TLDR
Arelli Garcia, a 25-year-old automotive service advisor from Salinas, California, vanished on September 22, 2022 after leaving her apartment at 6:34 AM — an hour later than her usual gym routine. Her bright red modified Honda Accord was found parked on a Highway 1 turnout near Big Sur, an hour from home, with her phone (in airplane mode), keys, and wallet locked inside. The driver's seat was pushed back for a taller person and the car's air suspension was not lowered as she always did, suggesting someone else drove it. Despite extensive searches, 62 interviews, and security footage showing her car passing a general store at 7:30 AM, no trace of Arelli has been found in nearly four years. Her family has protested for more transparency from law enforcement, and a similar disappearance of Kiley Gamill occurred five weeks earlier in the same area, though police deny a connection. The case remains unsolved with no suspects.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
A Google Maps Street View car happened to drive past Arelli's abandoned Honda at noon on the exact day she disappeared, capturing it on imagery still viewable today — an astronomically rare coincidence.
The senior detective stated the turnout where the car was found was not a major cliffside and had no fall risk, explicitly ruling out accidental death or suicide by jumping, contrary to what the Big Sur coastline might suggest.
Every single piece of camera footage — apartment, traffic, general store — was rendered useless for identifying the driver because Arelli's aftermarket window tint was too dark to see through, a modification she chose for her car.
Arelli's family did not know about her boyfriend Marcelo until after she vanished; her sisters explained that in their Hispanic household, bringing a partner home invites immediate marriage pressure, so keeping a new relationship private was culturally normal, not suspicious.
Police interviewed 62 people over the investigation but have identified zero persons of interest or suspects nearly four years later, despite having her phone, car, and multiple camera sightings of the vehicle.
Key takeaways
Arelli followed a strict daily routine — gym at 5:00-5:30 AM, shower and dress there, then work by 7:30 AM — so her 6:34 AM departure in gym clothes with no time to work out before her shift immediately signaled something was wrong to her sisters.
Her car was found on a random Highway 1 turnout with no trail or beach access, locked, with phone in airplane mode, keys and wallet inside, the driver's seat pushed back for someone taller than her 5'5" frame, and the air suspension raised instead of 'slammed' low as she always parked it — strongly indicating another person drove it there.
Security footage from her apartment shows her leaving alone at 6:34 AM, but heavily tinted windows prevent seeing if anyone was already inside the car; a later camera at Carmel Highlands General Store captured her car passing at 7:30 AM, placing it at the Big Sur turnout between 7:50-8:45 AM.
A Google Maps Street View car randomly photographed her parked Honda at noon that same day with a white SUV and silver sedan behind it; the occupants were tracked down and interviewed but provided no useful information.
Her phone and car were forensically examined from day one, but police have released no findings — no call logs, messages, location history, or vehicle telematics data — leaving the family with zero insight into who she may have been communicating with or where the car traveled.
The family's relationship with law enforcement deteriorated from initial cooperation to public protests by March 2023, citing lack of transparency, dismissed suggestions, and being barred from searching private ranch land near where the car was found.
Five weeks before Arelli vanished, 20-year-old Kiley Gamill disappeared from a few blocks away in Salinas; her body was found in Big Sur 30+ miles south of Arelli's car, but detectives on both cases and Kiley's mother say there is no connection, though both cases remain unsolved.
Arelli's sisters and mother maintain she would never have voluntarily gone to Big Sur on a work morning without telling anyone, and they believe if she did meet someone, she intended to return — making the pushed-back seat and un-slammed suspension the most chilling evidence that someone else controlled the car.
Notable quotes
“It doesn't matter what type of day you're having. If you see Arelli, you know you're going to be laughing.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:48“She would always tell us pretty much where she was going to be at, so it was very unlike her to disappear out of nowhere.”
▸ Notable quotes · 13:49“The way it was parked, it was not usually how she leaves it... the car was up. Like, obviously like makes us feel like it wasn't her driving, if that makes sense.”
▸ Notable quotes · 15:55“Everything was strange on the last day... It makes no sense.”
▸ Notable quotes · 23:43“This anguish of not knowing is killing me. It kills me not to know where my daughter, Arelli, is.”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:06“We pray every night she comes home.”
▸ Notable quotes · 35:44Chapters
0:08 — Introduction & Arelli's Background: Kendall Rae introduces the case of Arelli Garcia, a 25-year-old from Salinas who vanished on September 22, 2022. Arelli was the youngest of seven siblings, close with sisters Ellie and Veronica, worked as a service advisor at My Chevrolet, loved cars, and was studying to become an ultrasound technician.
3:54 — Arelli's Personality, Car Passion & Career: Sisters describe Arelli as bubbly, selfless, and routine-oriented. She modified her 2013 Honda Accord with a candy-apple red wrap, tinted windows, and air suspension she always lowered ('slammed') when parked. She was active in the local car club scene but transitioning to a medical career.
9:12 — Disappearance Day & Family's Discovery: On September 22, Arelli didn't show up for work. Her sister Ellie got a call from a coworker. Veronica had received a 6:56 AM text from Arelli but her reply failed to deliver. Find My iPhone showed Arelli's phone pinging in Big Sur, an hour away. Ellie and her husband drove there; Veronica filed a missing person report.
17:03 — Car Found in Big Sur — Suspicious Details: Ellie found Arelli's red Honda locked on a random turnout near Little Sur River Bridge with no trail access. The car was not backed in, not slammed (suspension raised), and the driver's seat was pushed back for a taller person. Phone, keys, wallet were inside; phone in airplane mode. No signs of foul play per police, but seat position is highly suspicious.
23:35 — Security Footage & Timeline Discrepancies: Apartment footage shows Arelli leaving at 6:34 AM (timestamp off by one hour) in gym clothes — an hour later than her usual 5:00-5:30 AM gym departure, leaving no time to work out and reach work by 7:30 AM. She wasn't wearing work attire. A Carmel Highlands General Store camera captured her car at 7:30 AM, placing arrival at the turnout 7:50-8:45 AM.
29:07 — Google Maps Capture & Investigation Status: A Google Maps Street View car photographed Arelli's parked Honda at noon with a white SUV and silver sedan behind it; occupants were interviewed but saw nothing. Police interviewed 62 people, found no suspects. Forensic exams of phone and car yielded no released information. No bank or digital activity since disappearance.
30:42 — Family Frustration & Protests: Family initially felt supported but later protested outside Salinas PD, citing diminished transparency, dismissed suggestions, and being barred from searching nearby private ranch land. Marches and rallies continued; mother Blanca says the anguish is killing her. Police cite understaffing but say tips are high priority.
38:40 — Theories & Similar Case of Kiley Gamill: Theories include stalking via her distinctive car, human trafficking, a staged breakdown kidnapping, or a serial killer. Five weeks prior, Kiley Gamill vanished from nearby Salinas; her body was found in Big Sur 30+ miles south. Police and Kiley's mother deny a connection. Both cases unsolved. $10,000 reward for Arelli.
Speakers
Kendall Rae — Host
Ellie — Arelli's sister
Veronica — Arelli's sister
Blanca — Arelli's mother
News reporters — News clips