Who Can Spot The Fake Historical Dish? (ft. Tasting History)

Original Media · 41m · English · YouTube · Mythical Kitchen

TLDR

Mythical Kitchen host Josh and Tasting History's Max Miller play a game identifying fake historical dishes across three eras. In the ancient round, Max serves four dishes including a Hittite stew that's revealed as fake due to anachronistic jameed (fermented yogurt). In the medieval round, Josh serves four dishes including a fabricated 'frog and cockpie' from a nonexistent House of Beaufort manuscript. In the modern round, the team collaborates to spot a fake 1960s magazine recipe for creamed vegetable pancakes with canned peach among real gelatin-based horrors.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Galen, the father of humoral theory, coined 'wolf peach' for a mythical poisonous fruit — later applied to tomatoes when they arrived in Europe, leading some to speculate Galen had syphilis-induced hallucinations.

•

Medieval sauces routinely used heavily burnt bread as thickener and colorant, with recipes explicitly instructing to burn bread black — a technique that tastes terrible to modern palates.

•

The word 'ceviche' traces directly to 'sikbaj' (Persian for vinegar stew) through Spanish 'escabeche' and Peruvian indigenous cooking techniques adopted by Spanish sailors.

•

John of Gaunt, one of England's wealthiest men, employed cooks who hid live chickens and frogs in pastry cases for banquet entertainment — then served the same animals in pie the next day.

•

Weight Watchers rebranded to 'WW' because people found 'Weight Watchers' offensive, yet the acronym still stands for Weight Watchers.

Key takeaways

•

Historical recipes often lack quantities, forcing modern cooks to interpret proportions and techniques through trial and error.

•

The fake ancient dish (Hittite stew) was exposed by a single anachronistic ingredient — jameed, a Persian fermented yogurt from 1000 years later — despite all other ingredients being period-accurate.

•

Sikbaj, a 10th-century vinegared lamb stew, is the direct ancestor of ceviche, escabeche, aguachile, and even British fish and chips through cultural transmission across empires.

•

Medieval Europeans genuinely believed barnacle geese grew from barnacles on driftwood, classifying them as fish to permit consumption during Lent — a belief Pope Innocent III had to explicitly forbid in 1215.

•

The fake medieval dish (frog and cockpie) was invented with plausible-sounding details but betrayed by its modest seasoning — a household as wealthy as John of Gaunt's would have used expensive spices, not just herbs.

•

1950s-60s American cookbooks produced gelatin-heavy 'dessert' deviled eggs and tomato aspic refreshers driven by publisher demands for structured recipe categories, not culinary logic.

•

The fake modern dish (creamed vegetable pancakes with canned peach) was a plausible fabrication because mid-century magazines often printed unnamed, corporate-sponsored recipes at article bottoms.

Notable quotes

“Food didn't get good until like 1938.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:10

“Everyone figured out how to do a haggis because you had to eat them.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:47

“They also thought beaver was okay to eat, so.”

▸ Notable quotes · 22:06

“The fact that she didn't have a name for this, but she admitted that she didn't have a name before we asked. It's not like we tripped her up.”

▸ Notable quotes · 39:00

“I think if you did, like it's almost not creative enough for you to have come up with.”

▸ Notable quotes · 35:44

“When you asked me for the manuscript number, I was like, surely — I wasn't thinking back. I don't know why.”

▸ Notable quotes · 27:55

Chapters

•

0:48 — Ancient History Round: Max presents four ancient dishes — Hittite stew, Jiangxi liver skewers, Lamb Battimakam, and Galen's snails — challenging Josh to identify the fake. The Hittite stew is revealed as fake due to anachronistic jameed.

•

15:59 — Middle Ages Round: Josh presents four medieval dishes — sikbaj, monk's stuffed egg soup, barnacle goose, and frog and cockpie — for Max to evaluate. The frog and cockpie is exposed as a fabrication with a nonexistent manuscript source.

•

29:14 — Modern History Round: The team collaborates on post-1500 dishes including Jelly Devils, tomato aspic, creamed vegetable pancakes, and Almonds in a Haystack. They correctly identify the unnamed magazine recipe as the fake.

Speakers

•

Josh — Host

•

Max — Guest

•

Ash — Culinary Producer

⋮