TLDR
In a Dino Week special, Shayne hosts Trevor and Tommy as they explore ancient Reddit stories from the platform's 'museum.' They cover the first-ever AITA post (a 2013 office thermostat dispute), a lockdown-era TIFU about a girlfriend burying beans in the woods, the legendary AskReddit comment 'I also choose this guy's dead wife,' an AITA post about a woman dating her ex's father and clearing out his childhood room, a 2014 r/GrilledCheese purist meltdown, a teacher's saga of 'Kevin' the bafflingly incompetent student, a LegalAdvice mystery solved by carbon monoxide poisoning, and a wholesome list of reasons a wife cries. The hosts react with humor, disbelief, and occasional genuine emotion.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The first AITA post was a reasonable office dispute, not the outrageous validation-seeking posts that dominate the subreddit today.
The 'I also choose this guy's dead wife' comment has 10,000 more upvotes than the grieving widower's original heartfelt comment.
The woman dating her ex's father cleared out his childhood room during lockdown and couldn't understand why he was upset.
The grilled cheese purist had been a Reddit lurker for three years before creating an account solely to post his manifesto.
Kevin the student's mother couldn't remember which school he attended and drove to wrong schools for meetings.
The Post-it note mystery was solved by Reddit commenters diagnosing carbon monoxide poisoning before the poster realized they had a detector still in its box.
Key takeaways
The first AITA post in 2013 was a mundane office thermostat dispute between men in suits and women wanting warmer temperatures, reflecting the subreddit's original purpose of genuine moral ambiguity rather than validation-seeking.
During early COVID lockdowns, a woman buried 30 cans of beans in the woods behind her apartment complex to protect them from hypothetical looters, leading her boyfriend to demand their location and ultimately causing their breakup.
The most famous Reddit comment of all time — 'I also choose this guy's dead wife' — was a cruel but perfectly timed joke on a grieving widower's earnest answer; the widower later confirmed he found it funny and his wife would have approved.
A woman moved in with her ex-boyfriend's father during lockdown, cleared out her ex's childhood room, boxed his belongings to the garage, and gave him a year to retrieve them before donating everything — universally condemned as monstrous behavior.
A 2014 r/GrilledCheese post by a self-described 'bland white Midwestern male' erupted in rage over 'melts' being mislabeled as grilled cheeses, sparking a subreddit schism and the creation of r/Melts the same day.
A teacher's 2014 AskReddit answer about 'Kevin,' a ninth-grade student who ate crayons, tried to spend tuition checks at 7-Eleven, tased himself, didn't know dogs and cats were different animals, and finished with a 3% average, became legendary for its escalating absurdity.
A LegalAdvice poster discovered mysterious Post-it notes in their apartment written in their own handwriting; Reddit users correctly diagnosed carbon monoxide poisoning (100 PPM), potentially saving the poster's life.
A husband's 2023 list of reasons his wife cries includes 'swans can be gay' (twice), a piglet photo while hungover, a bunny escaping a fox, no biscuits in the house, and him cooking her dinner — all treated as equally valid emotional triggers.
Notable quotes
“I also choose this guy's dead wife.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:15“I'm not a religious man, nor am I anything close to a culinary expert, but as a bland white Midwestern male, I am honestly the most passionate person when it comes to grilled cheese and mac and cheese.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:36“Kevin ate an entire 24 pack of crayons, puked, and then did it again the next day.”
▸ Notable quotes · 43:00“Kevin kept a bottle of orange Kool-Aid in his backpack for about four months. He thought it would turn into alcohol.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:31“Guess I should probably take that out of its box and plug it in.”
▸ Notable quotes · 60:16“She found out swans can be gay and thought it was really nice.”
▸ Notable quotes · 64:45Chapters
0:00 — First AITA Post & Bean Burial: Shayne introduces Dino Week with Trevor and Tommy as cavemen. They discuss the first AITA post (2013 thermostat dispute) and a 2020 TIFU where a girlfriend buried 30 cans of beans in the woods during lockdown, causing a breakup.
15:19 — Ultimate Lay AskReddit Thread: The hosts read the legendary 2016 AskReddit thread 'Who's your ultimate lay from history?' featuring the famous comment 'I also choose this guy's dead wife' and the widower's gracious response years later.
21:09 — Ex's Dad AITA & Grilled Cheese Purist: A 2020 AITA post about a woman dating her ex's father and clearing out his childhood room horrifies the hosts. Then a 2014 r/GrilledCheese purist's manifesto against 'melts' sparks debate about sandwich taxonomy.
41:14 — Saga of Kevin the Student: A teacher's 2014 AskReddit answer details 'Kevin,' a ninth-grader with baffling incompetence: eating crayons, trying to spend tuition checks at 7-Eleven, tasing himself, not knowing dogs and cats are different animals, and finishing with a 3% average.
55:04 — Carbon Monoxide Post-it Mystery: A 2015 LegalAdvice post about mysterious Post-it notes in an apartment is solved when Reddit users diagnose carbon monoxide poisoning (100 PPM); the poster had a detector still in its box.
64:24 — Wife's Crying List: A 2023 r/Funny post shows a husband's notebook listing reasons his wife cries, including 'swans can be gay' (twice), a piglet photo while hungover, a bunny escaping a fox, no biscuits, and him cooking dinner.
Speakers
Shayne — Host
Trevor — Guest
Tommy — Guest