TLDR
This episode covers the case of Devon Young, who was 17 when he allegedly murdered paddleboarder Sunshine Stewart in Maine in July 2025. Young, vacationing with his family at the same campsite, was arrested after acting suspiciously helpful during the investigation. Now 19, he has waived a hearing and will be tried as an adult, facing a potential life sentence. Newly obtained 2023 body camera audio reveals his parents describing his bipolar disorder, medication non-compliance, and violent outbursts.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The alleged killer actively inserted himself into the search, even taking investigators onto the water in the wrong direction.
Young maintained an apparently normal social-media presence ('doing well') just days after the brutal killing.
His parents casually described him as both 'the sweetest, nicest kid' and a 'crazy little psycho' depending on medication adherence.
Maine's mental-health system had a three-year waitlist for in-home services, leaving a volatile teenager without support.
Key takeaways
Devon Young, 17 at the time, is accused of strangling and bludgeoning Sunshine Stewart at a Maine campsite in July 2025.
Young waived his right to a juvenile transfer hearing; the case will proceed in adult court where he faces life in prison if convicted.
During the manhunt, Young repeatedly offered to help police and allegedly led them on a 'wild goose chase' away from where Stewart's body was found.
Days after the murder, Young posted on Facebook that he was 'doing well,' presenting a normal vacation persona.
2023 body-cam audio captures Young's parents telling a deputy he has bipolar disorder, goes off medication, and becomes a 'crazy little psycho.'
The parents said Young was on a three-year waitlist for state in-home mental-health services but never received them.
Former prosecutor Dan Shore says the waiver was likely strategic to preserve plea-bargain leverage and avoid a damaging hearing.
Shore notes that motive is not required for a murder conviction; the prolonged nature of strangulation plus blunt-force trauma demonstrates intent.
Notable quotes
“He has bad spells because medication ain't on board.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:31“He's the sweetest, nicest kid you'll ever meet in life. And then he's like a crazy little psycho.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:48“Sometimes that shows a consciousness of guilt because if someone seems to know where to look or not to look, then that implies that they had some knowledge of the crime.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:08“For most people, they wouldn't be able to commit a crime like that in the first place. So once someone does that, it's not shocking that someone who did that would then try to take the minimal effort to cover up their intent.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:19“Strangulation is something that doesn't happen instantly. It takes time to strangle someone. Blunt force trauma is another separate act that led to the death of this victim here. So that all that type of crime is a very intentional crime.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:18Chapters
0:00 — Case Introduction and Victim Profile: Host Chris Cuomo introduces the update on Devon Young's case and profiles victim Sunshine Stewart, a Maine native and outdoor enthusiast staying at the Mic Mac campsite on Crawford Pond.
1:02 — The Crime and Investigation: Details the night Stewart disappeared paddleboarding, the discovery of her body with strangulation and blunt-force trauma, and the two-week investigation that zeroed in on Young after he acted suspiciously helpful and allegedly misdirected searchers.
6:00 — 2023 Body-Cam Audio: Prior Behavioral Issues: Audio from a Waldo County deputy's visit to Young's home reveals his parents discussing his bipolar diagnosis, medication non-compliance, violent outbursts, and a three-year wait for state services.
8:00 — Legal Analysis with Former Prosecutor Dan Shore: Shore explains why waiving the juvenile transfer hearing was likely strategic, discusses how Young's cooperation with police may show consciousness of guilt, and analyzes how mental-health history could affect competency, guilt phase, and sentencing.
18:00 — Prosecution Strategy and Trial Outlook: Shore outlines the prosecutor's current focus on evidence gathering and discovery compliance, notes Young will likely serve any sentence in an adult facility, and clarifies that motive is not required to prove intentional murder given the nature of the injuries.
Speakers
Chris Cuomo — Host
Dan Shore — Legal Analyst
Deputy (Waldo County) — Law Enforcement
Devon's Father — Parent
Devon's Mother — Parent