El-Sayed Gives MASTERCLASS Response To Absurd Question

Original Media · 11m · English · YouTube · The Young Turks

TLDR

The Young Turks hosts Cenk Uygur and Ana Kasparian criticize cable news media for repeatedly asking Muslim politicians like senator-elect Abdul Al-Sayed and Mayor Abdullah Hammoud to denounce antisemitism and prove they're not a threat to Jewish voters, while never asking pro-Israel politicians about Muslim safety. They argue this framing falsely portrays Jewish Americans as monolithically pro-Israel and fuels anti-Muslim bigotry.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

80% of Jewish Americans say Israel's actions in Gaza/West Bank increase antisemitism in the US — a statistic rarely cited in mainstream coverage.

•

66% of Jewish Americans say AIPAC campaign spending against Israel-critical candidates increases antisemitism.

•

The same media outlets that claim to oppose bigotry use explicitly bigoted framing ('you Muslim man, you look scary') when questioning Muslim officials.

Key takeaways

•

60% of Jewish Americans in Michigan voted for Abdul Al-Sayed; 72% nationally voted for Democrats; 61% believe Israel committed war crimes; 80% say Israel's actions increase US antisemitism.

•

Media repeatedly questions Muslim elected officials about Jewish safety but never asks pro-Israel politicians about Muslim safety despite US funding of actions killing Palestinian civilians.

•

The framing implies Jewish Americans uniformly support Israel's government, which the hosts call a 'dual loyalty trope' that is itself antisemitic.

•

Abdullah Hammoud (Dearborn Mayor) emphasized shared experiences of religious discrimination and commitment to safety for all communities.

•

Cenk Uygur argues media coordination on this line of questioning across Fox and MSNBC reveals they 'work for Israel' rather than doing journalism.

Notable quotes

“We get it. You work for Israel. We get it.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:27

“80% of Jewish Americans say Israel's actions in Gaza and the West Bank increase antisemitism in the US. 80% of Jewish Americans say that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:09

“That is literally a dual loyalty trope saying no, even if Jews say that they're not supporting Israel's actions, we're going to say that they're real loyalty to Israel no matter what.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:51

“Every cable news anchor is like, oh, you Muslim man, you look scary. You know, wait, if you get elected, people are going to feel unsafe. Tell us why we shouldn't feel unsafe because a savage Muslim like you got elected.”

▸ Notable quotes · 3:07

“You're the uni-media supporting the uni-party for the uni-country, which is Israel and not us.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:11

Chapters

•

0:00 — MSNBC's Question to Abdul Al-Sayed: Hosts react to MSNBC asking senator-elect Abdul Al-Sayed what he'll do to protect Jewish voters from antisemitism, calling the question dishonest and bigoted.

•

1:45 — Jewish American Voting Data and Opinions: Cenk cites polling showing majority of Jewish Americans voted for Al-Sayed, oppose Israel's current government, believe Israel committed war crimes, and say Israel's actions increase US antisemitism.

•

3:09 — The Muslim Double Standard: Hosts contrast the treatment of Muslim officials with pro-Israel politicians who are never asked about Muslim safety despite US funding of actions harming Palestinians.

•

4:20 — Abdullah Hammoud's Response: Dearborn Mayor Hammoud shares personal history with Jewish community, emphasizes religious freedom, and criticizes unconditional US funding for Israeli government actions.

•

8:40 — Mom Dani Clip and Media Coordination: Hosts play clip of journalist Mom Dani pressing a Muslim official on associations, noting Fox and MSNBC alignment on Israel coverage reveals propaganda.

Speakers

•

Cenk Uygur — Host

•

Ana Kasparian — Co-host

•

Abdul Al-Sayed — Senator-elect (referenced)

•

Abdullah Hammoud — Mayor of Dearborn (clip)

•

Mom Dani — Journalist (clip)

⋮