TLDR
In part three of the Jade Benning case, hosts Stephanie Harlo and Derek Levasser detail the catastrophic investigation failures after Jade's collapse, including an unsecured crime scene, a CSI who only collected items detectives explicitly requested, and the failure to seize boyfriend Bla1 Taylor's phone for over a year. They reveal Bla1's decade-long pattern of pressuring pregnant partners to abort — including Apple Denny, who testified Bla1 asked her to obtain abortion pills to secretly give to his then-girlfriend Xavier Winford — and analyze the suspicious Blink camera timeline that went offline days before Jade's poisoning and was moved to her bedroom. Bla1 was arrested in Utah in March 2024, living with Xavier, and charged with two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Jade and their unborn daughter Ivy. The defense has exploited investigative gaps, but the hosts argue the cumulative evidence points to deliberate poisoning. The final episode will cover the trial's conclusion and recent developments.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The CSI explicitly testified he was not there to independently assess evidentiary value but only to collect what homicide detectives told him to collect — a fundamental misunderstanding of the CSI role.
Detective Adam Reese acknowledged the bottles from the refrigerator had been removed by homicide detectives before CSI documented the scene, violating basic crime scene protocol.
Bla1 asked Apple Denny to pretend to be Xavier Winford and schedule an abortion appointment for her, which Apple did — and Bla1 then manipulated Xavier into attending.
The Blink camera's offline period (Feb 22–26) coincides with Bla1's alleged business trip, but no evidence was presented that he actually traveled; the camera was moved to the bedroom and plugged back in before police secured the scene.
Jade's phone created a KTX snapshot of the Blink app showing the kitchen view at 9:37 p.m. on February 26th — likely when police first accessed her phone after obtaining it.
Key takeaways
The crime scene at Jade's apartment was not secured until February 27th — two days after her collapse — because domestic violence investigators failed to follow protocol, allowing family and friends to contaminate the scene and creating chain-of-custody issues the defense can exploit.
CSI Detective Jason Terry testified he only collected items homicide detectives specifically requested — two glasses on the kitchen island, two bottles from the fridge, the comforter, and a washcloth — and ignored a pink cup by the sink, cookies on the stove, a glass on the nightstand, and an open bag of M&Ms, because no one told him to take them.
Lead detective Adam Reese admitted this was his first poisoning investigation and that he never obtained a search warrant for Bla1 Taylor's phone, despite classifying the case as a homicide by February 26th; Bla1's phone was never seized, and the device he used during the relevant period was never recovered.
Apple Denny testified that in 2017, when she became pregnant at 18, Bla1 supported her abortion and attended both appointments; months later, when Bla1 got Xavier Winford pregnant, he panicked, pressured Xavier to abort, and asked Apple to obtain abortion pills so he could secretly put them in Xavier's drink — establishing a pattern of reproductive coercion.
Bla1 maintained a years-long romantic relationship with Xavier Winford while dating Jade; messages from February 24, 2023 — the night before Jade's collapse — show Bla1 professing love to Xavier and planning a future with her, while Jade believed they were co-parenting their daughter Ivy.
The Blink camera in Jade's kitchen went offline at 8:37 a.m. on February 22nd and remained offline until at least February 26th at 7:08 p.m.; a cached image timestamped 2:48 p.m. on the 22nd indicates Jade opened the app that afternoon, and the camera was later found in her bedroom facing the balcony, plugged in and online.
Police never obtained a warrant from Amazon for the Blink camera's cloud data, which would have provided exact timestamps for when the camera was unplugged, moved, and plugged back in — instead relying only on limited phone artifacts like KTX snapshots and iOS motion notifications.
Bla1 Taylor worked normally the week of February 27th — including the day his daughter Ivy was declared dead — and only stopped showing up after March 6th, the day Jade was removed from life support; he moved to Utah with Xavier Winford by June 2023 and was arrested there in March 2024.
Notable quotes
“I am here to collect certain items of potential evidentiary value that the homicide detectives already told me they wanted collected.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:47“Derek, every crime scene is contaminated. The question is how much?”
▸ Notable quotes · 12:28“He was googling things... he was looking stuff up to figure out how she like if there was something he could do to make her have an abortion.”
▸ Notable quotes · 74:57“Put it in her drink.”
▸ Notable quotes · 75:21“In retrospect, I absolutely wish I would have done that, but just that night, I did not cuz we thought those were the glasses that were in use.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:52“We are going to be just fine. We just need to stick together.”
▸ Notable quotes · 61:37Chapters
4:05 — Jade's death and Bla1's behavior: Jade died on March 6, 2023, her 25th birthday — the day she planned to announce her pregnancy. Bla1 worked normally that week, only missing work after March 6th, and moved to Utah with Xavier Winford by June 2023.
9:58 — Crime scene failures and CSI testimony: The apartment wasn't secured until Feb 27; CSI Detective Terry only collected items detectives explicitly requested, missing the pink cup, cookies, nightstand glass, and other potential evidence. Detective Reese admitted this was his first poisoning case.
43:46 — Bla1's phone never seized: Despite classifying the case as homicide by Feb 26, police never obtained a warrant for Bla1's phone. At his 2024 arrest, he had an iPhone 15 Pro, but the phone used during the relevant period was never recovered; iCloud data showed multiple associated devices.
59:41 — Xavier Winford and Bla1's double life: Messages from Feb 24, 2023 show Bla1 professing love to Xavier and planning a future, while Jade believed they were co-parenting. Bla1 was arrested in Utah in a vehicle registered to Xavier, over a year after Jade's death.
69:56 — Apple Denny's testimony reveals pattern: Apple testified Bla1 supported her 2017 abortion but panicked when Xavier got pregnant months later, asking Apple to get abortion pills to secretly give Xavier — establishing a pattern of reproductive coercion and drink tampering.
90:49 — Blink camera timeline and investigation gaps: The kitchen camera went offline Feb 22 at 8:37 a.m., a cached image appeared at 2:48 p.m. (Jade opening the app), and the camera was found in the bedroom by Feb 26. Police never got an Amazon warrant for exact online/offline logs, relying only on phone artifacts.
Speakers
Stephanie Harlo — Co-host
Derek Levasser — Co-host