TLDR
The hosts analyze how Ben Shapiro and centrist Democrats use identical talking points to dismiss progressive victories, particularly Abdul El-Sayed's 7-point win in Michigan, by claiming he 'underperformed' — a tactic previously used against Zohran Mamdani in NYC and Troy Jackson in Maine. They argue this reveals a coordinated messaging campaign from the Israel lobby/APAC to undermine pro-Palestinian candidates.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
APAC's $55M in losing expenditures in a single midterm cycle undermines their claimed electoral effectiveness.
The two Senate candidates who explicitly said 'genocide' (El-Sayed and Jackson) both won, contradicting the centrist claim that the term is politically toxic.
Joel Rubin claimed he hasn't worked at J Street since 2009, yet J Street's official account aggressively defended him in replies — suggesting ongoing ties.
Haley Stevens, a white non-Jewish representative, was positioned as the face of 'Jewish voter concerns' against a Muslim candidate.
Susan Collins (most anti-Trump Republican) won easily in Maine, while Trump-aligned Republicans lost — yet centrists argue Democrats must move right to win.
Key takeaways
Ben Shapiro's post-election analysis mirrors centrist Democratic consultants and APAC-aligned Democrats word-for-word, suggesting coordinated messaging.
The 'underperformed' narrative moves goalposts: first predicting losses, then claiming victories weren't large enough despite 7+ point margins.
APAC spent $84.1M in the midterms, with $55M backing losing candidates — contradicting claims that their strategy wins elections.
Democratic establishment figures (Hillary Scholten, Haley Stevens, Elissa Slotkin) withheld endorsements or attacked progressive candidates, likely suppressing turnout.
Joel Rubin (former J Street) at Crooked Con denied Gaza constitutes genocide and claimed saying 'genocide' hurts candidates — but the two Senate candidates who used the term (El-Sayed and Jackson) both won.
Kamala Harris's campaign collapsed after moderating on Gaza and blocking a Palestinian speaker at the DNC, following consultant advice to 'say nothing.'
Third Way and similar groups recycle the same 'underperformed' argument against every progressive winner (Mamdani, El-Sayed), ignoring establishment sabotage.
The hosts argue the Democratic Party is burning credibility with its base through arrogance, Israel lobby alignment, and sabotage of Black and Muslim candidates.
Notable quotes
“Ben Shapiro coincidentally sounds exactly like Democratic consultants, centrist Democrats, APAC Democrats.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:00“His argument is that the Islamophobia didn't work well enough. And we saw this a little while ago at Crooked Con.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:15“If it's not a genocide, then what is it? Like starvation, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, whatever you want to say.”
▸ Notable quotes · 7:43“APAC spent $84.1 million in this midterm and 55 million of it was losing money.”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:23“They are the drag. They are the reason that these candidates underperform because they are the ones that have an issue with genocide. But guess what? There's not enough of them to cause them to lose. We don't need them to win.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:57“It's like they just typed into chat GPT: what would the racist Israel lobby's tactic be against a Muslim in a Democratic primary? And they came out with the same answer for both.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:30Chapters
0:00 — Ben Shapiro's Failed Predictions & Mirrored Talking Points: Hosts replay Ben Shapiro's incorrect Senate prediction (52-56 GOP) and show his post-election analysis of El-Sayed's Michigan win mirrors centrist Democratic consultants almost word-for-word, claiming Islamophobia 'worked but not enough.'
3:00 — The 'Underperformed' Goalpost-Shifting Tactic: Centrists move goalposts: first predicting El-Sayed would lose, then claiming his 7-point win (vs. projected double digits) is underperformance — ignoring that polls were wrong and establishment Democrats withheld support.
4:30 — Crooked Con & Joel Rubin's Genocide Denial: At Crooked Con, former J Street official Joel Rubin denies Gaza genocide, claims saying 'genocide' hurts candidates — but the two Senate candidates who said it (El-Sayed, Jackson) both won. Audience pushes back.
8:00 — Kamala Harris's Collapse After Moderating on Gaza: Harris nosedived after DNC blocked Palestinian speaker and consultants (Sarah Longwell, Never Trumpers) advised her to 'say nothing' and offer 'no daylight' from Biden — contradicting the 'moderation wins' theory.
10:00 — Recycled Playbook: Zohran Mamdani & Troy Jackson: Third Way used identical 'underperformed Harris by 18 points' argument against Mamdani in NYC mayoral race, ignoring lack of Schumer/Jeffries endorsement. Same tactic used against Troy Jackson in Maine after DC operatives pressured him to drop 'genocide' language.
16:00 — APAC's Losing Record & Democratic Establishment Sabotage: APAC spent $84.1M ($55M on losers). Democratic leaders (Janet Mills, Hillary Scholten, Haley Stevens, Elissa Slotkin) withheld endorsements or attacked progressive candidates, then blame candidates for 'underperformance.'
Speakers
Host 1 — Primary host
Host 2 — Co-host
Host 3 — Co-host
Eli Clifton — Referenced journalist