1st Day on Earth! Ft. Direct_Caterpillar77 || Reddit Stories || Two Hot Takes

Original Media · 2h 11m · English · YouTube · Two Hot Takes

TLDR

The hosts discuss six Reddit stories under the theme 'First Day on Earth,' featuring people displaying baffling lack of awareness: a man feeling deceived by his girlfriend's cystic acne, a boyfriend biting into a tamarind seed and blaming his girlfriend, a fiancé refusing to accompany his distressed partner to the bathroom during a 3-hour movie, a husband revealing a 10-year affair while arguing about their cat, a couple demanding guests buy $150-500 puppets for their wedding, a new grad refusing to give up a decorated office to a returning maternity-leave coworker, and a groom using AI to write vows causing his bride to walk out mid-ceremony. The episode includes a guest appearance by Reddit curator Matt (Direct Caterpillar) who shares his story-finding process.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts and guest Matt genuinely enjoyed the puppet wedding concept and would attend, contrasting with near-universal Reddit condemnation of the couple's demands.

•

The flooded causeway story's update revealed the friend had forged a lawyer's letterhead — a criminal act — yet the OP's lawyer advised no further action needed after the friend admitted it.

•

The AI vows groom received overwhelmingly hostile Reddit comments calling him 'malicious' and 'worthless scum,' while the hosts saw a panicked, overwhelmed person making a single bad choice, not a pattern of cruelty.

•

The office story commenters unanimously sided with the returning maternity-leave coworker, calling the new grad's decorations 'free labor' and the bosses' mixed signals a potential discrimination lawsuit.

Key takeaways

•

A 22-year-old man felt 'deceived' upon discovering his girlfriend's cystic acne after makeup rubbed off during a tipsy night, framing her skin condition as a curated false baseline rather than a medical issue, and questioned whether he should force an 'honest conversation' about her makeup use.

•

A man bit hard into a tamarind (a fruit with a large hard seed) without asking what it was, cracked his tooth, then blamed his girlfriend for not warning him — despite her having a pattern of 'pranking' him with food containing inedible parts, which the hosts identified as the real red flag.

•

A 21-year-old groom-to-be refused to walk his fiancée to the bathroom during a 3-hour movie despite her repeated stomach distress signals, sarcastically telling her to go only during credits; she posted her side, was unanimously voted 'not the asshole,' and the comments revealed she deleted her post after being called out.

•

A husband of 10 years exploded when his wife suggested euthanizing their sick cat, revealing a decade-long affair in the process, then proposed 'joint custody' of his time between his wife and affair partner (4 days with her, 3 with wife), and faked a lawyer letter demanding $50,000 after driving through a flooded causeway against his friend's advice.

•

Reddit curator Matt (Direct Caterpillar) spends months or years tracking down story updates using 18 different archive sources, including the Wayback Machine, purely for 'love of the game' with no monetary reward from karma.

•

A 23-year-old new grad painted walls, installed LED lights, and brought plants into a senior coworker's office during her year-long maternity leave, then resisted giving it back despite mixed signals from two bosses, framing it as 'standing her ground' while commenters called it discrimination against a returning mother.

•

A 35-year-old groom used ChatGPT to write his wedding vows; his bride immediately recognized the AI tone, confronted him at the altar, gave him an ultimatum to speak from the heart or she'd leave, walked out when he froze, then ghosted him and refused counseling — ending the marriage before it began.

Notable quotes

“What if her idea of makeup is really to change her whole face? I'm not claiming to be the victim here, but I also can't say she's entirely without responsibility in all of this.”

▸ Notable quotes · 9:33

“You're not a 7-year-old at Despicable Me. You are perfectly capable of going to the restroom.”

▸ Notable quotes · 34:44

“I thought I could spend 4 days a week with a fair partner and three days with you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 47:38

“It's almost for you. Does it feel like you're like metal detecting or rock collecting? Like puzzle solving things.”

▸ Notable quotes · 62:55

“She ended up getting even more angry with me about quote posting our business even though our names weren't mentioned and that she couldn't believe I needed online strangers to tell me why I was wrong.”

▸ Notable quotes · 122:15

“To be a human is to be a hypocrite which is so I love that well it's so funny to me because it's like I used to be like hypocrites bother me so much but like I'm probably hypocrite too like we all have myself week to week.”

▸ Notable quotes · 129:26

Chapters

•

0:00 — Intro and mogging: Hosts Morgan and Lauren banter about 'mogging' (outshining someone), earrings from Mallorca, ADHD jewelry/clothing phases, and sleep t-shirt preferences before introducing the 'First Day on Earth' theme.

•

5:13 — Story 1: Makeup deception: A 22M feels shocked and deceived seeing his 21F girlfriend's cystic acne after makeup rubs off; hosts and commenters condemn his framing of her skin condition as a lie.

•

17:27 — Story 2: Tamarind seed: Man bites into tamarind seed, cracks tooth, blames girlfriend for not warning him; hosts note her pattern of food 'pranks' makes her the real problem, but Reddit votes everyone sucks.

•

30:43 — Story 3: Bathroom refusal: 21M refuses to accompany fiancée to bathroom during 3-hour movie despite her distress; she posts her side, gets validated, he admits she wasn't in danger but felt interrupted.

•

46:03 — Story 4: 10-year affair: Husband reveals decade-long affair during argument about cat; proposes joint custody of time with wife and affair partner; later fakes lawyer letter after driving through flood.

•

59:03 — Guest: Matt (Direct Caterpillar): Reddit curator Matt joins, discusses his 4-year account, 5.7M karma, story-finding methods using 18 archive sources, and shares two stories: puppet wedding and flooded causeway.

•

88:13 — Story 5: Office maternity leave: 23F new grad decorates senior coworker's office during year-long maternity leave, resists returning it; commenters call it discrimination, hosts advise giving it up for career longevity.

•

106:03 — Story 6: AI wedding vows: 35M uses ChatGPT for vows; 34F bride recognizes AI, walks out mid-ceremony, ghosts him; update reveals she refuses counseling, marriage over, he's suicidal; hosts advocate grace.

Speakers

•

Morgan — Co-host

•

Lauren — Co-host

•

Matt (Direct Caterpillar) — Guest

•

Bailey — Producer

⋮