TLDR
This episode covers the opening statements in the federal trial of former Stoughton police officer Matthew Farwell, charged with murdering Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child, then staging her death as a suicide. The prosecution presented a detailed timeline showing Farwell groomed Sandra from age 12, sexually abused her for years, and killed her when she threatened to expose him after becoming pregnant. The defense admits the affair but claims Sandra killed herself after Farwell broke up with her and denied paternity, arguing DNA evidence can be explained by consensual contact.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The prosecution alleges Farwell told Sandra 'the best day of my life was taking your virginity' when she was 15, and texted 'I would have absolutely effed you in 2012' when she would have been 14.
Farwell started his own family with his wife just one month after taking Sandra's virginity at age 15, and had two children with his wife while continuing to abuse Sandra.
The CPAC investigator Fanning told William Farwell (Matthew's brother), 'We need this investigation like we need a bullet in the effing head,' suggesting active hostility toward investigating Sandra's death.
Farwell wore a mask and all-black clothing to Sandra's apartment despite being documented as anti-mask and resisting mask mandates, which the prosecution argues shows consciousness of guilt.
Sandra told 81 people she was pregnant, had booked baby shower venues, scheduled photo shoots, and was actively planning for her baby's arrival on the day she died, which the prosecution argues is inconsistent with suicidal intent.
The defense admits Farwell was the person on the surveillance video entering Sandra's apartment wearing a mask, but claims it was to hide his affair, not because he was committing murder.
Key takeaways
Farwell met Sandra Birchmore at age 12 through the Police Explorers program and began grooming her at 15, engaging in statutory rape and a years-long sexual relationship while on duty as a Stoughton police officer.
Sandra became pregnant in December 2020; Farwell believed he was the father but DNA later proved he was not, which the defense argues removes his motive to kill her and her unborn child.
On January 20, 2021, a woman called Stoughton PD about Farwell's relationship with Sandra; 12 days later Sandra was dead, and the prosecution argues this timeline shows Farwell lost control and acted to silence her permanently.
Surveillance video shows Farwell entering Sandra's apartment wearing a mask and all-black clothing on the night she died, despite evidence he resisted wearing masks during COVID, which the defense claims was to conceal his affair, not commit murder.
The Norfolk County CPAC unit initially ruled Sandra's death a suicide and allegedly conducted a negligent or intentional cover-up: they met Farwell casually, let him keep his phone for days, allowed him to delete data, and only interviewed his brother William Farwell.
The medical examiner initially ruled the death a suicide but changed the ruling to homicide after the FBI investigation uncovered Farwell's history of choking Sandra and his presence at her apartment.
The defense's theory is that Farwell went to Sandra's apartment to break up with her and tell her he wasn't the father, and she killed herself in despair; they argue hyoid bone fractures can occur in suicidal hangings with as little as 7 pounds of force.
Farwell's DNA was found on the duffel bag strap used to hang Sandra; the defense argues this could be secondary transfer from their sexual relationship and his presence in her home, not evidence he staged the scene.
Notable quotes
“The evidence will show Sandra had no idea the defendant decided she would die that night. The defendant knew he had a real problem because his wife was going to give birth the next day.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:54“Farwell said the best day of his life was taking Sandra's virginity. I mean, you're going to want to barf a lot through this trial.”
▸ Notable quotes · 8:29“Farwell told Sandra to delete all of their communications from her phone to hide evidence of his crimes. Knowing that's conscious of guilt, right? Knowing what you're doing is wrong.”
▸ Notable quotes · 9:14“Everything was fine. Farwell was keeping her at arm's length, keeping her quiet as much as he could cuz he thought he was controlling her and she wasn't telling anybody. But as soon as he finds out she has been telling people and it's out of his control now, 12 days later she's dead.”
▸ Notable quotes · 17:28“The Norfolk DA C-PAC team did not even do the semblance of an investigation. They met Farwell casually in the parking lot. They let Farwell keep his phone for days before searching it. They let him delete material from his phone.”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:09“Farwell's lawyer says Sandra killed herself because Farwell broke up with her and said he wasn't the father of her baby. You must find him not guilty.”
▸ Notable quotes · 36:43Chapters
0:00 — Introduction and Case Overview: Host Peter Trakas introduces the federal trial of Matthew Farwell, charged with murdering Sandra Birchmore and her unborn child, staging it as suicide. He outlines the allegations: Farwell groomed Sandra from age 12, abused her for years, and killed her to prevent exposure.
2:13 — Prosecution's Opening Statement: Via reporter Grant Smith Ellis's notes, the prosecution's detailed opening is summarized: timeline of grooming from age 12, statutory rape at 15, years of abuse, Sandra's pregnancy, the January 20 call to police, Farwell's surveillance video at her apartment, DNA evidence, and the CPAC unit's alleged cover-up.
28:01 — Defense's Opening Statement: The defense admits Farwell had an affair and was at Sandra's apartment but claims he went to break up with her and deny paternity. They argue Sandra killed herself in despair, challenge the medical examiner's findings, and claim DNA transfer from consensual contact explains the evidence.
39:02 — Host Analysis and Commentary: Trakas analyzes both openings, finding the prosecution's timeline compelling and the defense's theory logically inconsistent with Sandra's past behavior of using threats as leverage. He highlights the CPAC unit's alleged failures and the medical examiner's changed ruling.
42:02 — Wrap-Up and Future Coverage Plans: Trakas previews upcoming trial coverage, emphasizing focus on witness credibility, cross-examination, DNA reliability, and law enforcement testimony. He asks for audience input on trusted reporters and plans to cover the trial every few days.
Speakers
Peter Trakas — Host