TLDR
Brian Coberger is attempting to withdraw his guilty plea in the University of Idaho murders, claiming his attorneys coerced him and withheld exculpatory evidence. Co-host Derek Labasser argues a new trial would likely result in the death penalty since the plea deal would be void. A defense-hired digital forensics expert, Sai Ray, has now reversed his own January 2025 report, claiming phone data shows Coberger stalked victim Maddie Mogen — a claim contradicted by his original defense report. The hosts debate whether a new trial (risking death penalty) or life in miserable prison is the better outcome, while victims' families have called Coberger a narcissist for reopening the case. Legal experts consider the withdrawal petition unlikely to succeed. The episode also covers media misrepresentation of Derek's comments. The hosts remain certain of Coberger's guilt and that he acted alone. They discuss the overwhelming evidence: DNA on the knife sheath, cell phone data, surveillance video, eyewitness testimony, and Coberger's own guilty plea after months of counsel review. The alleged exculpatory hair evidence from Ethan Chapin's hand was found by the defense's own expert to be Ethan's own hair. Sai Ray's credibility is questioned due to his contradictory reports. The hosts ask listeners what they would want if they were a victim's parent: life in prison or a death penalty trial. The episode ends with a preview of the next Chandler Halderson case episode.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A defense-hired expert witness (Sai Ray) has completely reversed his own sworn report, now claiming the prosecution missed incriminating phone data that he himself previously said did not exist.
The alleged 'clumps of hair' in Ethan Chapin's hand — cited by Coberger as exculpatory — were analyzed by the defense's own hair expert and found to be Ethan's own hair, not an unknown attacker's.
Derek Labasser, a true-crime host, explicitly states he wants Coberger to get a new trial not for justice but because it would likely lead to the death penalty — and he acknowledges this means more taxpayer cost and family trauma.
Co-host Stephanie Harllo says she would prefer Coberger serve 60 years in miserable prison rather than get the death penalty, because 'there are fates worse than death' and he is already living one.
The hosts use belief in Coberger's innocence as a 'litmus test' for whether they can take someone's opinion seriously on any topic, equating doubt of his guilt with irrationality.
Key takeaways
Brian Coberger filed a post-conviction petition to withdraw his guilty plea, claiming attorney coercion, misunderstanding of exculpatory evidence, and misinformation about prison conditions — but legal standards make withdrawing a plea after sentencing extremely difficult, requiring proof of a serious constitutional defect rather than mere regret.
The alleged exculpatory evidence centers on hair or debris from Ethan Chapin's hand, but the FBI found no hair microscopically consistent with Coberger's, and the defense's own expert, Ruth Ballard, concluded the hair was morphologically consistent with Ethan's own reference sample, undermining the claim it came from an unknown attacker.
Derek Labasser publicly stated he is 'thrilled' Coberger is trying to retract his confession because a new trial would void the plea deal and likely result in the death penalty — a position he clarified was strategic, not supportive of Coberger, though media outlets ran misleading headlines suggesting otherwise.
Digital forensics expert Sai Ray, originally hired by Coberger's defense, now claims phone location data shows Coberger's phone repeatedly near the King Road house before the murders and 'colliding' with Maddie Mogen's phone at two prior locations, suggesting stalking — but his January 2025 defense report stated the exact opposite: no association between Coberger and the victims or their residences, and no evidence of stalking.
The hosts emphasize the overwhelming evidence of Coberger's guilt: DNA on the knife sheath, cell tower data placing him near the scene, surveillance video, eyewitness description matching Coberger, his phone being turned off during the murders, and his own guilty plea after two years of evidence review with counsel — and they dismiss alternate theories as requiring an implausible CIA-level framing operation.
Victims' families have publicly condemned Coberger's petition, with the Goncalves family calling him a narcissist who 'chose not to leave his fate or the facts of the case to a jury' and never raised concerns during two years of discovery review.
Defense attorney Bob Motta (Defense Diaries) reacted to the petition with 'Good luck with that,' signaling even defense-side legal experts view the withdrawal attempt as having virtually no chance of success.
The hosts debate the moral outcome: Stephanie prefers Coberger suffer decades in miserable prison conditions, while Derek would accept a new trial for the chance at a death penalty verdict and the closure of witnessing the execution — both agree Coberger is guilty and acted alone.
Notable quotes
“I for one am thrilled that Brian Coberger is trying to retract his confession and I think we should grant him a new trial.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:09“When the verdict comes out, there's no deal. No going to prison for the next 30, 40 years and living off the taxpayers's dime. Nope. It's the death penalty.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:33“If I were the father of one of these children and you told me that if I was willing to go through this trial, I could have the chance at the end of it to sit there and watch the person responsible be killed. Sign me up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:14“The official FBI report did not apparently describe the material as this dramatic clumps of hair. It described debris recovered from Ethan's right hand and additional debris recovered from Zana's left hand.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:31“A DNA and hair expert retained by Brian Cobberg's own defense team, her name is Ruth Ballard, reportedly examined hair recovered from Ethan's hand and concluded that it was quote morphologically consistent with Desident Chapman's own reference hair.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:20“He chose not to leave his fate or the facts of the case to a jury. He never cried foul, never claimed he was uninformed or pressured, and never suggested there was problems with the discovery materials he and his council had reviewed for 2 years that should have been challenged.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:49Chapters
0:10 — Derek's viral video and media backlash: Derek Labasser explains his 2-minute driveway video saying he's 'thrilled' Coberger is trying to withdraw his plea because a new trial would likely bring the death penalty. InTouch Weekly and Yahoo ran misleading headlines calling him a Coberger supporter, but listeners defended him in comments.
5:10 — Legal analysis of Coberger's petition to withdraw plea: The hosts break down Coberger's claims: attorney coercion, failure to disclose exculpatory evidence, and misinformation about prison conditions. They explain the high legal bar for withdrawing a plea after sentencing — requiring a constitutional defect, not just regret — and why this petition faces an uphill battle.
7:20 — The alleged exculpatory hair evidence debunked: The 'clumps of hair' from Ethan Chapin's hand, cited by Coberger as potentially exculpatory, were examined by the FBI (no match to Coberger) and the defense's own expert Ruth Ballard, who found the hair morphologically consistent with Ethan's own hair — not an unknown attacker.
10:10 — Hosts' certainty of guilt and dismissal of alternate theories: Stephanie and Derek detail the overwhelming evidence: DNA on the knife sheath, cell phone data, surveillance video, eyewitness testimony, Coberger's phone turned off during the murders, and his guilty plea after two years of counsel review. They mock alternate theories as requiring an implausible framing operation.
16:34 — Sai Ray's contradictory expert reports: Defense-hired digital forensics expert Sai Ray now claims phone data shows Coberger stalked Maddie Mogen — but his January 2025 defense report stated the exact opposite: no association between Coberger and victims, no evidence of stalking. The hosts question his credibility and motives.
27:00 — Debate: new trial with death penalty vs. life in miserable prison: Stephanie prefers Coberger suffer decades in brutal prison conditions; Derek would accept a new trial for the chance at a death penalty verdict and the closure of witnessing the execution. They discuss Idaho's firing squad option and ask listeners what they would want as a victim's parent.
31:20 — Victims' families' reaction and conclusion: The Goncalves family called Coberger a narcissist for reopening the case after knowingly pleading guilty. Defense attorney Bob Motta dismissed the petition's chances. The hosts reaffirm Coberger's guilt, preview the next Chandler Halderson episode, and promote their membership platforms.
Speakers
Stephanie Harllo — Co-host
Derek Labasser — Co-host