Post Game: Can JD Vance clear primary field in 2028?

Original Media · 10m · English · YouTube · NBC News

TLDR

In this Postgame episode, panelists Carol, Carlos, and Steve Rashetti analyze former Vice President Mike Pence's call for Republicans to return to conservative principles and distance themselves from Trump's second-term policies, while also discussing Senator-elect Scott Colom's moderate Democratic platform and a broader Southern strategy for Democrats ahead of 2028. Pence declined to endorse JD Vance, criticized the administration's China and Iran policies, and raised corruption concerns about Trump's sons. The panel debates whether Marco Rubio could rebuild the 2024 coalition better than Vance, and whether Democrats' recent Southern wins signal a shift toward broader, more ideologically diverse coalitions.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Mike Pence explicitly criticized Trump's sons for creating an 'air of corruption' — a rare direct rebuke from a former vice president of a sitting president's family.

•

The panel agrees JD Vance may not clear the 2028 Republican field, despite being the sitting vice president, with Carlos suggesting Rubio is the establishment's preferred alternative.

•

Steve Rashetti, a Democratic strategist, predicts 15-25 Democratic primary candidates in 2028 — far more than the 2020 field — and frames a crowded primary as a strength, not a weakness.

Key takeaways

•

Mike Pence sharply criticized the Trump administration's second-term policies on China, Iran, and corruption — specifically naming Trump's sons — and declined to endorse JD Vance as the 2028 standard-bearer, signaling a potential establishment-primary challenge.

•

Carlos argues Republicans fear a 2006/2008-style collapse and see Marco Rubio, not Vance, as best positioned to rebuild the coalition by recovering Hispanic and suburban voters.

•

Steve Rashetti predicts unusually large primary fields for both parties in 2028 — 15 to 25 Democratic candidates — and urges Democrats to compete in every state rather than ceding territory to pollsters.

•

Senator-elect Scott Colom of Mississippi represents a wave of moderate Democrats winning in the South who reject Medicare for All, support private insurance, and prioritize affordability and bipartisan dealmaking.

•

Democrats have recently won Senate and gubernatorial races across the South (Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina, Mississippi, Kansas, Iowa, Alaska), suggesting a viable Southern strategy built on economic pragmatism.

•

Carlos notes both parties have spent two decades purging ideological dissenters — Democrats purged pro-life members, Republicans purged pro-choice members — which is unsustainable in a two-party system.

•

Steve highlights permitting reform in the lame-duck session as a key test of whether bipartisan collaboration on affordability is possible in the next Congress.

Notable quotes

“Vance is wrong. We we were not voted out because of the war with Iran. We're voted out because we didn't finish it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:39

“These aren't the policies that that we had supported. Um and then he talked about corruption where he said this air of corruption um and specifically mentioned the Trump sons um which was really fascinating”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:24

“I definitely don't think that Vice President Vance can clear the field. I think if anyone can do that, and there are Republicans in Congress asking him to, it's Marco Rubio”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:57

“I expect that there will be 15, 20, 25 candidates on our side. And I think that's a good thing.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:43

“If we had 10 parties, it could work, but it doesn't work. Now, uh, something to watch, I think, in the lame duck is permitting reform.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:46

“we'll work with anyone to address the affordability issues that our constituents, our voters, our citizens said are front and center for them, including working, as we discussed earlier, with President Trump.”

▸ Notable quotes · 8:08

Chapters

•

0:11 — Mike Pence's critique of Trump administration: Pence calls for return to conservative principles, declines to endorse Vance for 2028, criticizes Iran and China policies, and raises corruption concerns about Trump's sons.

•

2:17 — Republican 2028 field and Rubio vs. Vance: Carlos argues Republicans fear a 2006/2008 repeat and see Marco Rubio as better positioned than Vance to rebuild the coalition with Hispanic and suburban voters.

•

3:32 — Democratic 2028 strategy and primary expectations: Steve predicts a large Democratic primary field (15-25 candidates) and urges competing in every state rather than following pollster-driven resource allocation.

•

5:27 — Scott Colom and moderate Southern Democrats: Mississippi Senator-elect Colom rejects Medicare for All, supports private insurance, and represents a wave of moderate Democrats winning in the South.

•

7:30 — Southern strategy and bipartisan potential: Steve details Democratic wins across the South and a pragmatic affordability-focused approach; Carlos notes both parties have purged moderates unsustainably; Steve flags permitting reform as a bipartisan test.

Speakers

•

Host — Moderator

•

Carol — Analyst

•

Carlos — Analyst

•

Steve Rashetti — Analyst

⋮