TLDR
This episode tells the remarkable story of Biddy Mason, an enslaved woman who walked over 2,000 miles to California with her Mormon enslaver Robert Smith, won her freedom in an 1856 Los Angeles court case despite laws barring Black testimony, and became one of the wealthiest Black women in the United States through shrewd real estate investments and community building. Her journey illuminates the overlooked history of slavery in the American West and the fragile nature of freedom in a free state that tolerated bondage.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
California, a free state, tolerated open slaveholding for years; officials turned a blind eye because the Mormon colony was prosperous and stable.
The only Confederate volunteer militia from a free state originated in Los Angeles, with about 250 Angelenos fighting for the South.
Robert Smith's enslaved workforce consisted almost entirely of women and children; he increased his human property through reproduction, likely raping the women he enslaved.
Biddy Mason never learned to read or write, yet she timed real estate purchases and sales with extraordinary precision, buying at the bottom of a post-war slump and selling at peaks.
Judge Benjamin Hayes, a former slaveholder who initially expressed paternalistic views, ruled in Mason's favor after Smith attempted to use force rather than legal means to reclaim his 'property.'
After her commercial building burned down in 1885, Mason — in her 60s and suffering from kidney disease — chose to rebuild a two-story commercial complex (Mason Block) rather than retire, cementing her fortune.
Key takeaways
Slavery existed de facto in California despite its 1849 constitutional ban, with San Bernardino hosting the largest slaveholding colony in the Far West.
Biddy Mason's enslaver Robert Smith became the largest slaveholder in the American West through forced reproduction, not purchase.
The Underground Railroad operated in the West, with Black and white allies helping enslaved people escape to freedom in Mexico and California.
Biddy Mason could not testify in open court because California law barred Black people from testifying against whites; the judge interviewed her privately to hear her testimony.
After winning freedom in 1856, Mason leveraged her midwifery skills and 'mother wit' to buy prime Los Angeles real estate, becoming the wealthiest Black person in the city by the 1870s.
She co-founded the First African Methodist Episcopal Church, the first Black church in Southern California, creating a lasting community institution.
Los Angeles was a Confederate hotbed during the Civil War, supplying the only Confederate volunteer militia from a free state, threatening Mason's hard-won freedom.
Mason's legacy endures: in 2024, the Los Angeles City Council voted to rename Pershing Square as Biddy Mason Park.
Notable quotes
“To Biddy, this Liberty Pole did not mean the beginning of a new chapter of freedom in her life. She remained enslaved. She remained the property of Robert Smith.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:02“I have always done what I was told to do.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:05“I have always been afraid of this trip to Texas and of course I want to remain with my family as a free woman in California.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:20“Biddy, Ellen, Ann, Harriet, Hannah, Ann, Lawrence, Nathaniel, Jane, Charles, Marion, Martha, Mary, and newborn Henry are entitled to their freedom and are free forever.”
▸ Notable quotes · 20:55“No one knew the value of property and money better than a slave. Because they were property.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:19“If you walked across the country and you've been a slave, what's a little fire? You can rebuild.”
▸ Notable quotes · 29:33Chapters
0:12 — Election Day 1864 and the Stakes for Biddy Mason: The episode opens on November 8, 1864, as Lincoln faces re-election against McClellan. A Confederate victory could undo the freedom of Biddy Mason, a formerly enslaved woman in Los Angeles, where 250 men have joined the only Confederate militia from a free state.
2:46 — The Mormon Wagon Train and a Moving Plantation: In 1848, Biddy Mason walks the Mormon Trail with Robert Smith's wagon train — 34 enslaved people, the largest such group on the Overland Trail. She endures dust, disease, and the constant threat of family separation, while her enslaver views the journey as a biblical Exodus.
10:31 — Slavery in a Free State: San Bernardino: Smith moves his enslaved laborers to San Bernardino in 1851. Despite California's constitutional ban on slavery, Mormon leaders and local officials ignore the law. Smith becomes the largest slaveholder in the Far West, running a prosperous wheat operation.
12:29 — Resistance and the Road to Court: By 1855, Smith plans to move to Texas. Biddy, aided by a Western Underground Railroad of Black and white allies, resists. In January 1856, the LA Sheriff serves a writ of habeas corpus, seizing Smith's human property and forcing a court hearing.
17:44 — The Trial and a Private Testimony: Biddy cannot testify in open court due to racial exclusion laws. Judge Benjamin Hayes, a former slaveholder, interviews her privately. She declares she does not wish to go to Texas and wants to remain free with her children. Hayes rules all 14 people free forever.
21:13 — Freedom, Danger, and Building Wealth: Free but vulnerable in a violent, Confederate-sympathizing Los Angeles, Mason chooses the surname Mason to reclaim her identity. She works as a midwife, buys land at the bottom of the market, and watches her investments quadruple as LA booms.
26:49 — Community, Church, and the Civil War Threat: Mason co-founds the First AME Church, the heart of Black Los Angeles. During the Civil War, a Confederate invasion from Texas threatens to reach California, but the rebels retreat. Lincoln's 1864 re-election secures her freedom.
29:29 — Mason Block, Legacy, and a Park: After a fire destroys her property in 1885, Mason rebuilds the two-story Mason Block, becoming one of the wealthiest Black women in the US. She dies known as 'Grandma Mason.' In 2024, Pershing Square is renamed Biddy Mason Park.
Speakers
John Errol (John Earl) — Host and narrator
Kevin Waite — Historian and guest expert
Jackie Braxton — Guest expert and descendant advocate