TLDR
Attorney Peter Trelgos analyzes the government's motion for curative instructions in the Matthew Farwell federal trial. The motion challenges two alleged misstatements of law in defense counsel's opening statement — one on jury unanimity, another on the elements of the federal witness-tampering charge — and the defense's reference to six disputed or unnoticed exhibits. Trelgos agrees with the government on the elements misstatement but finds the unanimity quote ambiguous. He predicts the judge will give a simple unanimity instruction and read the correct elements, while admonishing defense counsel not to reference disputed exhibits without court approval.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Defense counsel stated in opening that Birchmore 'called up and pulls up' cash-app images that the defense's own expert confirms she never accessed.
The government acknowledges the court already overruled its objection to exhibit T13 'during trial,' yet this motion was filed before testimony began — suggesting a prior hearing or proceeding not fully explained.
Federal prosecutors know that if they lose on the killing element (part one of Count 1), 'it's very difficult to win on what a lot of people would call a technicality even though it is in fact the reason we're here in federal court and not in state court.'
No cameras are allowed in federal court, and Trelgos believes the judiciary will 'dig in' against cameras rather than trend toward transparency.
Key takeaways
The government argues defense counsel misstated the unanimity requirement by telling jurors 'if any one of you finds the government has not met its burden, you must acquit,' which the government says implies a single juror can force an acquittal; Trelgos reads the quote as correctly stating an individual juror's duty to vote not guilty if unconvinced.
On the elements of the §1512 charge, defense counsel claimed the government must prove Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from communicating directly with a federal law enforcement officer, and noted his wife is not a federal officer; the government correctly counters that it need only show a reasonable likelihood any communication would reach federal authorities, and that preventing such communication need not be the sole motive.
Defense counsel referenced at least six disputed or unnoticed exhibits in opening, including cash-app images (Z-13, A-14) that the defense's own expert says Birchmore never accessed, a 'gushing blood' text message the government says does not exist, FBI agent notes constituting double hearsay, and a claim Farwell denied paternity via text — which the government says first appears in an unrecorded Feb 6 parking-lot interview.
The government did not object during the defense opening despite having reviewed the defense's PowerPoint beforehand; Trelgos questions this tactical choice but notes the volume of disputed exhibits (175 of 248 defense exhibits) may have made real-time objections impractical.
Trelgos predicts the judge will give a brief curative instruction on unanimity ('all 12 must agree to convict or acquit') and re-read the correct elements, but will not explicitly rebuke defense counsel in front of the jury; he expects a sidebar admonishment barring further reference to disputed exhibits without prior court approval.
Notable quotes
“If any one of you finds that the government has not met its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, you must acquit Matthew Farwell.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:25“The government does not have to prove that Mr. Farwell or Sandra Birchmore had federal law enforcement in mind, but the government must show that there was a reasonable likelihood that a relevant communication had it actually occurred would have been made to a federal law enforcement officer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:09“Moreover, you need not find that preventing a communication about the commission or possible commission of one of the foregoing federal offenses was the defendant's sole intention. It is sufficient if you find beyond a reasonable doubt that he possessed this intent among others.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:25“In reality, I think jurors make it a little easier if you prove part one to prove part two, but that needs to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt as well.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:24“There's no way to unring the bell that the defense counsel rung during their opening statement.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:56“I think this is a totally fair request from the prosecutor. Even if they didn't object in time, even if you want to say they waived some of these, I think it's a totally appropriate. I think it's professional. I think this is the exact way you do it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:16Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and motion overview: Trelgos introduces the government's motion for curative instructions filed after defense opening statements in the Matthew Farwell trial, noting the motion reveals details about the defense opening not previously public.
4:22 — Misstatement 1: Jury unanimity: Government challenges defense counsel's statement that 'if any one of you finds the government has not met its burden, you must acquit'; Trelgos analyzes the quote as potentially ambiguous but likely a correct statement of an individual juror's duty.
8:20 — Misstatement 2: Elements of the offense: Government argues defense misstated the §1512 elements by requiring proof Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent direct communication with a federal officer; correct standard is reasonable likelihood any communication would reach federal authorities, and intent need not be sole motive.
18:40 — Disputed exhibits referenced in opening: Government identifies six categories of disputed or unnoticed exhibits defense referenced: cash-app images, 'gushing blood' text, FBI agent notes, paternity denial text, series of Birchmore texts, and an affidavit; many lack evidentiary support or are inadmissible hearsay.
32:40 — Government's requested relief: Government seeks curative instructions before testimony begins on Oct 13, and an order prohibiting defense from questioning witnesses about disputed/unnoticed exhibits without prior court approval.
34:30 — Trelgos's predictions and analysis: Trelgos predicts judge will give simple unanimity instruction and re-read elements, admonish defense at sidebar, but not explicitly rebuke defense counsel before the jury; notes federal vs. state trial differences and lack of courtroom cameras.
Speakers
Peter Trelgos — Host/Attorney