Trump Bans Journalists From White House

Original Media · 28m · English · YouTube · LegalEagle

TLDR

In September 2024, President Trump banned CNN, MSNBC, and Politico from the White House, revoking reporters' hard passes without notice or explanation in retaliation for coverage he disliked. The outlets sued, and Judge Timothy Kelly — a Trump appointee — issued a temporary restraining order restoring access, ruling the White House violated Fifth Amendment due process requirements established in Sherrill v. Knight. The press corps protested by refusing pool coverage, leaving Trump with only Newsmax and the White House feed for major events including Xi Jinping's state visit, a self-inflicted media blackout that embarrassed the administration.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Trump explicitly called it a "ban on the free press" and said "I would say the ban would go as far as you can."

•

The government argued Trump's public statements about banning "fake news" were a deliberate "ruse" to distract from national security concerns.

•

The "national security" violations cited included a story about Trump possibly renaming Ford's Theatre, with the proof being Trump's own Truth Social post denying it.

•

Betsy Klein's hard pass was renewed by the Secret Service five months after the story the White House claimed jeopardized national security.

•

The press corps' solidarity included Fox News signing an amicus brief supporting the banned outlets.

•

The White House tried to create its own pool feed, which was technically incompetent and accidentally broadcast "So sorry" on loop.

Key takeaways

•

Trump explicitly admitted the ban was retaliation for "fake news" coverage he disliked, calling it a "ban on the free press" and saying "I would say the ban would go as far as you can."

•

The White House revoked hard passes without any written explanation, notice, or opportunity to respond, violating the due process requirements established in Sherrill v. Knight (1977) and codified in 31 C.F.R. § 409.

•

Judge Timothy Kelly, a Trump appointee who previously ruled against the White House in the Jim Acosta case, issued a temporary restraining order restoring the passes based solely on Fifth Amendment due process grounds, without reaching the First Amendment issue.

•

The government's shifting justifications — first "fake news," then "national security," then "decorum" — undermined their case; the "national security" rationale was contradicted by Trump's own posts and the trivial nature of the cited stories.

•

The White House press corps collectively protested by refusing to provide pool coverage, leaving Trump with only Newsmax and the White House's own feed for major events, including the Xi Jinping state dinner.

•

The government's own expert witness, Kingsley Wilson, had previously purged mainstream reporters from the Pentagon and replaced them with partisan figures like Laura Loomer and Mike Lindell.

•

The legal precedent from Sherrill v. Knight requires clear standards and due process before denying press access, which the White House failed to provide — the belated letters were unsigned, not on letterhead, and gave only days instead of the required 30 days to respond.

•

Even Trump-appointed judges on the DC Circuit have ruled that the president cannot ban journalists from general White House areas accessible to hard pass holders based on viewpoint discrimination.

Notable quotes

“Effective immediately, I am banning fake news CNN, MS Now, and Politico from the White House as a result of their constant reporting fake news.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:11

“When you say the ban, which you know, you know I have many bans I'm involved in. I got more bans going than any of you would believe.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:15

“Oh, the ban on the on the free press, right? Uh a very simple ban. I don't want them in my office. I don't want them here. I would say the ban would go as far as you can.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:35

“Because they're fake news. I I you get so tired of reading and seeing fake news.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:55

“the president has a right and indeed an obligation to obfuscate when it comes to issues of national security”

▸ Notable quotes · 19:38

“pointing out that he's actually just mad about a story with zero national security implications really don't help your case, dude”

▸ Notable quotes · 21:02

Chapters

•

0:00 — Trump Announces Ban: Trump bans CNN, MSNBC, and Politico from the White House via Truth Social, citing "fake news," and admits in the Oval Office that it is a ban on the free press.

•

4:00 — Hard Passes Revoked: Reporters with longstanding hard passes are denied entry and badges confiscated by Secret Service without written explanation or opportunity to respond.

•

7:00 — Legal Background: Review of Sherrill v. Knight, the Jim Acosta case, the Brian Karem case, and the AP case establishing due process and First Amendment protections for press access.

•

13:00 — Lawsuit Filed: CNN, MSNBC, and Politico sue in DC federal court; case assigned to Judge Kelly, who previously ruled against Trump in the Acosta case.

•

14:00 — Government's Shifting Justifications: White House sends belated, unsigned letters citing vague standards; government argues national security but cites trivial stories like a Ford's Theatre rename rumor.

•

18:40 — Court Hearing: DOJ lawyer Velchek argues Trump's public statements are a "ruse"; Judge Kelly issues TRO restoring passes on due process grounds, noting no evidence of national security rationale.

•

22:00 — Press Corps Protest: Pool reporters refuse to cover Trump events; Fox joins amicus brief; Trump loses media visibility during Xi Jinping state visit, with only Newsmax and White House feed available.

•

24:00 — White House's Failed Alternatives: White House tries to replace pool with partisan outlets and its own feed, resulting in technical failures, Secret Service rule violations, and public embarrassment.

Speakers

•

Devin Stone — Host

•

Liz — Co-host/Producer

•

Donald Trump — President

•

Paula Gardner — Reporter

•

Cheyenne Haslett — Reporter

•

Betsy Klein — Reporter

•

Timothy Kelly — Judge

•

Michael Velchek — DOJ Attorney

•

Ted Boutrous — Plaintiffs' Attorney

•

Kingsley Wilson — Government Witness

⋮