TLDR
Mythical Kitchen celebrates Ben Schwartz's birthday with a wish-fulfillment episode where Ben uses a "wish phone" to request experiences including elevated childhood foods, a knight-costumed Josh, a choreographed dance, the culinary team cooking their signature dishes, basketball, video games, Josh demonstrating his collegiate weight-throwing skill, and a Lady-and-the-Tramp-style chili-dog ice cream kiss. The episode culminates in a crew group hug, a birthday shout-out to makeup artist Jillian, and a surprise visit from Rhett and Link.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Josh, the host, admits he is not a trained chef and would tell a real chef he's "a huge piece of shit" — despite being the face of a cooking show.
The crew has a custom soundboard with Josh's Sonic the Hedgehog voice impressions, including a bit about Sonic's human teeth controversy from the movie redesign.
Ben held a world record for speed-running a level in Crash Bandicoot 3, a fact he casually mentions mid-episode.
The "chili dog" ice cream dessert contains an actual hot dog bun toasted with butter and brown sugar, but the "weenie" is chocolate and the "chili" is raspberry-strawberry sauce.
Rhett and Link appear unannounced at the very end, revealing the episode was also a surprise reunion for Ben's birthday.
Key takeaways
Ben Schwartz gets a personalized birthday episode where every wish — food, activities, costumes — is granted by the Mythical Kitchen crew, turning the show into a variety showcase of his interests.
The culinary team each prepares a dish representing their cultural background or cooking passion: Ash's teriyaki potato skins, Vee's Mexican-Black fusion fried chicken and watermelon, Tony's Filipino-Salvadoran pork fried rice, and Colby's Nobu-inspired hamachi crudo.
Josh reveals he placed 10th in the PAC-12 indoor weight throw (35-pound weight, 61-foot personal best) and demonstrates the technique in the parking lot, a hidden athletic past unknown to Ben.
Ben and Josh share a staged but committed Lady-and-the-Tramp kiss via a chocolate "chili dog" ice cream dessert, which Ben insisted on despite crew hesitation, making it a memorable moment.
The episode announces Mythical Kitchen's move to Netflix, with Ben as the first guest on the new platform, framing the chaotic wish format as a fitting premiere.
Ben's wish structure — a phone hotline with hold music and queue jokes — becomes a recurring comedic device that frames each segment and allows meta-commentary on the show's production.
The crew's dynamic is highlighted through unscripted moments: KG's dance challenge, the sword-cutting onion stunt, basketball on a mini-hoop, and the final group hug with simultaneous compliments.
Ben's improv background shapes the episode's tone: he "yes, ands" every surprise, redirects wishes mid-stream, and treats the crew as scene partners, blurring line between guest and co-creator.
Notable quotes
“Salt is the bassline from which all harmonies are written.”
▸ Notable quotes · 32:23“We did it all IATSE, and we did it in... Pastrami. It's good, right?”
▸ Notable quotes · 44:25“I think this is one of the few combinations in the world that I don't love, Jillian Anderson.”
▸ Notable quotes · 47:55“The prison's only up here and we know it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:22“Ben Schwartz give Dobby a sock.”
▸ Notable quotes · 45:30“To me, your body is just opening and just confetti is popping out of your clown-like mouth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 54:59Chapters
0:00 — Birthday Setup & Netflix Announcement: Ben Schwartz arrives as first guest for Mythical Kitchen's Netflix premiere; crew reveals it's his early birthday celebration with a wish-granting format.
3:00 — Wish Phone & First Wishes: Ben uses a custom 'wish hotline' phone to request a Ratatouille-style perspective meal (elevated childhood foods) and no FDA-recalled ingredients.
13:00 — Josh's Costume Change & Dance Wish: Ben wishes for Josh in a different outfit (knight helmet) and a choreographed dance by KG with eye contact and no smiling allowed.
34:00 — Chefs' Signature Dishes: Each culinary team member presents a personal favorite dish: teriyaki potato skins, fried chicken with watermelon, pork fried rice, and hamachi crudo.
43:00 — Basketball, Video Games & Weight Throw: Ben and Josh play mini-hoop basketball, play Pilot Wings on SNES, and Josh demonstrates his collegiate indoor weight throw technique in the parking lot.
51:00 — Desserts & Lady-and-the-Tramp Kiss: Crew serves collaborative 'bookie' dessert and chili-dog ice cream; Ben insists on sharing the latter Lady-and-the-Tramp style, resulting in a kiss.
52:00 — Group Hug, Jillian's Birthday & Rhett & Link Surprise: Crew group hug with simultaneous compliments, birthday shout-out to makeup artist Jillian, and surprise appearance by Rhett and Link.
Speakers
Josh — Host
Ben Schwartz — Guest
Annaliese — Producer
Colby — Chef
Vee — Chef
Tony — Chef
Ash — Chef
KG — Crew/Dancer
Winnie — Camera Operator
Rhett & Link — Surprise Guests