TLDR
Tara and Roxy (the 'She Jakes') react in real-time to the psychological thriller 'Verity' (2024), based on Colleen Hoover's novel, starring Dakota Johnson, Josh Hartnett, and Anne Hathaway. They discuss the film's ambiguous ending — whether Verity's manuscript confession or her exculpatory letter is true — and praise the performances, direction by Michael Showalter, and soundtrack, noting the stark contrast between the 31% critic score and 72% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The hosts initially assumed the film was horror but found it to be a psychological thriller with an unreliable narrator structure.
Verity's 'autobiography' opens with a meta warning: 'A writer should never have the audacity to write about themselves... One should only walk away from an autobiography with distaste for its author.'
The nurse character (played by Irina Dvorovenko, known from 'The Americans' and 'Flesh and Bone') is intensely creepy but ultimately a red herring with no payoff.
Josh Hartnett's character drives a Honda Civic despite wearing expensive suits — a detail the hosts found oddly specific and character-revealing.
Colleen Hoover wrote a bonus chapter for the 2022 deluxe edition but explicitly stated it was not a sequel setup; she joked about exploring an adult Crew someday.
Key takeaways
The film centers on Lowen (Dakota Johnson) hired to ghostwrite for bestselling author Verity Crawford (Anne Hathaway), who is supposedly catatonic after a car accident.
Verity's secret autobiography manuscript reveals she may have murdered her daughter Harper and manipulated her husband Jeremy (Josh Hartnett).
A late twist introduces Verity's letter claiming the manuscript was just a writing exercise ('antagonistic journaling') and that Jeremy drugged her and tried to kill her in a staged car crash.
The ending deliberately refuses certainty — the audience cannot know whether the manuscript or the letter is true, making 'truth' and 'perspective' the central themes.
Dakota Johnson's character Lowen is drawn into the Crawfords' world, potentially becoming a villain herself by wanting to replace Verity.
Michael Showalter's direction balances thriller, romance, and dark comedy tones; the hosts highlight Anne Hathaway's committed performance despite limited screen time.
The soundtrack is noted as exceptional and emotionally resonant throughout the film.
Critics rated the film 31% on Rotten Tomatoes while audiences gave it 72%, a split the hosts attribute to the film being a fun, discussable thriller rather than 'prestige' cinema.
Notable quotes
“I don't know what the [__] answer is. I don't know. Um and I think that that's really cool.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:00“The movie is telling us not to be so certain that we know what the answer is. And so I'm taking that at face value.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:18“Be careful what you want to believe, right? Like in this scenario, Dakota Johnson wants to believe... this woman is a raging [__] whose life I'm going to steal.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:47“Each novel in your series is based on nine moral and ethical guidelines. Which of those themes was the most fun to corrupt? Truth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 58:00“I'm really glad that they didn't just leave it like... it's just too straightforward. Like it's just too simple.”
▸ Notable quotes · 65:35“This was a 31% on the tomato meter. Verity does with 72% audience score. Yeah, it was a great time.”
▸ Notable quotes · 69:31Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Movie Setup: Hosts Tara and Roxy introduce themselves as the 'She Jakes,' explain they're watching 'Verity' (2024) based on Colleen Hoover's novel, and set up their reaction format.
1:00 — Opening Scenes: Lowen Meets Jeremy: Lowen (Dakota Johnson) witnesses a gruesome accident, meets Jeremy (Josh Hartnett) in a coffee shop bathroom, and they bond over shared trauma — her mother's death, his daughter's drowning.
7:00 — The Job Offer: Jeremy and his lawyer offer Lowen $75k/book (3 books, 6 months) to finish Verity's series. Lowen hesitates but considers it due to debt and eviction.
12:00 — Arrival at the Crawford Estate: Lowen moves into the Vermont estate, meets the creepy nurse Anna, sees catatonic Verity, and discovers Verity's autobiography manuscript on a thumb drive.
19:00 — Reading the Manuscript: Lowen reads Verity's disturbing autobiography revealing hatred for her children, possible murder of daughter Harper, and manipulation of Jeremy. Flashbacks show Verity and Jeremy's toxic relationship.
35:00 — Romance & Suspicion: Lowen and Jeremy grow close; Lowen suspects Verity may be faking her condition. She finds a mysterious yellow vial and cameras in Verity's room.
47:00 — The Confrontation: Lowen shows Jeremy the manuscript. He reads it, appears devastated, but then Lowen discovers Verity's letter claiming the manuscript was a writing exercise and Jeremy tried to kill her.
55:00 — The Ambiguous Ending & Discussion: Verity dies (apparently); Lowen and Jeremy cover it up. The film ends with Lowen uncertain which version is true. Hosts discuss performances, direction, soundtrack, and critic/audience score disparity.
Speakers
Tara — Co-host
Roxy — Co-host