TLDR
In 2016, 22-year-old Katie Blauvelt was brutally murdered and staged with satanic symbols in an abandoned house to frame her friend Wayne Roer. The killer was her husband, John Blauvelt, an Army recruiter who used his military training to execute a near-perfect crime and flee with his 17-year-old girlfriend, Hannah Thompson. Detectives set a daring trap at Katie's funeral to collect John's DNA, which matched evidence under Katie's fingernails. John and Hannah evaded capture for six years, living under aliases across multiple states, until U.S. Marshals arrested John in Oregon in 2022. He was convicted in 2024 and sentenced to life without parole; Hannah received 10 years for obstruction and accessory after the fact. The full details of how Katie was lured to the house remain unknown. Charles Scott, John's Army friend, was implicated by a jailhouse informant but never charged due to lack of forensic evidence. Hannah continued secretly communicating with John while he was a fugitive, feeding him case information. The case reveals a calculated, premeditated murder driven by John's obsession with Hannah and desire to escape his marriage, enabled by a teenager who became his accomplice in flight.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
John defended Wayne Roer — the man he was actively framing — during his police interrogation, using a manipulation tactic called 'reverse empathy' to appear trustworthy and harmless.
Detectives wired Katie's funeral home with hidden cameras and microphones and planted cups of water to secretly collect John's DNA, an unconventional tactic that succeeded when John drank from a cup and left it behind.
At Katie's funeral, John took photos of her body in the casket while making unsettling comments, and 17-year-old Hannah Thompson stood beside him, giggling — behavior so disturbing it immediately drew investigative scrutiny.
John and Hannah were on the run for over two weeks before any arrest warrants were issued, giving them a massive head start that allowed them to vanish across state lines before law enforcement could fully mobilize.
After Hannah's interrogation where she admitted John confessed to her, detectives deliberately kept her free and under surveillance hoping she would lead them to John — but she continued secretly communicating with him and feeding him case details for years.
John lived under a false identity for six years, married a new woman, and built a seemingly normal life in Oregon before being caught, demonstrating an extraordinary level of planning and discipline for a fugitive.
Key takeaways
John Blauvelt meticulously planned and executed his wife Katie's murder, staging the crime scene with satanic symbols and a concealed body to frame her friend Wayne Roer, exploiting Wayne's history with Katie and his presence at the discovery scene.
Detectives employed an unconventional and risky strategy at Katie's funeral, wiring the funeral home with hidden cameras and planting drinks to collect John's DNA without a warrant — a tactic that succeeded when John drank from a cup and left it behind, providing the crucial DNA match to evidence under Katie's fingernails.
John used 'reverse empathy' during his first interrogation, defending Wayne — the very man he was framing — to appear compassionate and trustworthy, manipulating detectives into perceiving him as harmless while planting the narrative that Katie was dating around to divert suspicion.
John fled with 17-year-old Hannah Thompson, his girlfriend and former friend of Katie, and they remained on the run for over two weeks before any arrest warrants were issued, giving them a massive head start that allowed them to cross multiple states and evade capture for six years.
Hannah Thompson was complicit well beyond the flight: she hid John's journal containing premeditation evidence, communicated with him throughout his fugitive years, and fed him information about the investigation after her own interrogation, effectively acting as his inside source while pretending to cooperate with police.
A jailhouse informant, the cellmate of John's Army friend Charles Scott, provided detailed allegations that Charles helped lure Katie to the murder site and participated in moving her body — details that matched forensic findings — but Charles was never charged due to insufficient physical evidence linking him to the crime.
John lived under the alias 'Ben Klene' for years in Oregon, married a new woman, and integrated into a community before U.S. Marshals tracked him down in 2022, demonstrating the sophistication of his long-term evasion and the challenges of locating a fugitive with military training and a fabricated identity.
The investigation stalled for years after the initial breakthroughs, relying on sporadic tips and the eventual recovery of John's journal — which Hannah had hidden — to confirm premeditation and motive: John's obsessive desire to be with Hannah and his willingness to kill Katie to make it happen.
Notable quotes
“Mr. defies any kind of logic that I have experienced in my 62 years on this earth.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:56“We know more than you think we do. What if I told you that your cell phone did ping somewhere other than where you say you were?”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:02“All you got to do is lay the burden down. That's the only way you'll be forgiven. You got to say, 'I messed up. Help me.'”
▸ Notable quotes · 11:33“He killed her for me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:19“The last thing she she said was ow. And she said that before that that if he let her go that she wouldn't call the police.”
▸ Notable quotes · 52:55“I don't know what he's saying. I don't know. But I know I never seen that girl day in my life.”
▸ Notable quotes · 46:23Chapters
0:00 — Body discovered, Wayne Roer becomes suspect: Katie Blauvelt disappears after work on October 24, 2016; her body is found 10 hours later in an abandoned house basement, staged with satanic symbols. Friend Wayne Roer discovers the body and becomes the prime suspect due to his presence at the scene and past relationship with Katie.
4:47 — Wayne Roer interrogated, reveals John's jealousy: Detectives interrogate Wayne, who reveals he once dated Katie and later lived with her and John. He describes John's violent jealousy and a drunken threesome, shifting suspicion toward John. However, Wayne's own inconsistencies keep him in the crosshairs.
13:24 — John Blauvelt's first interrogation, reverse empathy tactic: John is questioned at his military office. He calmly directs detectives toward Katie's dating life, defends Wayne as a 'good guy,' and uses reverse empathy to appear harmless. Detectives suspect him but lack evidence to hold him.
16:46 — Witness interviews: Crystal, Catherine, Cheyenne: Detectives interview Katie's best friend Crystal (John's roommate), John's ex-wife Catherine, and Katie's niece Cheyenne. Crystal unknowingly reinforces John's narrative about Katie's dating. Catherine refuses to discuss past violence. Cheyenne reveals John's motive: rage over losing his job, blaming Katie, and a $150,000 life insurance policy.
23:58 — Funeral home DNA trap: Detectives wire Katie's funeral home with hidden cameras and planted drinks to collect John's DNA without a warrant. John drinks from a cup, takes disturbing photos of Katie's body, and 17-year-old Hannah Thompson giggles beside him. DNA from the cup later matches evidence under Katie's fingernails.
27:11 — Hannah Thompson interrogated, caught lying: Hannah is brought in and confronted with funeral footage. She lies about not remembering trash removal on the murder night, but John later confirms they took out bags. Detectives bluff about knowing more than she thinks, but she refuses to confess.
32:58 — John's second interrogation, Charles Scott emerges: John is questioned again. He mentions Army friend Charles Scott for the first time. Cell phone data places both John and Charles near the crime scene. John refuses a polygraph. Detectives now have a link between John, Charles, and the murder location.
38:52 — John and Hannah flee, nationwide manhunt begins: John disappears after a call to Crystal; he and Hannah flee in his red Yukon. The vehicle is spotted in New Mexico and found abandoned in Oregon with their belongings. Arrest warrants are issued, but the pair has a two-week head start. Phone and chat logs later reveal premeditation and John's statement: 'He killed her for me.'
Speakers
Narrator — Podcast host
John Blauvelt — Katie's husband, killer
Wayne Roer — Katie's friend, framed suspect
Detectives — Simpsonville Police investigators
Crystal — Katie's best friend, John's roommate
Catherine — John's ex-wife
Cheyenne — Katie's niece
Hannah Thompson — John's 17-year-old girlfriend, accomplice
Charles Scott — John's Army friend
Mark — Charles Scott's cellmate, informant