TLDR
Mythical Kitchen host Josh and Tasting History's Max Miller play a game identifying fake historical dishes across three eras. In the ancient round, Max serves four dishes including a Hittite stew that's revealed as fake due to anachronistic jameed (fermented yogurt). In the medieval round, Josh serves four dishes including a fabricated 'frog and cockpie' from a nonexistent House of Beaufort manuscript. In the modern round, the team collaborates to spot a fake 1960s magazine recipe for creamed vegetable pancakes with canned peach among real gelatin-based horrors.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Galen, the father of humoral theory, coined 'wolf peach' for a mythical poisonous fruit — later applied to tomatoes when they arrived in Europe, leading some to speculate Galen had syphilis-induced hallucinations.
Medieval sauces routinely used heavily burnt bread as thickener and colorant, with recipes explicitly instructing to burn bread black — a technique that tastes terrible to modern palates.
The word 'ceviche' traces directly to 'sikbaj' (Persian for vinegar stew) through Spanish 'escabeche' and Peruvian indigenous cooking techniques adopted by Spanish sailors.
John of Gaunt, one of England's wealthiest men, employed cooks who hid live chickens and frogs in pastry cases for banquet entertainment — then served the same animals in pie the next day.
Weight Watchers rebranded to 'WW' because people found 'Weight Watchers' offensive, yet the acronym still stands for Weight Watchers.
Key takeaways
Historical recipes often lack quantities, forcing modern cooks to interpret proportions and techniques through trial and error.
The fake ancient dish (Hittite stew) was exposed by a single anachronistic ingredient — jameed, a Persian fermented yogurt from 1000 years later — despite all other ingredients being period-accurate.
Sikbaj, a 10th-century vinegared lamb stew, is the direct ancestor of ceviche, escabeche, aguachile, and even British fish and chips through cultural transmission across empires.
Medieval Europeans genuinely believed barnacle geese grew from barnacles on driftwood, classifying them as fish to permit consumption during Lent — a belief Pope Innocent III had to explicitly forbid in 1215.
The fake medieval dish (frog and cockpie) was invented with plausible-sounding details but betrayed by its modest seasoning — a household as wealthy as John of Gaunt's would have used expensive spices, not just herbs.
1950s-60s American cookbooks produced gelatin-heavy 'dessert' deviled eggs and tomato aspic refreshers driven by publisher demands for structured recipe categories, not culinary logic.
The fake modern dish (creamed vegetable pancakes with canned peach) was a plausible fabrication because mid-century magazines often printed unnamed, corporate-sponsored recipes at article bottoms.
Notable quotes
“Food didn't get good until like 1938.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:10“Everyone figured out how to do a haggis because you had to eat them.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:47“They also thought beaver was okay to eat, so.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:06“The fact that she didn't have a name for this, but she admitted that she didn't have a name before we asked. It's not like we tripped her up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 39:00“I think if you did, like it's almost not creative enough for you to have come up with.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:44“When you asked me for the manuscript number, I was like, surely — I wasn't thinking back. I don't know why.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:55Chapters
0:48 — Ancient History Round: Max presents four ancient dishes — Hittite stew, Jiangxi liver skewers, Lamb Battimakam, and Galen's snails — challenging Josh to identify the fake. The Hittite stew is revealed as fake due to anachronistic jameed.
15:59 — Middle Ages Round: Josh presents four medieval dishes — sikbaj, monk's stuffed egg soup, barnacle goose, and frog and cockpie — for Max to evaluate. The frog and cockpie is exposed as a fabrication with a nonexistent manuscript source.
29:14 — Modern History Round: The team collaborates on post-1500 dishes including Jelly Devils, tomato aspic, creamed vegetable pancakes, and Almonds in a Haystack. They correctly identify the unnamed magazine recipe as the fake.
Speakers
Josh — Host
Max — Guest
Ash — Culinary Producer