TLDR
The host recreates In-N-Out Double Doubles, McDonald's Big Macs, and Five Guys cheeseburgers at home using $50 of groceries to compare cost and taste against buying them at the restaurants. Homemade versions cost significantly less: In-N-Out dupes at $4.11 each (43% cheaper), Big Mac dupes at $3.28 (107% cheaper), and Five Guys dupes at $7.06 (84% cheaper). McDonald's emerges as the biggest markup at 107% over homemade cost.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
McDonald's Big Mac has the highest markup (107%) despite having the least beef (only 3 oz total) and cheapest ingredients.
The homemade Big Mac tasted better than the real one because McDonald's beef patties taste like 'under-seasoned sausage' rather than beef.
Five Guys intentionally does not salt their beef patties, claiming they want the beef flavor to shine — but the host found the result bland and unseasoned.
Pusha T wrote McDonald's 'I'm Lovin' It' jingle (ba-da-ba-ba-ba).
The original Thousand Island dressing recipe contained raisins, hard-boiled eggs, and almonds — nothing like the modern mayo-ketchup-relish version.
Key takeaways
With $50 of groceries, the host made 12 In-N-Out-style Double Doubles at $4.11 each versus buying 7 at $5.90 each — a 43% savings, though the real In-N-Out still tasted more harmonious due to fresher produce and better bun architecture.
The homemade Big Mac cost $3.28 to make versus $6.79 at McDonald's — a 107% markup — and actually tasted better because the 80/20 beef had real beef flavor compared to McDonald's under-seasoned, sausage-like patties.
Five Guys burgers contain 7-8 ounces of beef (vs 3 oz for Big Mac, 4 oz for Double Double), making the homemade version $7.06 each versus $12.99 at the restaurant — an 84% markup — but Five Guys doesn't salt their beef, which the host considers a fatal flaw.
Beef is the primary cost driver across all three burgers; the host used 80/20 ground beef at ~$5/lb, and even at that price, homemade burgers cost $3-7 each depending on patty size.
The host explains fast food price inflation through 'rockets and feathers' economics: prices shoot up like rockets during crises (pandemic, drought, conflict) but drift down like feathers, staying artificially high as long as demand remains elastic.
In-N-Out sources produce within 24 hours of each store, giving them the freshest lettuce and tomatoes in fast food, which contributes to why their burgers still taste better than the homemade versions despite the cost savings.
The Big Mac's special sauce contains no ketchup — just mayo, relish, mustard, and spices — and the host's version (In-N-Out spread minus ketchup) replicated it nearly perfectly.
Five Guys was founded in 1986 when Jerry and Janie Murrell asked their three sons whether they wanted college or a business; the sons chose business, and the chain is named after the five men (Jerry + four sons).
Notable quotes
“Fast food for our parents was an indulgence. Fast food for us was a cheap necessity. Fast food for our kids will again be an expensive indulgence.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:02“Economists, they use the term rockets and feathers. Prices go up like a rocket and come down like a feather.”
▸ Notable quotes · 21:10“McDonald's beef don't really taste like beef. You know what I mean? That tastes like an under-seasoned sausage patty.”
▸ Notable quotes · 27:01“I think McDonald's is officially the winner of biggest scammer in fast food. Everyone give it up for 'em. Give it up for McDonald's with a 107% increase from homemade to store bought.”
▸ Notable quotes · 30:53“In-N-Out, still a tremendous value for what you're actually getting. And then Five Guys, hey man, if you really need a half pound of beef in your life, and sometimes you do, it's pretty damn delicious.”
▸ Notable quotes · 31:06Chapters
0:00 — Premise and setup: The host explains the experiment: compare $50 spent at three fast food burger chains (McDonald's, In-N-Out, Five Guys) versus $50 of groceries to recreate each burger at home, motivated by rising fast food prices.
1:29 — In-N-Out Double Double recreation: The host builds an In-N-Out Double Double dupe: thousand island spread, whole grilled onions, fresh produce, toasted buns, and 2oz smashed patties with Kraft Deluxe American cheese. Makes 12 burgers for $49.20 ($4.11 each) vs 7 purchased at $5.90 each.
8:34 — Big Mac recreation: The host recreates the Big Mac: special sauce (mayo, relish, mustard, no ketchup), 1.5oz patties, shredded lettuce, minced onions, pickles, triple-decker bun. Homemade cost $3.28 vs $6.79 at McDonald's (107% markup) and tastes better due to real beef flavor.
16:56 — Five Guys recreation: The host builds a Five Guys 'all the way' burger with grilled onions, mushrooms, mayo, ketchup, mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickles on a foil-wrapped bun. Uses 3.4oz unsalted patties. Homemade cost $7.06 vs $12.99 (84% markup) but Five Guys doesn't salt beef.
21:04 — Price analysis and economics: The host breaks down the cost comparisons, explains 'rockets and feathers' pricing dynamics, and declares McDonald's the biggest ripoff at 107% markup, while acknowledging In-N-Out's value and Five Guys' portion size.
25:00 — Taste test and conclusion: Side-by-side taste tests: In-N-Out still wins for harmony, homemade Big Mac beats McDonald's, Five Guys is massive but bland. Host concludes with value rankings and feeds leftovers to the office.
Speakers
Host — Host/Chef
Taylor — Crew member
Blaine — Mythical PA
Ash — Crew member
Crew — Production crew