vaccine supply and delivery to the most affected populations.
Key takeaways
Lancaster County, Pennsylvania is experiencing the nation's worst measles outbreak in decades with over 1,500 cases and six deaths including two babies, driven by vaccination rates that have fallen from 94% in 2019 to 87.6% today.
Midwife Deborah Devers serves a community where half her clients are Amish and largely unvaccinated; she has seen dozens of pregnant women contract measles in recent months, with some pregnancies ending in miscarriage.
Pediatrician Evan Shirey in nearby Hershey describes devastating, entirely preventable cases: babies gasping for air, children needing oxygen and respiratory support, patients on ventilators, and infants unable to take bottles.
Misinformation about vaccine safety has spread nationwide, amplified by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s 2021 speech in the area claiming without evidence that the shots are harmful, which influenced some community members' decisions not to vaccinate.
Some Amish community members are now actively asking Devers to vaccinate them after witnessing the outbreak's severity, with one mother stating "He got it wrong. Measles are not not dangerous."
Pennsylvania law prohibits traditional midwives who work outside hospitals from administering vaccines, classifying it as practicing medicine; the state health department says only the legislature can change this, despite having distributed over 10,000 vaccines since April.
Clinics offering vaccines are not easily accessible for Amish families who rely on horse-and-buggy transportation and home births, creating a critical access gap that midwives could fill if legally permitted.
The United States may lose its measles elimination status as soon as this week, with the Pan American Health Organization meeting behind closed doors to deliver a decision by Friday; three-quarters of U.S. counties now fall below the 95% vaccination threshold needed to prevent outbreaks.
Notable quotes
“EVERY SINGLE DAY.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:47“THERE WAS NO DOUBT IN MY MIND THAT IT WAS MEASLES. TWO WEEKS EARLIER, SHE HAD GOTTEN THE MEASLES AND THEN MISCARRIED.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:04“BABIES GASPING FOR AIR, CHILDREN NEEDING OXYGEN AND RESPIRATORY SUPPORT, PATIENTS ON VENTILATORS, BABIES THAT CAN'T TAKE BOTTLES.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:20“THIS IS ENTIRELY PREVENTABLE.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:26“HE GOT IT WRONG. MEASLES ARE NOT NOT DANGEROUS.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:01“WITHOUT A DOUBT. WE WERE BOOTS ON THE GROUND.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:56Chapters
0:07 — Outbreak Overview: Pennsylvania's Lancaster County faces the nation's worst measles outbreak in decades with over 1,500 cases and six deaths including two babies, as vaccination rates drop below the herd immunity threshold.
1:01 — Midwife Deborah Devers' Work: Midwife Deborah Devers makes house calls across rural Lancaster County for prenatal appointments, serving a community where many pregnant women have contracted measles during the outbreak.
1:50 — Amish Community Impact: Half of Devers' clients are Amish and largely unvaccinated; the community has been hit hard by the outbreak, with families now experiencing measles daily.
2:02 — Pregnant Women and Miscarriages: Devers has seen dozens of pregnant women with measles in recent months, including cases where measles infection was followed by miscarriage, confirming the virus's danger in pregnancy.
2:13 — Pediatrician's Perspective: Dr. Evan Shirey in Hershey describes devastating pediatric cases — babies gasping for air, on ventilators, unable to eat — emphasizing that every case is entirely preventable through vaccination.
2:37 — Misinformation and RFK Jr.: Vaccine misinformation spread nationwide, amplified by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s 2021 speech in the area claiming without evidence that measles shots are harmful, influencing community hesitancy.
3:23 — Legal Barriers for Midwives: Pennsylvania law prohibits traditional midwives from administering vaccines; Devers cannot vaccinate willing Amish patients despite being their trusted provider, and the health department says only the legislature can change this.
4:41 — Potential Loss of Elimination Status: The Pan American Health Organization is meeting this week to decide whether the U.S. will lose its measles elimination status, with a decision expected by Friday; three-quarters of U.S. counties now fall below the 95% vaccination threshold.
Speakers
Anchor — News anchor
Erika Edwards — NBC News medical reporter
Deborah Devers — Traditional midwife
Hannah Garman — Amish client
Dr. Evan Shirey — Pediatrician
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. — Anti-vaccine activist