TLDR
Reese Davis joins the show to break down the latest College Football Playoff rankings, highlighting course corrections like Notre Dame rising to No. 5 and Indiana dropping without playing. The committee's Alabama-over-Tennessee decision despite the head-to-head result sparks debate, while Miami's steep fall to No. 7 without Malachi Thomas draws scrutiny. Davis also discusses Oregon's playoff path as the highest-ranked three-loss team, Lane Kiffin's hot seat at LSU, and why he trusts Marcus Freeman and CJ Carr more than any other coach-QB duo down the stretch. The conversation covers playoff expansion implications, Boise State's automatic bid controversy, and Notre Dame's statement win over Miami as a psychological turning point.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A two-loss SEC team (Alabama) ranked ahead of an undefeated team from another conference (UCLA) is rare but not unprecedented — it happened multiple times in the CFP era, including last week.
Oregon's offensive coordinator was fired as Wyoming's OC less than a year ago; now he's coordinating a national title contender.
The projected first-round spread for Notre Dame (5) vs. Boise State (12) in a 12-team playoff is 21.5 points — the largest of any first-round matchup, while a 2014-style four-team playoff would have produced much tighter spreads.
Indiana is technically the 'reigning champion' of the 2024 season so far (only loss by inches), yet receives little national respect due to program history and schedule strength.
Key takeaways
The CFP committee made notable course corrections: Notre Dame jumped to No. 5 after beating Miami, Indiana dropped without playing due to weak strength of schedule, and UCLA rose after a dominant second half at Minnesota.
Alabama remains ahead of Tennessee despite the Volunteers' head-to-head win; the committee weighs full resumes and comparative data across all teams, not just head-to-head results.
Miami's drop from No. 1 to No. 7 reflects the committee wanting to see how they perform without Malachi Thomas, though their competitive loss to Notre Dame may earn future forgiveness.
Oregon (No. 16) is the highest-ranked three-loss team and has a plausible at-large path if they win out, especially with a potential Big Ten title game berth.
Reese Davis trusts Marcus Freeman and CJ Carr as the top coach-QB combo, giving Notre Dame the edge over Georgia's Kirby Smart and Gunner Stockton.
Lane Kiffin faces growing frustration at LSU after a home blowout loss to Alabama marked by questionable fourth-down decisions and a fourth-quarter collapse.
Notre Dame's win over Miami was a psychological must-win that showcased defensive depth and CJ Carr's poise, validating Freeman's leadership and the program's resilience.
Playoff expansion to 12 teams creates more access but risks diluting regular-season stakes; Davis acknowledges the appeal of more football but laments potential loss of 'every game matters' intensity.
Notable quotes
“The CFP ranking only one that matters.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:06“I think they did some course correction, Pat, and they don't like to admit it uh that way, but I think you can look at a couple of rankings and see where that comes into play.”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:48“You know, I I think the one thing that I still haven't reconciled completely is the thing that everybody's all hot and bothered about is the difference between Alabama and Tennessee.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:53“It was absolute must win. Not that they would have been eliminated, but I think for their psyche, they needed to come through in a game like that.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:56“Freeman and Carr.”
▸ Notable quotes · 24:16“You do not have to be the best team in the country every Saturday. You just have to be the best team in the stadium.”
▸ Notable quotes · 28:06Chapters
0:00 — CFP Rankings Overview & Course Corrections: Hosts establish that only the CFP ranking matters for playoff access. Reese Davis joins and identifies course corrections: Notre Dame rises to No. 5 after signature win, Indiana drops without playing due to weak opponent records, UCLA rises after dominant second half at Minnesota.
4:00 — Alabama vs. Tennessee Debate & Miami's Drop: Davis explains the committee's rationale for ranking Alabama over Tennessee despite the head-to-head loss: full resume comparison across all teams. Miami's drop to No. 7 is seen as a 'prove it without Malachi Thomas' signal, though their competitive loss may earn future forgiveness.
7:00 — Playoff Expansion & Format Implications: Discussion of 12-team playoff dynamics: projected spreads show massive mismatches in first round (e.g., Notre Dame vs. Boise State at 21.5), while a four-team format would yield tighter games. Hosts debate whether expanded access dilutes regular-season stakes.
11:00 — Boise State & Group of 5 Controversy: Iowa fan frustration over Boise State's automatic bid despite being ranked 11 spots below Iowa. Hosts debate whether Group of 5 champions deserve automatic access given recent first-round blowouts.
13:00 — Oregon's Path & Coaching Resilience Story: Oregon at No. 16 is highest-ranked three-loss team with plausible at-large path if they win out and reach Big Ten title game. Remarkable turnaround under first-year OC who was Wyoming's OC less than a year ago.
15:00 — Notre Dame's Statement Win Over Miami: Notre Dame's win called a psychological must-win. CJ Carr's poised performance, defensive depth despite five missing starters, and Marcus Freeman's leadership highlighted. Davis believes Notre Dame can win the national title.
21:00 — Lane Kiffin & LSU Under Pressure: LSU's home blowout loss to Alabama — marked by questionable fourth-down decisions and fourth-quarter collapse — inflames fan base. Kiffin's job is safe but leash is shorter; fans want fewer theatrics and more meaningful wins starting vs. Texas.
24:00 — Coach/QB Combos & Reese's Ballot: Davis picks Freeman/Carr as most trusted duo over Smart/Stockton. He reveals his AP ballot differences: rewards Utah for BYU win, keeps Indiana higher due to 'winning know-how,' wants to see UCLA against elite offense. Tone's 'Above Average Poll' puts Notre Dame No. 1.
Speakers
Reese Davis — Guest
Pat — Host
Ty — Host
Tone — Host
Darius — Host
Con man — Producer
Debut — Host