Judge Glanville is out! Where the Young Thug Trial goes from here! The Emily Show Ep 294

Original Media · 51m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

A Georgia judge has been removed from the Young Thug YSL RICO case after improperly defending himself against recusal motions instead of referring them to another judge as required by law. The recusal motions stemmed from an ex parte meeting in the judge's chambers with prosecutors and a witness, which defense attorneys were excluded from. The new ruling grants recusal based solely on the judge's post-meeting conduct, not the meeting itself, and the case will be randomly reassigned — though practical challenges loom after 11 months of jury selection and 9+ months of trial.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The judge who ruled on the recusal motions explicitly stated he had 'no doubt that Judge Glanville can and would continue presiding fairly' — yet still removed him solely for procedural violations in handling the motions.

•

The DA's office told witness Copeland he would remain in custody until the conclusion of trials for all 28 defendants — potentially years beyond 2025 — as leverage to compel testimony.

•

Judge Glanville reviewed surveillance footage of his own chambers for 'timeline and security' after learning Steel knew about the meeting, effectively investigating how his own ex parte proceeding was discovered.

Key takeaways

•

Judge Glanville held an ex parte meeting in chambers on June 10 with prosecutors, witness Kenneth Copeland, and Copeland's attorney to pressure Copeland to testify after he invoked the Fifth Amendment; defense counsel were not notified or present.

•

When defense attorney Brian Steel learned of the meeting and objected, Judge Glanville immediately held him in contempt for refusing to reveal his source, then issued a show cause order threatening contempt against everyone at the meeting for disclosing it to the defense.

•

Three recusal motions were filed. Judge Glanville initially denied one, ruling the affidavit legally insufficient because there was 'no actual evidence of the extent of the discussion' — despite acknowledging the motion was timely and supported by affidavit.

•

Under Georgia's Uniform Superior Court Rule 25 and the judicial conduct code, once a recusal motion meets three threshold criteria (timely, supported by affidavit, facts that might warrant recusal), the judge 'shall' refer it to another judge and 'may not oppose the motion.'

•

Judge Glanville violated this mandate by making a record on July 1 defending his actions, evaluating his own factual allegations, and arguing the ex parte meeting was proper — conduct that itself mandated recusal.

•

The new judge's order grants recusal on narrow grounds: not because the ex parte meeting was improper (the order says it 'perhaps should have' been in open court but was not 'inherently improper'), but because Judge Glanville defended himself against the recusal motions.

•

The case will be randomly reassigned to a new judge, but the practical hurdles are immense: 11 months of jury selection, 9+ months of trial testimony, and a sworn jury that cannot easily be kept sequestered during a lengthy transition.

•

The defense is expected to file new motions seeking dismissal with prejudice or a mistrial, arguing a new judge cannot fairly preside without mastering the massive record.

Notable quotes

“shall means must do it it's not discretionary when it is a shall when it is a shall you shall you must another judge must be assigned”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:02

“the judge whose recusal is sought may not respond to the motion or attempt to refute the allegation which stand denied automatically no matter how false or even defamatory the judge might know or perceive the allegations to be”

▸ Notable quotes · 30:21

“his efforts at defending himself against a motion to recuse will inevitably create an appearance of partiality one reason is that if he defends himself he becomes an adversary of the movement for recusal”

▸ Notable quotes · 31:20

“this court has no doubt that judge Glenville can and would continue presiding fairly over this matter if the recusal Motions were denied but the necessity of preserving the public's confidence in the judicial system weighs in favor of excusing Judge Glenville”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:47

“the way he handled the recusals mandates he be recused”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:42

Chapters

•

4:00 — Case background and ex parte meeting: The Young Thug YSL RICO case, paused since June, involved an ex parte meeting in Judge Glanville's chambers on June 10 with prosecutors, witness Kenneth Copeland, and Copeland's attorney to pressure Copeland to testify after he invoked the Fifth Amendment; defense attorneys were excluded and unaware.

•

15:00 — Contempt and show cause orders: When defense attorney Brian Steel objected to the ex parte meeting, Judge Glanville held him in contempt for refusing to reveal his source, then issued a show cause order threatening contempt against all meeting participants for disclosing it to the defense.

•

17:10 — Recusal motions filed and initially denied: Three recusal motions were filed (by Kendrick, Bumpus, and Williams). Judge Glanville denied Kendrick's motion, ruling the affidavit legally insufficient despite acknowledging it was timely and supported by affidavit, because there was 'no actual evidence of the extent of the discussion.'

•

25:00 — Legal framework for recusal: Georgia's Uniform Superior Court Rule 25 and judicial conduct code require that once a recusal motion meets three threshold criteria, the judge 'shall' refer it to another judge and 'may not oppose the motion' — mandatory, not discretionary.

•

32:30 — Judge Glanville's improper defense: Judge Glanville violated the mandate by making a record on July 1 defending his actions, evaluating his own factual allegations, and arguing the ex parte meeting was proper — conduct that case law says 'inevitably creates an appearance of partiality.'

•

37:30 — Recusal granted on narrow grounds: The new judge granted recusal solely because Judge Glanville defended himself against the motions, not because the ex parte meeting was improper (which the order says 'perhaps should have' been in open court but was not 'inherently improper').

•

40:30 — Practical challenges and next steps: The case will be randomly reassigned, but a new judge faces immense hurdles: 11 months of jury selection, 9+ months of trial, and a sworn jury. Defense is expected to seek dismissal with prejudice or mistrial.

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host

⋮