TLDR
The Mississippi Senate race remains undecided with Democrat Scott Colom leading Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde Smith by 2,536 votes as thousands of affidavit ballots are counted. The close margin is complicated by the state's use of error-prone Experian credit data to purge over 230,000 voters from rolls, leaving many unaware until they attempted to vote. The Secretary of State's office pressured counties to implement the flawed purge list, then quietly abandoned the program after the election. Mississippi's restrictive voting laws and lack of standardized counting procedures further undermine confidence in the process. Voters must cure affidavit ballots by 5 p.m. the next day, with certification due November 13.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Mississippi used a credit reporting agency's database as the primary source for voter roll maintenance, despite the agency explicitly disclaiming accuracy.
One in five voters in DeSoto County were flagged as inactive — far higher than the typical provisional ballot rate of one in a hundred.
The state only sends a single notice to the potentially incorrect address on file, creating a catch-22 where voters cannot know they've been purged.
County election officials reported being pressured by the Secretary of State's office to use the flawed Experian data.
Key takeaways
Mississippi's Senate race between Scott Colom and Cindy Hyde Smith is separated by only 2,536 votes with approximately 25,000 ballots still uncounted.
The state used Experian credit data — despite a disclaimer about its accuracy — to remove 230,000 voters (1 in 9 statewide, 1 in 5 in DeSoto County) from rolls as 'inactive.'
Voters were notified only at the address Experian had on file, meaning many never received notice and discovered their inactive status only at the polls.
The Secretary of State's office pressured county election officials to implement the Experian purge list despite known errors.
Mississippi's restrictive voting laws (no early voting, no online registration, excuse-required absentee, photo ID) compounded the confusion.
The state lacks standardized vote-counting procedures, relying on part-time officials and a patchwork system that delays results and limits observer access.
The Secretary of State quietly abandoned the Experian program after the election, switching to another vendor without acknowledging failure.
Affidavit ballot voters must 'cure' their ballots by 5 p.m. the next day, and the state must certify results by November 13.
Notable quotes
“The state of Mississippi used that information from Experian's database to scrub its voter rolls, to remove people that it deemed to be inactive voters, mostly because of conflicting information provided by a credit reporting agency about where they live.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:48“Experian issued a disclaimer to the state that it could not guarantee the accuracy or reliability of its data. The state of Mississippi signed the disclaimer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:21“230,000 voters taken off of the rolls amounts to one in nine registered voters in Mississippi this year.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:13“By law, counties are only required to send one notice that a voter has been deemed ineligible except that the notice is sent to the address that Experian has on file. Meaning if they've got the incorrect address for which they are incorrectly deeming you ineligible, you'd never know until you showed up to the polls.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:36“They quietly stopped using it and shifted to another company. And I don't think, obviously, the secretary of state can admit that it was a failure, but the fact that they quickly stopped using it when all of these problems emerged shows IT'S A FAILURE OF A PROJECT.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:00“We took this list. It was a direction from the Secretary of State's office. We had to take these people off the list. And they told us that they were pressured by the Secretary of State's office to use this data to remove people.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:44Chapters
0:01 — Mississippi Senate Race Too Close to Call: The race between Democrat Scott Colom and Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde Smith is separated by 2,536 votes with 97% counted; ~25,000 ballots remain, including absentee and affidavit ballots that will decide the outcome.
1:06 — Experian Data Used to Purge Voter Rolls: Mississippi paid Experian $50,000 for credit data to remove 'inactive' voters, despite Experian's disclaimer that it could not guarantee accuracy; 230,000 voters (1 in 9) were made inactive statewide.
3:36 — Voters Unaware Until Election Day: State law requires only one notice sent to the address Experian has on file; many voters discovered they were purged only when they arrived at polling places, causing widespread confusion and anger.
6:18 — Interview with VoteBeat Reporter Diane Nissenbaum: Nissenbaum reports from DeSoto County (where 1 in 5 voters were purged) that the Secretary of State quietly dropped Experian after the election, but the burden to cure ballots falls on voters within 24 hours.
4:48 — Systemic Voting Barriers in Mississippi: Mississippi lacks early voting, online registration, and no-excuse absentee voting; photo ID is required; no standardized counting method exists, leading to delays and limited observer access.
Speakers
Host — News anchor/host
Diane Nissenbaum — Senior national reporter at VoteBeat