Diddy gets denied by the court. Alex Murdaugh may get a new trial. The Emily Show Ep. 333

Original Media · 54m · English · YouTube · Emily D. Baker

TLDR

Emily D. Baker covers Alec Murdaugh's 132-page appeal to the South Carolina Supreme Court focusing on Clerk of Court Becky Hill's jury tampering and character evidence issues, updates on the paused ethics investigation into Hill due to a criminal probe by the AG's office, and Sean 'Diddy' Combs' case developments including granted laptop access and a denied motion alleging government leaks. This is the final Wednesday episode before the show shifts to Monday 'Quick Bits' and Tuesday-Thursday live streams in 2025. Baker also previews a packed 2025 trial calendar including Karen Read, Bryan Kohberger, and Donna Adelson cases. She reflects on the community built over 333 episodes and the move toward more real-time legal analysis.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Murdaugh's defense cites Chief Justice Marshall's 1807 opinion from the Aaron Burr trial to argue jury impartiality is 'ancient and foundational.'

•

The AG's office is simultaneously arguing Hill's actions didn't prejudice Murdaugh's jury while criminally investigating those same actions.

•

Diddy's legal team suggested the video leak was timed to a 'slow news day' during a break in Trump's trial for Barron's graduation — the judge called this 'wild.'

•

Judge Toal found Becky Hill 'not completely credible,' motivated by the 'siren call of celebrity' and a desire for a guilty verdict to sell a book.

•

Diddy's team never once refuted allegations they paid $100k in cash to hotel security to destroy the surveillance video.

Key takeaways

•

Murdaugh's appeal argues for an irrebuttable presumption of prejudice when a state official (Clerk Becky Hill) tampers with a jury, citing U.S. Supreme Court precedent and the 1807 Aaron Burr trial.

•

The South Carolina Supreme Court took the appeal directly, signaling potential willingness to change the state's legal standard for state-actor jury interference.

•

Becky Hill's 76-count ethics investigation was held in abeyance pending a criminal investigation by the AG's office — the same office defending Murdaugh's conviction, raising conflict concerns.

•

Diddy granted supervised laptop access 7 days/week (8am–3:30pm) for discovery review only — no internet, notes, or communication functions.

•

Judge Subramanian denied Diddy's motion alleging government leaked the 2016 Intercontinental Hotel video to CNN, finding no evidence of Rule 6(e) violations and noting Diddy's team allegedly paid $100k to destroy the video.

•

The defense never denied paying to suppress the hotel video, which Baker speculates explains their intense focus on its release.

•

Show format changing in 2025: Monday 'Quick Bits' podcast drops, live streams Tuesday–Thursday at 11am ET, daily during trials.

•

2025 trial calendar includes Karen Read (April), Bryan Kohberger (Aug–Nov), Donna Adelson (summer), and potential Keefe D. trial (March).

Notable quotes

“I feel like I've become a full-time Diddy legal researcher at this point”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:22

“Miss Hill was attracted by the siren Call of celebrity she wanted to write a book about the trial”

▸ Notable quotes · 20:34

“tell me you think you can buy your way out of everything without telling me you think you can buy your way out of everything in a legal filing”

▸ Notable quotes · 38:36

“law is a conversation and it's harder to have that conversation in the comment section than it is to have that conversation in real time in the chat”

▸ Notable quotes · 46:37

“the principle is ancient and foundational to our system of trial by jury in the ultimate analysis only the jury can strip a man of his Liberty or his life”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:42

“this could undermine this entire trial it goes on to say one juror and the alternate testified that she told them not to be quote fooled by the defense which is wild”

▸ Notable quotes · 16:25

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & 2025 Format Changes: Emily announces this is the final Wednesday episode; the show moves to Monday 'Quick Bits' with Tuesday–Thursday live streams in 2025 to accommodate heavy trial coverage.

•

5:00 — Alec Murdaugh Appeal Overview: Murdaugh filed a 132-page appeal to the SC Supreme Court on two grounds: jury tampering by Clerk Becky Hill (arguing for irrebuttable presumption of prejudice) and improper character evidence admission. The Court took the case directly, suggesting it may revisit state precedent.

•

10:00 — Becky Hill Jury Tampering Hearing Details: Former Justice Toal presided over a hearing where jurors testified Hill commented on Murdaugh's testimony and told them not to be 'fooled by the defense.' One juror initially said Hill influenced her vote but walked it back. Toal found Hill 'not completely credible' and motivated by a book deal.

•

24:00 — Courthouse Becky Ethics Investigation Paused: The State Ethics Commission held Hill's 76-count investigation in abeyance pending a criminal investigation by the AG's office — the same office defending Murdaugh's conviction, creating a potential conflict.

•

29:30 — Diddy Case Updates: Laptop Access & Leak Motion Denied: Judge granted Diddy supervised laptop access for discovery review only. Denied motion alleging government leaked the 2016 hotel video to CNN, finding no evidence of grand jury leaks and noting Diddy's team allegedly paid $100k to destroy the video — a claim the defense never denied.

•

44:30 — Farewell to Wednesdays & 2025 Trial Preview: Emily reflects on 333 episodes, community milestones, and previews 2025 trials: Keefe D (March), Karen Read (April), Cory Richens (April), Donna Adelson (summer), Bryan Kohberger (Aug–Nov).

Speakers

•

Emily D. Baker — Host / Legal Analyst

⋮