TLDR
Progressive commentator argues JD Vance's political career is collapsing due to historically low approval ratings, abandonment by MAGA allies, and fundamental contradictions in his persona that prevent him from appealing to either the general electorate or the Republican base.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Vance is historically the least popular VP at this stage since polling began, underperforming even widely criticized VPs like Harris and Pence.
A prominent Israel-first Republican (Randy Fine) attacked Vance from the right using '1932 Germany' imagery — suggesting Vance's mild criticism of Israel alienated the pro-Israel wing faster than his bigotry attracted the nationalist wing.
Vance's own 2028 'consolation prize' (the Republican nomination) is collapsing before Trump's term advances significantly, with DeSantis-world already positioning against him.
Key takeaways
JD Vance has the worst net approval rating of any modern vice president at this point in their term (-18, a 21-point drop from +3), worse than Kamala Harris (-3), Mike Pence (-7), Joe Biden (+4), or Dick Cheney (+37).
Vance's political rise was entirely manufactured through institutional backing (Tucker Carlson, Peter Thiel, Trump) rather than organic voter connection, leaving him unable to pivot authentically.
Key MAGA figures are distancing from Vance: Florida's Byron Donalds (DeSantis ally) refused to commit to supporting him for 2028, and Congressman Randy Fine explicitly rejected him, comparing Vance's rhetoric to 1932 Germany.
Vance's post-election attempt to blame losses on 'the war' and signal anti-Israel sentiment was dismissed as deceitful slight-of-hand to capture the Tucker Carlson/Steve Bannon isolationist wing.
Vance cannot effectively wield white nationalist rhetoric because his wife Usha and children are brown, creating an unresolvable contradiction for the Republican base.
Democrats (led by figures like Zoran Mandani and Abdul El-Sayed) plan to relentlessly target and humiliate Vance for the next 18-20 months.
Notable quotes
“JD Vance is done and he knows it. The man is toast. He's cooked. It's over.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“JD Vance is historically the least popular vice president at this point in their vice presidency.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:27“I don't think that much about that stuff. First of all, that stuff's all based on polling that we found a number of times in the past have been untrue. But I just try to do my job.”
▸ Notable quotes · 3:40“JD Vance does not connect with the everyday person. He requires institutional power. The Tucker uplift, the Peter Thiel dollars, Donald Trump making him his vice president. Nothing comes organically from Vance.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:40“Everything about this guy is a contradiction. Everything about him is a contradiction and one that he can't explain away with a wink and a nod again because he's not charming enough to do so.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:33“JD Vance is Donald Trump with twice the bigotry and half the charm.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:04“I definitively will not be supporting the vice president in that nominating contest. I thought his message that he put out the day after the election was abhorrent and frankly smacked of the kind of thing you would read in 1932 Germany.”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:53Chapters
0:00 — Vance's Political Obituary: Host declares Vance finished: deeply unpopular with general electorate, no path to general election win, lacks charm/charisma to reinvent himself, and even 2028 nomination hopes collapsing as MAGA turns on him.
2:28 — Historic Unpopularity in Polling: CNN data shows Vance's net approval plummeted from +3 to -18 (21-point swing), making him the least popular VP at this stage in modern history — worse than Harris, Pence, Biden, or Cheney.
3:40 — Vance's Dismissive Response to Polls: Vance claims not to care about approval ratings, blames faulty polling methodology; host notes this reveals his obsession with DC insider metrics while failing to connect with ordinary people.
4:00 — Manufactured Rise, No Organic Base: Vance's entire career built on institutional patronage (Tucker Carlson, Peter Thiel, Trump), not grassroots appeal; now establishment figures like Byron Donalds (DeSantis ally) are refusing to back him for 2028.
6:53 — Fundamental Contradictions: Race, War, Populism: Vance cannot credibly run as anti-war (lockstep with Trump), populist (owned by tech oligarchs), or white nationalist (brown wife and kids); every attempted lane is blocked by his own biography and record.
8:49 — Post-Election Blame-Shifting Backfires: Vance blamed 'the war' for midterm losses in a post-election statement, attempting to signal anti-Israel isolationism; CNN panel and Randy Fine condemned it as deceitful and evocative of 1932 Germany rhetoric.
11:45 — MAGA Civil War Over Vance: Pro-Israel hardliner Randy Fine explicitly rejects Vance for 2028, signaling the pro-Israel evangelical/Zionist wing will oppose him; host concludes Vance has 'nowhere to run' and will be relentlessly mocked by Democrats.
Speakers
Host — Progressive political commentator
Zoran Mandani — Democratic leader
CNN Anchor(s) — News anchors
JD Vance — Vice President of the United States
Byron Donalds — Florida Congressman / Gubernatorial candidate
Randy Fine — Florida Congressman
CNN Panelist (Prior) — Political analyst