TLDR
In part three of the Ashley Flynn case, hosts Stephanie Harlow and Derek Levasseur detail the final days before Caleb Flynn murdered his wife Ashley on February 16, 2026. After a month of no contact, Caleb reeled his mistress Aleah Boatner back in on Valentine's Day, claiming he had finally told Ashley he wanted a divorce. That night, while Ashley waited at home with their daughters, Caleb stayed at church with Aleah. Digital forensics — Apple Watch steps, AirPods connections, deleted apps, and a staged garage door — contradict Caleb's 911 call story that an intruder broke in and shot Ashley while he slept on the couch. Autopsy shows Ashley was asleep, shot twice in the head at close range. Police were suspicious from the start; the missing 9mm from Caleb's truck matches the shell casings. Aleah's pressure and Caleb's fear of losing her appear to have accelerated the timeline. Part four will cover the gun search and trial.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Caleb created a fake Instagram account ('Derek Hammett') using photos from a man he followed, registered it on his own phone, and used it to catfish his own mistress to test her loyalty.
Caleb paid for a subscription service (Snoop Report) to receive weekly reports on Aleah's public Instagram activity — follows, likes, interactions — even after she ended their relationship in January 2026.
The 911 dispatcher repeatedly called Caleb 'ma'am' because his high-pitched, performative crying sounded like a woman; his mother sounds identical, confirming a family vocal trait.
Caleb's Apple Watch logged 105 steps between 2:18–2:28 a.m. — while he claimed to be asleep — and his AirPods connected to his locked phone at 2:17 a.m., which only happens when they are removed from the case and placed in ears.
The garage side door's strike plate was bent inward, not outward as expected from forced entry; screws were straight with no wood fragments; tool marks indicated damage was inflicted while the door was already open.
Caleb told the 911 dispatcher Ashley had been shot twice in the head within minutes, but the medical examiner could not determine the number of wounds until shaving her head during autopsy hours later.
Caleb claimed he slept on the bottom bunk of his daughters' bed, but the bunk was filled with stuffed animals and too small for an adult; both girls slept through two gunshots feet away.
Aleah told Caleb 'I know you'll stalk him' about her date, acknowledging his surveillance as a known, accepted dynamic in their relationship.
Key takeaways
Caleb Flynn maintained a years-long affair with Aleah Boatner while manipulating both her and his wife Ashley, demanding Aleah's exclusivity while remaining married and living with Ashley.
Caleb digitally surveilled Aleah by hacking her Instagram, creating a fake 'Derek Hammett' account to catfish her, and paying for Snoop Report to monitor her social media activity even after she went no-contact.
On Valentine's Day 2026, Caleb told Aleah he had finally informed Ashley of the divorce, but digital evidence shows he was texting Aleah late into the night while Ashley was home with their daughters.
The 911 call at 2:30 a.m. on February 16 and forensic data — Apple Watch steps, AirPods connections, deleted apps, and a palm print on a refrigerator blocking the garage side door — directly contradict Caleb's claim that he was asleep on the couch when an intruder entered.
Autopsy revealed Ashley was shot twice in the head at close range while sleeping on her side with her arm under her head; the bullets traveled parallel paths and one re-entered her elbow.
The garage side door showed damage consistent with being forced open from the inside while already open, not from an outside intruder; a refrigerator blocked it and bore Caleb's palm print.
Caleb's police interviews contained inconsistencies: he knew Ashley was shot twice before anyone could have determined that, he only coughed during interviews (not on the 911 call or body cam), and his story about sleeping in his daughters' bunk bed was physically impossible.
Neighborhood surveillance, a K9 track, and a drone heat search found no evidence of an intruder; the only footprints were from police and the dog.
Notable quotes
“He said it was because he was not because of the canceling Easter, it's because of filing for divorce with Ashley. And um 'I'm actually leaving her this town.' Something along the lines of that.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:33“Are you sure there's nothing between you and Zack? The only, and I mean only reason I wouldn't go through with this right now is if you told me you really didn't want this or if you have feelings for him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:03“I don't know this guy, but I know he can't give you what I can. He can't or never will care and love you with the absolute magnitude that I can. It was real and I have so much more to give.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:44“Oh my god, somebody Somebody broke into my home. Somebody broke into my home. They shot my wife.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:30“She was facing towards the middle of bed. Like she was on her left side with her left arm. I don't know if it was under the pillow or under her head that is I put it on the United States mine under pillows like I don't know if it was under her head or towel I can't remember. And she looked like she was sleeping I mean when she was shot I mean in fact there was no, you know, startledness I mean it was like when she was she was asleep when she was shot.”
▸ Notable quotes · 68:11“The fact that you would know that to me is is not logical. I don't see that being the case. I've seen multiple multiple gunshot wounds to a hand. It's usually not until an autopsy where I'm able to determine how many times she's been shot through the pathologist.”
▸ Notable quotes · 69:38Chapters
0:11 — Recap & Viewer Theory: Hosts recap parts 1-2: Caleb's dual promises to wife Ashley and mistress Aleah, missed deadlines, Aleah's Florida trip, and Valentine's Day reunion. A viewer theory suggests Caleb may have manipulated Aleah into killing Ashley.
3:03 — No-Contact Period & Digital Surveillance: During Jan 12–Feb 14 no-contact, Caleb hacked Aleah's Instagram, created a fake 'Derek Hammett' account to catfish her, and paid for Snoop Report to monitor her social media. Aleah knew he was watching.
18:31 — Valentine's Day Reconnection: On Feb 14, Caleb texted Aleah he'd told Ashley about divorce; they met at church. Aleah revealed a March date with a man named Gabe. Caleb reacted with jealousy but claimed confidence; they resumed constant contact.
33:23 — Feb 15: Galentine's Day & Caleb's Lies: Ashley held a Galentine's party with daughters. Caleb lied to Aleah about Ashley's whereabouts, sent photos of daughters in bed to prove he wasn't with Ashley, and texted Aleah past midnight while Ashley slept.
52:33 — Murder Timeline & 911 Call: Digital forensics show Ashley's phone locked at 11:20 p.m. Feb 15. Caleb deleted apps at 1:01 a.m., Apple Watch logged steps and heart rate, AirPods connected at 2:17 a.m., 911 called at 2:30 a.m. — contradicting his story of sleeping on couch.
66:48 — Police Response & Body Cam: First officer found garage side door open but blocked by refrigerator with Caleb's palm print. No forced entry elsewhere. Dogs didn't bark. Caleb's 911 call was performative; dispatcher called him 'ma'am.' Officer Giampapa immediately treated him as a suspect.
71:05 — Autopsy & Forensic Evidence: Autopsy: two close-range shots behind right ear, parallel paths, bullet re-entered left elbow (arm under head). Pillows had bullet holes, brain matter, bone fragments. Shell casings near bed. Light switch had blood transfer.
110:36 — Caleb's Interviews & Inconsistencies: Caleb claimed he slept on couch, heard dog collar, went to daughters' bunk bed, heard shots, froze. Bunk bed too small for adult. He knew Ashley was shot twice before medically possible. Coughed only in interviews. Story changed between interviews.
Speakers
Stephanie Harlow — Host
Derek Levasseur — Co-host