TLDR
Jaby Koay and Brandon Tenney react to the 2024 thriller 'Verity' starring Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson, and Josh Hartnett. They watch the film in real-time, discussing plot twists, character motivations, and the ambiguous ending where a manuscript suggests Verity killed her daughter, but a final letter claims it was just a writing exercise.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The manuscript's horrific content (child murder, spousal resentment) is framed as a therapeutic writing exercise suggested by Verity's editor.
Jeremy's emotional breakdown reading the manuscript in front of Lowen was a performance — he'd already read it privately.
Verity's paralysis was entirely faked; she was conscious and mobile the whole time, manipulating everyone.
The film never explains why Verity was driving alone at night when her accident occurred.
Lowen never confronts Verity directly despite suspecting the truth, and Verity dies without a final confrontation.
The nurse's applesauce feedings and Verity's 'ghostly' appearances are left unexplained — possible sedation or misdirection.
Key takeaways
The film centers on Lowen (Dakota Johnson) hired to finish Verity's (Anne Hathaway) book series after Verity's accident, leading to discovery of a disturbing manuscript.
The manuscript reveals Verity may have murdered her daughter Harper, but a final letter claims it was merely 'antagonistic journaling' — a writing exercise.
Josh Hartnett's Jeremy is ambiguous: he may have tried to kill Verity after reading the manuscript, or he's a victim of her manipulation.
The film uses heavy red color symbolism throughout (dresses, blood, wine, lighting) to signal danger and passion.
The isolated Vermont lake house setting is underutilized for atmospheric tension despite its potential.
The bike accident opening scene serves only to establish Jeremy's trauma tolerance, never returning narratively.
The nurse Anna acts as a red herring; her potential involvement is never resolved.
The ending deliberately refuses certainty, leaving viewers to decide whether Verity was a villain or victim.
Notable quotes
“I pulled my eight-year-old daughter's body out of a lake last spring.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:33“It was an exercise. It wasn't real.”
▸ Notable quotes · 57:15“The only thing I know for certain is that Verity was a master at manipulating the truth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 59:57“If you think about the premise too long, it falls apart. If you don't think about it, it's a fun beautiful movie.”
▸ Notable quotes · 78:28“I think that's what they wanted you to think.”
▸ Notable quotes · 88:48“This is a great movie for like making yourself ask those questions. Like what else could you have done?”
▸ Notable quotes · 89:56Chapters
0:00 — Introduction & Patreon Setup: Jaby and Brandon introduce the watch-along for 'Verity,' explain the Patreon sync-viewing format, and note the cast (Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson, Josh Hartnett).
1:03 — Movie Begins: Verity's Fame & Lowen's Trauma: Opening scenes establish Verity as a bestselling author. Lowen meets Jeremy after witnessing a fatal bike accident; both share traumatic losses (her mother, his daughter).
6:01 — The Job Offer & Arrival at the Crawford Home: Jeremy hires Lowen to finish Verity's series for $75k/book (Brandon says she should ask for $500k). Lowen moves into their Vermont home, meets son Crew and nurse Anna, and sees Verity's catatonic state.
15:14 — Reading the Manuscript: Dark Confessions: Lowen reads Verity's autobiographical manuscript revealing resentment toward her children, neglect, and the canoe incident where Harper died. The manuscript suggests Verity killed Harper intentionally.
46:37 — Climax: Confrontation, Murder & The Letter: Jeremy discovers Lowen read the manuscript, attacks Verity, and they stage her death as an accident. Lowen later finds a letter from Verity claiming the manuscript was just a writing exercise ('antagonistic journaling').
60:16 — Post-Movie Discussion & Analysis: The hosts debate the ending's ambiguity, compare to similar thrillers ('The Housemaid,' 'Trap'), praise Hartnett's comeback, critique underused setting/nurse character, and discuss whether the manuscript or letter is truth.
Speakers
Jaby Koay — Host
Brandon Tenney — Co-host