The 2nd College Football Playoff Rankins Are Here... Did They Get It Right?

Original Media · 35m · English · YouTube · The Pat McAfee Show

TLDR

Reese Davis joins the show to break down the latest College Football Playoff rankings, highlighting course corrections like Notre Dame rising to No. 5 and Indiana dropping without playing. The committee's Alabama-over-Tennessee decision despite the head-to-head result sparks debate, while Miami's steep fall to No. 7 without Malachi Thomas draws scrutiny. Davis also discusses Oregon's playoff path as the highest-ranked three-loss team, Lane Kiffin's hot seat at LSU, and why he trusts Marcus Freeman and CJ Carr more than any other coach-QB duo down the stretch. The conversation covers playoff expansion implications, Boise State's automatic bid controversy, and Notre Dame's statement win over Miami as a psychological turning point.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

A two-loss SEC team (Alabama) ranked ahead of an undefeated team from another conference (UCLA) is rare but not unprecedented — it happened multiple times in the CFP era, including last week.

•

Oregon's offensive coordinator was fired as Wyoming's OC less than a year ago; now he's coordinating a national title contender.

•

The projected first-round spread for Notre Dame (5) vs. Boise State (12) in a 12-team playoff is 21.5 points — the largest of any first-round matchup, while a 2014-style four-team playoff would have produced much tighter spreads.

•

Indiana is technically the 'reigning champion' of the 2024 season so far (only loss by inches), yet receives little national respect due to program history and schedule strength.

Key takeaways

•

The CFP committee made notable course corrections: Notre Dame jumped to No. 5 after beating Miami, Indiana dropped without playing due to weak strength of schedule, and UCLA rose after a dominant second half at Minnesota.

•

Alabama remains ahead of Tennessee despite the Volunteers' head-to-head win; the committee weighs full resumes and comparative data across all teams, not just head-to-head results.

•

Miami's drop from No. 1 to No. 7 reflects the committee wanting to see how they perform without Malachi Thomas, though their competitive loss to Notre Dame may earn future forgiveness.

•

Oregon (No. 16) is the highest-ranked three-loss team and has a plausible at-large path if they win out, especially with a potential Big Ten title game berth.

•

Reese Davis trusts Marcus Freeman and CJ Carr as the top coach-QB combo, giving Notre Dame the edge over Georgia's Kirby Smart and Gunner Stockton.

•

Lane Kiffin faces growing frustration at LSU after a home blowout loss to Alabama marked by questionable fourth-down decisions and a fourth-quarter collapse.

•

Notre Dame's win over Miami was a psychological must-win that showcased defensive depth and CJ Carr's poise, validating Freeman's leadership and the program's resilience.

•

Playoff expansion to 12 teams creates more access but risks diluting regular-season stakes; Davis acknowledges the appeal of more football but laments potential loss of 'every game matters' intensity.

Notable quotes

“The CFP ranking only one that matters.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:06

“I think they did some course correction, Pat, and they don't like to admit it uh that way, but I think you can look at a couple of rankings and see where that comes into play.”

▸ Notable quotes · 2:48

“You know, I I think the one thing that I still haven't reconciled completely is the thing that everybody's all hot and bothered about is the difference between Alabama and Tennessee.”

▸ Notable quotes · 4:53

“It was absolute must win. Not that they would have been eliminated, but I think for their psyche, they needed to come through in a game like that.”

▸ Notable quotes · 17:56

“Freeman and Carr.”

▸ Notable quotes · 24:16

“You do not have to be the best team in the country every Saturday. You just have to be the best team in the stadium.”

▸ Notable quotes · 28:06

Chapters

•

0:00 — CFP Rankings Overview & Course Corrections: Hosts establish that only the CFP ranking matters for playoff access. Reese Davis joins and identifies course corrections: Notre Dame rises to No. 5 after signature win, Indiana drops without playing due to weak opponent records, UCLA rises after dominant second half at Minnesota.

•

4:00 — Alabama vs. Tennessee Debate & Miami's Drop: Davis explains the committee's rationale for ranking Alabama over Tennessee despite the head-to-head loss: full resume comparison across all teams. Miami's drop to No. 7 is seen as a 'prove it without Malachi Thomas' signal, though their competitive loss may earn future forgiveness.

•

7:00 — Playoff Expansion & Format Implications: Discussion of 12-team playoff dynamics: projected spreads show massive mismatches in first round (e.g., Notre Dame vs. Boise State at 21.5), while a four-team format would yield tighter games. Hosts debate whether expanded access dilutes regular-season stakes.

•

11:00 — Boise State & Group of 5 Controversy: Iowa fan frustration over Boise State's automatic bid despite being ranked 11 spots below Iowa. Hosts debate whether Group of 5 champions deserve automatic access given recent first-round blowouts.

•

13:00 — Oregon's Path & Coaching Resilience Story: Oregon at No. 16 is highest-ranked three-loss team with plausible at-large path if they win out and reach Big Ten title game. Remarkable turnaround under first-year OC who was Wyoming's OC less than a year ago.

•

15:00 — Notre Dame's Statement Win Over Miami: Notre Dame's win called a psychological must-win. CJ Carr's poised performance, defensive depth despite five missing starters, and Marcus Freeman's leadership highlighted. Davis believes Notre Dame can win the national title.

•

21:00 — Lane Kiffin & LSU Under Pressure: LSU's home blowout loss to Alabama — marked by questionable fourth-down decisions and fourth-quarter collapse — inflames fan base. Kiffin's job is safe but leash is shorter; fans want fewer theatrics and more meaningful wins starting vs. Texas.

•

24:00 — Coach/QB Combos & Reese's Ballot: Davis picks Freeman/Carr as most trusted duo over Smart/Stockton. He reveals his AP ballot differences: rewards Utah for BYU win, keeps Indiana higher due to 'winning know-how,' wants to see UCLA against elite offense. Tone's 'Above Average Poll' puts Notre Dame No. 1.

Speakers

•

Reese Davis — Guest

•

Pat — Host

•

Ty — Host

•

Tone — Host

•

Darius — Host

•

Con man — Producer

•

Debut — Host

⋮