TLDR
Three hosts react in real-time to Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, praising Sam Raimi's horror-infused visual flair and Elizabeth Olsen's committed performance as Scarlet Witch, but criticizing the script's stiff dialogue, Wanda's unearned villain turn after WandaVision, and the wasted potential of the Illuminati cameo sequence. They conclude the film has spectacular highs but structural flaws, with ratings ranging from 6.5/10 to an enthusiastic 3/5 stars, and agree it deteriorates on rewatch as novelty fades.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Elizabeth Olsen was unhappy with Wanda's villain turn but gave a committed performance anyway, confirmed by the host's junket interview where she acknowledged the arc didn't work but thanked him for praising her performance.
The film's most "Raimi" moments (zombie Strange, Evil Dead-style possession) were likely compromises — the host notes the movie only "sings" when Raimi is "unleashed," suggesting studio restraint held back the director's full vision.
Despite making $1 billion, the hosts argue the film's financial success came from perfect marketing (post-No Way Home hype, Illuminati trailer reveals) rather than audience satisfaction, with rewatch value declining sharply.
Key takeaways
Sam Raimi's horror-infused direction shines in action sequences like zombie Strange and Scarlet Witch's rampage but feels restrained during dialogue scenes, creating a tonal inconsistency where the film only "sings" when Raimi is unleashed.
Elizabeth Olsen's performance as Scarlet Witch is universally praised as the film's highlight, selling a character arc the script doesn't properly earn after WandaVision; the host reveals from press junket experience that Olsen knew the turn didn't work but gave it her all anyway.
The Illuminati sequence introduces major characters (Professor X, Reed Richards, Black Bolt, Captain Carter, Captain Marvel) but wastes them in a perfunctory slaughter that lacks emotional weight — on rewatch, the hosts note "these guys don't do anything and these lines can belong to anyone."
The screenplay relies on exposition-heavy dialogue and introduces multiverse rules (dreamwalking, incursions, America Chavez's powers) without adequate setup, making stakes feel unearned and the narrative a series of cool scenes rather than a cohesive story.
Despite the title promising "Multiverse of Madness," the film only visits two alternate universes in depth, with the most imaginative visuals confined to a brief montage and the third act's zombie Strange sequence — one host suggests it should have been called "Doctor Strange: Incursion."
America Chavez functions more as a plot device than a character; her multiverse-travel ability serves the story's needs without meaningful development, and the hosts note she's "tricky" to use in future stories due to her overpowered nature.
The third act improves significantly when leaning into Raimi's style — zombie Strange conducting a soul-orchestra, the emotional Strange/Christine closure, and Wanda confronting her variant self provide the film's strongest character moments.
All three hosts agree the film deteriorates on rewatch: initial novelty of cameos and visuals masks structural weaknesses that become more apparent with each viewing, and the $1 billion box office came from perfect post-No Way Home marketing rather than audience satisfaction.
Notable quotes
“Insanely powerful now. And here's where the movie loses me. I mean, WandaVision set up that she would kind of go backwards in the post-credit scene. Yeah, this is just quite the leap of a lack of art. It's like they had an arc with 10 beats in it and they went from six to nine.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:03“I have one very easy fix to make me love this movie and it's simply doing one thing. 3/4 of the way into the movie, halfway through the third act, we reveal that this is an R Doctor Strange and this is all a multiverse, and then all of my issues go away because it lets the tone, it lets the Scarlet Witch, all that. And it's called Multiverse of Madness, and it could have gotten all the continuity of the MCU to this point cleaned, and they don't do it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 14:33“That's what the movie lacks inner conflict. That's what I was trying to say earlier, poorly, but like I just feel like I'm experiencing a series of scenes and they're really cool and they're well shot and they're well lit and they're well directed and, like, stuff's happening that's exciting, but that's about like it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:25“I do find the Illuminati like one of the most disappointed. I remember like the first time watching it being like oh my gosh, so cool. Yeah, the novelty is there, but then on the rewatch the second time I was like these guys don't do anything and these lines can belong to anyone.”
▸ Notable quotes · 40:04“This movie is at its best when when when they just let Sam Raimi do what he wants to do. A full lean in. Cheese it up.”
▸ Notable quotes · 61:54“Could have called it Doctor Strange uh Incursion. Cuz like we do see an Incursion event. It's the first time we do. It's a bit comic moment, but it's not madness, and there's moments of cool, but it's not madness.”
▸ Notable quotes · 81:43Chapters
0:00 — Opening Ratings & Expectations: The three hosts reveal their pre-watch ratings: Host gives 7.5/10, Greg loves it, Coy is skeptical. They debate whether the film holds up 10 years later (actually 2022) and set up the watch-along.
0:58 — Watch-Along: Opening Sequences & Raimi's Style: The hosts react to the cold open, Raimi's visual flair (wirework, color design, horror touches), Strange's wedding heartbreak, and the introduction of America Chavez. They note the film's strong energy and comic-book aesthetic.
13:03 — Watch-Along: Wanda's Turn & Illuminati Sequence: The hosts grapple with Wanda's abrupt villain turn post-WandaVision, criticizing the leap from episode 6 to 9 of her arc. They watch the Kamar-Taj battle, Scarlet Witch's rampage, and the Illuminati reveal — praising Olsen's performance but noting the members' perfunctory deaths.
42:00 — Watch-Along: Multiverse Travel & Zombie Strange Climax: Strange and Chavez traverse universes (Earth-838, the incursion world). The hosts enjoy the Raimi horror peak: zombie Strange conducting souls, the musical note battle, and Wanda confronting her variant self. They note the third act's emotional payoff for Strange/Christine.
64:00 — Post-Movie Ratings & Critique: Final ratings: Coy 6.5/10, Host enthusiastic 3/5 stars, Greg likes it more than the first film. They dissect the script's weaknesses, missed potential (revealing a variant Strange earlier), and how the film declines on rewatch despite visual strengths.
71:30 — Patron Comments: Wanda, Missed Potential & Raimi's Restraint: Patrons weigh in: Wanda's arc feels unearned (Vader comparison), the title overpromises, Raimi's horror flair is intermittently restrained, and the film's billion-dollar gross reflects marketing not satisfaction. Host shares junket anecdote confirming Olsen's dissatisfaction.
Speakers
Host — Primary narrator & film journalist
Greg — Co-host
Coy — Co-host