TLDR
Election analyst Jacob Rubashkin breaks down the 2024 election results, highlighting how Republican gerrymandering efforts largely backfired, the Mississippi Senate race remains undecided with ironic implications from an RNC lawsuit, and Democrats achieved a historic upset in Texas by winning the governorship for the first time in 36 years alongside a clean sweep of statewide offices.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The RNC sued Mississippi to block late-arriving mail-in ballots; had they won at the Supreme Court, Democrat Scott Colom would already be senator-elect because counting would have stopped on Election Day
Trump actively pushed for gerrymanders in Indiana and South Carolina that analyses suggest would have cost Republicans nearly all their seats in those states due to the strong Democratic turnout environment
In Texas-9, the Democratic winner received no national party support, was outspent, and still outperformed the top of the ticket by a massive margin in a heavily redrawn district
Republicans' North Carolina gerrymander was designed for a neutral environment but collapsed completely in a D+20 year, turning a planned 11-3 GOP map into a potential 10-11 Dem delegation
Key takeaways
Republican redistricting efforts failed to produce expected gains, netting only one seat in Texas while losing ground in North Carolina, Indiana, and South Carolina
The Mississippi Senate race is extraordinarily close (Democrat Scott Colom leads by ~1,700 votes/0.1%) with mail-in ballots still arriving — ballots the RNC sued to invalidate, creating irony that Republicans now need those ballots to win
North Carolina's Republican gerrymander nearly collapsed: Democrats may win 10-11 of 14 seats after Roy Cooper's 19-point gubernatorial win exposed overstretched GOP districts
Two stunning House upsets: Tennessee-4 (Trump +22) where scandal-plagued incumbent Scott DesJarlais trails, and Texas-9 (Trump +19) where Democrat Leticia Gutierrez leads by 16 points — a 35-point swing
Texas delivered Democrats' biggest victory: Gina Hinojosa won the governorship by 8 points, flipping every statewide office and the state House, ending a 36-year GOP hold
Notable quotes
“if they had won that case at the Supreme Court, which which they didn't, they lost it 5-4, if they had won um Scott Cillome would be the senator elect right now”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:25“they came essentially two percentage points away from complete and total catastrophe on this map”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:18“It is the most it will be the most Republican seat held by a Democrat anywhere in the country if if this result stands”
▸ Notable quotes · 16:29“outside of flipping the House and flipping the Senate, this is hands down the biggest victory for Democrats anywhere on this map”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:44“100% I mean, it's the equivalent of the Republicans flipping California”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:17Chapters
0:00 — Mississippi Senate Race and RNC Lawsuit Irony: The Mississippi Senate race remains undecided with Democrat Scott Colom leading by ~1,700 votes. Mail-in ballots arriving up to five business days post-election will determine the outcome. Ironically, the RNC sued to invalidate this law, but a GOP victory now depends on those same ballots being counted.
6:00 — Republican Gerrymandering Efforts Backfire Nationally: Republican redistricting plans across Florida, North Carolina, Texas, Alabama, and Tennessee failed to produce expected gains. They netted only one seat in Texas while losing two others, and the North Carolina map nearly collapsed entirely.
9:00 — North Carolina: Gerrymander Collapse: Republicans drew a map to limit Democrats to 3 of 14 seats, but Roy Cooper's 19-point gubernatorial win exposed overstretched GOP districts. Democrats may win 10-11 seats, a net gain of 6-7, because the map was tuned for a neutral environment, not a D+20 wave.
12:15 — Indiana and South Carolina: Avoided Disaster: Trump pushed for aggressive gerrymanders in Indiana and South Carolina. Analyses suggest Indiana's proposed map could have left Republicans with just one seat. Both states' legislatures declined, likely saving multiple GOP seats.
15:15 — House Upsets: Tennessee-4 and Texas-9: Two remarkable upsets: Tennessee-4 (Trump +22) where scandal-plagued incumbent Scott DesJarlais trails by hundreds of votes, and Texas-9 (Trump +19) where Democrat Leticia Gutierrez leads by 16 points — a 35-point swing with no national party support.
19:50 — Senate Upset: Mississippi: Mississippi qualifies as the biggest Senate surprise. Scott Colom's narrow lead in a Trump +22 state required a perfect storm: D+15 national environment, an agile candidate, and a complacent incumbent (Cindy Hyde-Smith).
21:45 — Texas Gubernatorial Sweep: Gina Hinojosa won the Texas governorship by 8 points — the first Democratic win in 36 years — defeating a three-term incumbent who outspent her $120M. Democrats also swept every statewide office and flipped the state House, a cataclysmic shift for national politics.
Speakers
Host (Brian) — Interviewer/Podcast Host
Jacob Rubashkin — Deputy Editor, Inside Elections