The Chicago Bears Just SHOCKED The NFL With This MASSIVE Jeffery Simmons Trade

Original Media · 15m · English · YouTube · The Pat McAfee Show

TLDR

The Chicago Bears acquired defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons from the Tennessee Titans for two first-round picks and a fourth-round pick, a massive haul reflecting Simmons' elite play and long-term contract. The Bears had initially pursued DeForest Buckner, but Buckner forced a trade to the 49ers for only a fourth-round pick. The Simmons deal moved Chicago's Super Bowl odds from +1400 to +1200, while the Titans and Colts both appear to be in rebuilding modes, stockpiling draft capital.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A defensive tackle trade moved a team's Super Bowl odds by 200 points — an almost unprecedented market reaction for a non-quarterback.

•

DeForest Buckner, a potential Hall of Famer, was traded for just a fourth-round pick because he refused to go anywhere but San Francisco, eliminating the Colts' leverage entirely.

•

The Titans traded their franchise icon and emotional leader while a new stadium is opening next year — a move that contradicts the usual 'build buzz' strategy for a new venue.

Key takeaways

•

Jeffery Simmons was the face of the Titans franchise — respected by everyone in the organization, including former coach Mike Vrabel, who admitted Simmons was the only player he couldn't beat up even in his prime.

•

The Bears pivoted to Simmons only after DeForest Buckner made it clear he would only accept a trade back to San Francisco, giving the 49ers leverage to acquire Buckner for just a fourth-round pick.

•

Simmons' contract — $105 million over three years, running through 2030 — made him far more valuable than Buckner or Quenton Nelson, both of whom are on expiring deals and viewed as rentals.

•

The trade cost the Bears two first-round picks (projected late 20s) and a fourth, the largest draft haul for an interior defensive lineman since 1967, and moved their Super Bowl odds 200 points — a massive market reaction for a single defensive tackle.

•

The Titans are explicitly rebuilding: trading their best player despite a new stadium opening next year signals they are years away from contention and are stockpiling picks like the Colts.

•

Indianapolis received only a fourth for Buckner and a third plus fifth for Nelson, frustrating Colts fans who see Simmons — three years younger with more All-Pros — command two firsts while their stars fetched far less.

•

Rapoport argues the Colts maximized value by using the Bears' interest as leverage to get a fourth from the 49ers instead of a fifth, but acknowledges it's hard to negotiate when the league knows you're selling.

•

Kirk Herbstreit calls the Bears' defensive line 'filthy' with Simmons joining Montez Sweat and Dennis Allen's scheme, and says Simmons' presence alone changes how offenses must block — he demands double teams and can win one-on-ones.

Notable quotes

“Everybody but Jeffery.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:51

“Jeffery Simmons has survived multiple GMs, multiple head coaches, multiple everything down there because everybody in the Tennessee Titans organization loves him.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:54

“This is where you win. This helps tremendously.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:33

“You're just worth what someone is willing to pay for you.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:26

“It's hard when people know you're selling.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:51

“You leave him isolated one-on-one, you're done.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:07

Chapters

•

0:00 — Simmons trade announced: The host breaks the news that Jeffery Simmons was traded from the Titans to the Bears for two first-round picks and a fourth, calling him a franchise pillar who survived multiple regime changes in Tennessee.

•

3:14 — Bears' pursuit and pivot from Buckner: Ian Rapoport explains the Bears were initially targeting DeForest Buckner, but Buckner would only go to the 49ers, so Chicago pivoted to Simmons after persistent calls to Tennessee.

•

4:36 — Super Bowl odds movement: The hosts discuss the Bears' Super Bowl odds shifting from +1400 to +1200 — a 200-point swing — and note it's the largest draft haul for an interior defensive lineman since 1967.

•

5:48 — Colts fan frustration over Buckner and Nelson returns: A Colts fan and host questions why Indianapolis got only a fourth for Buckner and a third plus fifth for Nelson, while Simmons commanded two firsts, suggesting the Colts were worked in negotiations.

•

8:14 — Rental vs. locked-in contract value: Rapoport explains Buckner and Nelson are on expiring contracts, making them rentals that depress trade value, whereas Simmons is signed through 2030 at top-of-market money.

•

11:50 — Colts' leverage and Buckner's no-trade stance: Discussion of how Buckner's refusal to go anywhere but San Francisco gave the 49ers all the leverage, and whether Colts GM Ed Dodds was disadvantaged as a perceived lame duck.

•

14:11 — Titans rebuilding and Bears' defensive outlook: Kirk Herbstreit analyzes the Titans' long-term rebuild despite a new stadium, and projects the Bears' defensive line with Simmons, Montez Sweat, and Dennis Allen's scheme as elite.

Speakers

•

Host 1 — Primary host, Colts fan

•

Ian Rapoport — NFL Insider

•

Kirk Herbstreit — College football analyst, Nashville resident

⋮