TLDR
Democrat Scott Colom won a historic U.S. Senate race in Mississippi, becoming the first Democratic senator from the state in 44 years. He flipped 18 counties that voted for Trump in 2024, powered by 88% turnout in majority-Black counties and 8% crossover from Trump voters. The panel argues the South is competitive when Democrats invest in authentic, locally rooted campaigns that address kitchen-table issues.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Mississippi, the state with the highest percentage of Black voters, had not elected a Democratic senator in 44 years until a midterm with typically low turnout.
A Democrat won 18 counties that voted for Trump just two years earlier, with 8% of Trump voters crossing over in a deeply polarized state.
The winning campaign's most effective ad was a low-budget, locally produced spot featuring ordinary Mississippians reacting to the incumbent's 'pick another protein' comment about rising beef prices.
Key takeaways
Scott Colom's victory in Mississippi relied on a coalition of energized Black voters — turning out at 88% of 2024 presidential levels — and 8% of Trump voters crossing over, proving racially polarized voting can be overcome with an affirmative economic agenda.
The campaign's authenticity was decisive: viral ads like 'pick another protein' used local actors and Mississippi vernacular, making the race feel homegrown rather than a national party project, which resonated across racial lines.
Erin Haines argues the South is not permanently red but has been written off by the national Democratic Party and media; competitive races require believing the region is winnable and investing early, as Schumer did by recruiting Colom.
Jake Sherman says the Republican coalition that delivered majorities under Trump has fractured, returning the GOP to its 2012 position, and Democrats can sustain gains by passing affordability and healthcare bills that force Trump to veto popular legislation.
Mondaire Jones connects Colom's win to the civil rights lineage of Freedom Summer, Medgar Evers, and Fannie Lou Hamer — a multiracial coalition achieving what was 'inconceivable until recently' in a state with the nation's highest percentage of Black voters.
Donors initially rejected Colom as unwinnable; only after his viral momentum did outside money (including Soros family) arrive. The panel agrees early national investment would have helped, but the race's authenticity was its own asset.
Notable quotes
“Absolutely not. I mean, look, I think what we saw in this midterm elections is that the South is absolutely in play.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:46“I think you can't talk about the blue wave without talking about the black tsunami, right?”
▸ Notable quotes · 2:49“It's both. You'll recall that the last time I was on the show, when we talked about this, I said that it was always within reach for a Democrat to win statewide in Mississippi.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:17“Well, it is a Democratic state in the Senate. Right. I mean, this is a it's a seismic development.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:08“And Katie, I think I said this to you maybe off air, but but it feels to me like the Republican Party is right back where they were in 2012.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:43“I just got to say, the man who I think will be the next majority leader, Chuck Schumer, did a fantastic job in recruitment.”
▸ Notable quotes · 10:28Chapters
0:00 — Mississippi upset introduced: Panel introduces the historic Senate win by Democrat Scott Colom in Mississippi, the first Democratic senator from the state in 44 years.
0:23 — Why Colom won: perfect storm: Elyse Jordan explains the convergence of economic dissatisfaction, Black voter mobilization around redistricting, a charismatic candidate, and viral local ads that overcame donor skepticism.
1:48 — The South is not permanently red: Erin Haines argues the South is competitive when Democrats compete authentically, citing record Black turnout and white Southerners joining a multiracial coalition for a new Southern trajectory.
3:26 — Turnout data and crossover voters: Host presents data: 88% turnout in majority-Black counties versus 75% elsewhere, 99% retention of Harris counties, and 8% of Trump voters crossing to Colom.
4:42 — Historical significance and civil rights legacy: Mondaire Jones connects the victory to Freedom Summer, Medgar Evers, and Fannie Lou Hamer, calling it the most meaningful win of the cycle given Mississippi's history of racial violence and disenfranchisement.
5:56 — Capitol Hill reaction and GOP coalition fracture: Jake Sherman describes the seismic shift on Capitol Hill, arguing the Trump coalition has collapsed and Democrats can lock in gains by forcing vetoes on affordability and healthcare bills.
8:17 — Viral 'pick another protein' ad: Panel plays and discusses the homemade ad featuring Mississippians mocking the incumbent's dismissive comment about rising beef prices, crediting its authentic local voice for breaking through.
9:09 — Schumer recruitment and funding debate: Discussion of whether earlier national money would have helped or undermined authenticity; Mondaire Jones defends Schumer's allocation given finite resources and notes donor skepticism shifted only after Colom proved viable.
Speakers
Katie — Host
Jake Sherman — Panelist
Erin Haines — Panelist
Elyse Jordan — Panelist
Mondaire Jones — Panelist