Ex-Psychologist Had Sex in Front of Teen Girl

Original Media · 20m · English · YouTube · Law&Crime Network

TLDR

Psychologist Maria Dwarte was convicted of lewd and lascivious behavior with a 15-year-old girl but acquitted of human trafficking after a Miami-area hotel encounter in August 2024. Her boyfriend and another man took plea deals and testified against her, while defense attorney Robert Bar argues the victim came and went freely and the trafficking charge was never supported by evidence. Dwarte faces up to 15 years at sentencing in January and has lost her license permanently.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The man identified as 'Pablo' to the victim was actually Hermes Mahia, who received only probation after pleading to a child abuse charge despite the victim's allegation that he had sex with her.

•

The victim played on her phone in the bathroom during the alleged assault rather than fleeing, which the defense used to argue she was not held against her will.

•

A federal prosecutor happened to be in the jury venire and was questioned by the defense about witness credibility, then cited by the defense in closing argument as validating their impeachment strategy.

Key takeaways

•

The jury rejected the human trafficking charge because the 15-year-old victim freely entered and left the hotel room without coercion or confinement, which the defense argued was fatal to the prosecution's top count.

•

Both male co-defendants — Dwarte's boyfriend Jason Moa and Hermes Mahia — secured dramatically reduced sentences by pleading guilty and testifying against her, with Moa receiving seven years and Mahia only probation.

•

The defense highlighted that the victim never called police herself and had a motive to fabricate because she was trying to help a friend involved in other criminal activity.

•

Dwarte's psychologist license was permanently revoked by Florida's Department of Health following her arrest, ending her career regardless of the criminal outcome.

•

The defense filed a motion for new trial arguing the judge erred by refusing lesser-included-offense instructions on the felony count, which could have reduced Dwarte's maximum exposure from 15 years to 60 days.

•

During voir dire, Bar used a federal prosecutor in the venire to establish that freedom is more valuable than money, then argued the co-defendants' plea deals for freedom made them inherently untrustworthy witnesses.

Notable quotes

“She's doing okay under the circumstances. Um, it was a long, not quite two weeks, but uh, I believe she's doing okay.”

▸ Notable quotes · 5:37

“Under the sentencing guidelines, I believe she's eligible for what's called non-state prison sanctions, which means um the judge has the discretion not to sentence her to a state penitentiary sentence.”

▸ Notable quotes · 6:06

“Clearly they believe she did not human traffic this young girl because human trafficking typically requires transporting, abducting, uh holding someone against their will. And this young lady freely went to and from the hotel.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:49

“The fact that she was found not guilty of the human trafficking was quite frankly a huge win.”

▸ Notable quotes · 11:45

“I asked the entire panel, 'What's more important to you, freedom or money?' And they all said freedom. So then I turned to the federal prosecutor and asked him if it is illegal to take a bribe in Florida in the United States for that matter. And of course it is. So then I asked him why is it illegal to take a bribe for a witness? And the federal prosecutor said it makes them untrustworthy.”

▸ Notable quotes · 14:21

“In my opinion, the human trafficking charge should have never been brought. It wasn't there. the evidence wasn't there from the start because if you look at the injury instructions on human trafficking, the things the state has to prove just weren't there.”

▸ Notable quotes · 18:32

Chapters

•

0:00 — Case background and arrest: Maria Dwarte, a 45-year-old psychologist, was arrested in August 2024 after allegedly luring a 15-year-old girl to a hotel room where she was sexually assaulted by two men.

•

1:01 — Hotel encounter details: The victim met Dwarte while walking her dog at the Aloft Hotel; Dwarte identified as a psychologist, offered alcohol and marijuana, and introduced her to two men who sexually assaulted her.

•

3:39 — Co-defendant plea deals: Jason Moa pleaded guilty to sex with a minor for seven years plus probation; Hermes Mahia pleaded to child abuse and received only probation. Both testified against Dwarte.

•

4:03 — Trial and verdict: Dwarte was convicted of lewd and lascivious exhibition (felony) and unnatural and lascivious act (misdemeanor) but acquitted of human trafficking, the most serious charge.

•

5:25 — Defense attorney interview: Robert Bar explains the verdict, argues the trafficking charge lacked evidence of coercion, and details his strategy attacking co-defendant credibility through their plea deals.

•

16:17 — Appeal and sentencing outlook: Bar filed a motion for new trial over denied lesser-included-offense instructions; Dwarte faces up to 15 years at January sentencing and has been remanded to jail.

Speakers

•

Jesse Weber — Host

•

Robert Bar — Defense attorney

•

Maria Dwarte — Defendant

⋮