TLDR
Victor Davis Hanson argues the 2022 midterms don't end the Trump presidency, which has 27 months left and is "set free" to govern via executive orders like Clinton and Obama after their midterm defeats. He contends the economy was objectively worse under Biden's midterm — higher inflation, lower GDP, negative wage growth — yet Democrats lost fewer seats, suggesting media framing shaped perceptions more than reality. Republican Senate solidarity is essential with only a 4-5 seat margin to sustain vetoes, while Democratic overreach on investigations mirrors the Tea Party's 2010 candidate-quality failures.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Clinton and Obama left office with 68% and 60% approval despite midterm wipeouts, showing midterm losses don't doom a presidency.
Biden's 2022 midterm economy was three times worse on inflation than Trump's 2024 economy, yet Democrats performed better in 2022 than Republicans did in 2024.
Voters supported deportation in polls (55-90%) but rejected it in practice when they saw ICE officers arresting people in their communities.
Trump's tariff policy was entirely "America First" — zero tariffs for companies bringing jobs to the US, high tariffs for those that didn't — yet critics claimed he abandoned America First economics.
Key takeaways
The Trump presidency has 27 months remaining and a president in his final two years is "set free" to govern via executive orders without electoral constraints, as Clinton and Obama demonstrated after their midterm defeats.
The 2022 economy under Biden was objectively worse than 2024's — higher inflation, lower GDP, negative wage growth — yet Democrats lost only nine House seats while Republicans lost more in 2024, suggesting media framing shaped perceptions more than economic reality.
Trump inherited 21% cumulative inflation from Biden but was blamed for price levels he couldn't reverse without causing a deflationary recession; he needed to explain he could only lower the inflation rate while raising wages, which he did achieve.
Border closure removed immigration as a voting motivator since voters thought the issue was solved, but abstract support for mass deportation collapsed when voters confronted the reality of ICE raids in their neighborhoods.
Republican Senate candidates in 2010 (Tea Party) and 2022 nominated unelectable extremists like Christine O'Donnell, costing winnable seats — a pattern of overreach that mirrors Democratic overreach with investigations and impeachment talk.
Democratic unity on confirmations and veto overrides is stricter than Republican unity; Republicans need near-total solidarity with only a 4-5 seat Senate margin to block Democratic legislation via sustained vetoes.
Notable quotes
“the Trump maggot movement is not over and the Trump presidency is not over. It's got two and a half years almost.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:57“a president in his last two terms under our system is set free. He has no elections to worry about. He signs executive orders. He does what he wants.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:41“the economy was terrible and yet we didn't have a red wave and now we're told the economy is terrible when it wasn't nearly as terrible as Biden's and we did have a blue wave.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:23“I can't lower the 21%. That's why you can't afford things. I can only lower the rate of inflation so we don't increase it too much. But more importantly, I can raise wages and I can raise per family income medium and he did.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:42“we want the border closed and we want all 10 million that Biden let in, especially those 500,000 criminals deported. But we go to bed at 10:00 at night and we wake up at 6:00 and we want them all gone that during the evening.”
▸ Notable quotes · 18:26“when they when they when the left discovered that and Christy Gnome and Cory Lyn Linendowski didn't understand that and thought I'm going to wear, you know, kind of like SWAT team stuff and it's I'm going to do all these photo ops, make all these bright about arresting people. You played right into the hands of Tim Waltz and the Minnesota Lunatics.”
▸ Notable quotes · 19:04Chapters
0:00 — Victor's Post-Midterm Analysis: Host introduces Victor Davis Hanson's X post arguing it's too early to judge post-midterm party directions and the left is already planning investigations and impeachments.
2:26 — Historical Parallels: Clinton and Obama: Hanson compares Trump's situation to Clinton and Obama, who lost midterms but governed effectively via executive orders and foreign policy in their final two years, leaving office with high approval ratings.
8:50 — The 2024 Presidential Race Begins: Trump's early candidacy declaration freezes the 2024 field; attention will shift to Rubio, DeSantis, Vance, Newsom, AOC and others, making current investigations irrelevant.
12:00 — Economy: Biden's 2022 vs Trump's 2024: Hanson details how Biden's midterm economy was far worse on every metric — inflation, GDP, wage growth, stock market — yet Democrats lost fewer seats, blaming media framing and inherited inflation math.
16:21 — Inflation Messaging Failure: Trump needed to explain he couldn't reverse 21% cumulative inflation without recession, only slow its rate while raising wages — which he did — but failed to articulate this distinction.
17:49 — Immigration: Abstract Support vs Reality: Border closure made immigration a non-issue; voters supported deportation in polls but recoiled at seeing ICE raids in their communities, playing into Democratic sanctuary-city narratives.
10:40 — Republican Senate Solidarity Needed: With a 4-5 seat Senate margin, Republicans must maintain unity on veto overrides or Democrats will peel off moderates like Murkowski to pass legislation.
Speakers
Host (Jack) — Host
Victor Davis Hanson — Guest