TLDR
Trump filed a $10 billion defamation suit against the BBC over a documentary on his January 6 speech, but now seeks to delay his court-ordered deposition until 2027. Because Trump initiated the lawsuit, he cannot claim presidential immunity to avoid testifying, and the BBC — unlike other media outlets — is refusing to settle. The case tests whether Trump will submit to questioning under oath or move to dismiss his own claim.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Trump's $10 billion damages demand against the BBC mirrors the identical $10 billion figure he sought from taxpayers in a separate lawsuit over an IRS leak on his watch.
The documentary at issue never aired in the United States, yet Trump claims it caused $10 billion in reputational damage.
Trump appointed the judge presiding over this case, yet the judge has already rejected the BBC's motion to dismiss and ordered Trump to sit for a deposition.
Key takeaways
Trump voluntarily filed the $10 billion lawsuit against the BBC in December 2025, alleging deceptive editing of his January 6 speech, but has repeatedly cancelled his deposition; a magistrate judge ordered him to appear by December 11 with discovery closing December 18.
Unlike Bill Clinton in Clinton v. Jones, Trump is the plaintiff, not an involuntary defendant, so the Supreme Court's ruling that a sitting president has no temporary immunity from civil suits for unofficial pre-presidency conduct applies even more forcefully.
The BBC wants to depose Trump to test the evidence for his claim, force him to substantiate the $10 billion damages figure, and explore whether the documentary — which never aired in the U.S. — caused any actual reputational harm.
The BBC also seeks to depose Jack Smith, arguing he has critical information; Trump opposes this citing executive privilege, but the BBC contends Smith's testimony is essential.
Trump's legal team wants to postpone the deposition until January 2027, but the judge has signaled the case could be dismissed or sanctions imposed if Trump refuses to appear.
The BBC is not subject to the financial or political pressure that caused CBS and other outlets to settle with Trump, making it a defendant unlikely to blink.
Trump has a pattern of claiming exactly $10 billion in damages — including in a suit against the U.S. government over an IRS leak during his first term — suggesting a strategic playbook of filing massive suits to extract settlements.
Trump avoids depositions because being under oath risks perjury given his history of false statements, and discovery would force disclosure of his true wealth, which he has fought to keep private.
Notable quotes
“he really chose the wrong the wrong defendant because they are not blinking and they have a right to depose him”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:19“Being under oath is a terrible thing for Donald Trump because we know that he is a compulsive liar”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:52“what Trump has been doing to these media firms and law firms has been its own form of extortion, its own... shakedown”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:03“he made this historic shocking you in fact horrific amount of money while being president”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:09“I suspect he would rather dismiss this case than be under oath anywhere on the planet”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:31Chapters
0:00 — Lawsuit background and deposition deadline: Trump filed a $10 billion defamation suit against the BBC in December 2025 over a January 6 documentary. A magistrate judge ordered Trump to submit to a deposition by December 11 with discovery closing December 18; Trump seeks to delay until January 2027.
1:36 — BBC seeks to depose Jack Smith: The BBC also wants to depose Jack Smith, arguing he has critical information. Trump opposes this citing executive privilege, but the BBC contends Smith's testimony is essential to the case.
2:13 — Presidential immunity and Clinton v. Jones precedent: The Supreme Court unanimously held in Clinton v. Jones that a sitting president has no temporary immunity from civil litigation for unofficial conduct predating the presidency. Trump's situation is stronger for compelled testimony because he voluntarily initiated the suit.
3:00 — BBC's deposition goals: damages, evidence, impact: The BBC wants to depose Trump to learn what evidence supports his claim, how he substantiates $10 billion in damages, and whether the documentary — which never aired in the U.S. — caused any actual reputational harm.
3:37 — BBC refuses to settle unlike other outlets: Unlike CBS and other media entities pressured by Trump's donors, the BBC is not subject to that leverage and is fighting the case rather than settling.
5:45 — Trump's pattern of $10 billion damages claims: Trump has repeatedly claimed exactly $10 billion in damages — including against the U.S. government over an IRS leak — revealing a playbook of filing massive suits to pressure defendants into settling rather than litigating.
7:09 — Trump avoids wealth disclosure and perjury risk: Trump has fought to prevent disclosure of his true wealth, which filings show grew enormously during his presidency. Being under oath risks perjury given his history of false statements, making him likely to dismiss the case rather than testify.
9:39 — E. Jean Carroll deposition and possible dismissal: Trump performed poorly in the E. Jean Carroll deposition, misidentifying her. With a Trump-appointed judge presiding, the key question is whether Trump will move to dismiss his own case to avoid a deposition.
Speakers
Speaker 1 — Host
Speaker 2 — Legal analyst