VERITY MOVIE REACTION – We Don’t Know What To Believe!! | Colleen Hoover | Amazon Studios

Original Media · 1h 13m · English · YouTube · Reel Rejects

TLDR

Tara and Roxy (the 'She Jakes') react in real-time to the psychological thriller 'Verity' (2024), based on Colleen Hoover's novel, starring Dakota Johnson, Josh Hartnett, and Anne Hathaway. They discuss the film's ambiguous ending — whether Verity's manuscript confession or her exculpatory letter is true — and praise the performances, direction by Michael Showalter, and soundtrack, noting the stark contrast between the 31% critic score and 72% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The hosts initially assumed the film was horror but found it to be a psychological thriller with an unreliable narrator structure.

•

Verity's 'autobiography' opens with a meta warning: 'A writer should never have the audacity to write about themselves... One should only walk away from an autobiography with distaste for its author.'

•

The nurse character (played by Irina Dvorovenko, known from 'The Americans' and 'Flesh and Bone') is intensely creepy but ultimately a red herring with no payoff.

•

Josh Hartnett's character drives a Honda Civic despite wearing expensive suits — a detail the hosts found oddly specific and character-revealing.

•

Colleen Hoover wrote a bonus chapter for the 2022 deluxe edition but explicitly stated it was not a sequel setup; she joked about exploring an adult Crew someday.

Key takeaways

•

The film centers on Lowen (Dakota Johnson) hired to ghostwrite for bestselling author Verity Crawford (Anne Hathaway), who is supposedly catatonic after a car accident.

•

Verity's secret autobiography manuscript reveals she may have murdered her daughter Harper and manipulated her husband Jeremy (Josh Hartnett).

•

A late twist introduces Verity's letter claiming the manuscript was just a writing exercise ('antagonistic journaling') and that Jeremy drugged her and tried to kill her in a staged car crash.

•

The ending deliberately refuses certainty — the audience cannot know whether the manuscript or the letter is true, making 'truth' and 'perspective' the central themes.

•

Dakota Johnson's character Lowen is drawn into the Crawfords' world, potentially becoming a villain herself by wanting to replace Verity.

•

Michael Showalter's direction balances thriller, romance, and dark comedy tones; the hosts highlight Anne Hathaway's committed performance despite limited screen time.

•

The soundtrack is noted as exceptional and emotionally resonant throughout the film.

•

Critics rated the film 31% on Rotten Tomatoes while audiences gave it 72%, a split the hosts attribute to the film being a fun, discussable thriller rather than 'prestige' cinema.

Notable quotes

“I don't know what the [__] answer is. I don't know. Um and I think that that's really cool.”

▸ Notable quotes · 65:00

“The movie is telling us not to be so certain that we know what the answer is. And so I'm taking that at face value.”

▸ Notable quotes · 65:18

“Be careful what you want to believe, right? Like in this scenario, Dakota Johnson wants to believe... this woman is a raging [__] whose life I'm going to steal.”

▸ Notable quotes · 65:47

“Each novel in your series is based on nine moral and ethical guidelines. Which of those themes was the most fun to corrupt? Truth.”

▸ Notable quotes · 58:00

“I'm really glad that they didn't just leave it like... it's just too straightforward. Like it's just too simple.”

▸ Notable quotes · 65:35

“This was a 31% on the tomato meter. Verity does with 72% audience score. Yeah, it was a great time.”

▸ Notable quotes · 69:31

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Movie Setup: Hosts Tara and Roxy introduce themselves as the 'She Jakes,' explain they're watching 'Verity' (2024) based on Colleen Hoover's novel, and set up their reaction format.

•

1:00 — Opening Scenes: Lowen Meets Jeremy: Lowen (Dakota Johnson) witnesses a gruesome accident, meets Jeremy (Josh Hartnett) in a coffee shop bathroom, and they bond over shared trauma — her mother's death, his daughter's drowning.

•

7:00 — The Job Offer: Jeremy and his lawyer offer Lowen $75k/book (3 books, 6 months) to finish Verity's series. Lowen hesitates but considers it due to debt and eviction.

•

12:00 — Arrival at the Crawford Estate: Lowen moves into the Vermont estate, meets the creepy nurse Anna, sees catatonic Verity, and discovers Verity's autobiography manuscript on a thumb drive.

•

19:00 — Reading the Manuscript: Lowen reads Verity's disturbing autobiography revealing hatred for her children, possible murder of daughter Harper, and manipulation of Jeremy. Flashbacks show Verity and Jeremy's toxic relationship.

•

35:00 — Romance & Suspicion: Lowen and Jeremy grow close; Lowen suspects Verity may be faking her condition. She finds a mysterious yellow vial and cameras in Verity's room.

•

47:00 — The Confrontation: Lowen shows Jeremy the manuscript. He reads it, appears devastated, but then Lowen discovers Verity's letter claiming the manuscript was a writing exercise and Jeremy tried to kill her.

•

55:00 — The Ambiguous Ending & Discussion: Verity dies (apparently); Lowen and Jeremy cover it up. The film ends with Lowen uncertain which version is true. Hosts discuss performances, direction, soundtrack, and critic/audience score disparity.

Speakers

•

Tara — Co-host

•

Roxy — Co-host

⋮