Bill Kristol Sees the Midterms Going From Bad to Worse for Trump's GOP | Morning Shots

Original Media · 43m · English · YouTube · The Bulwark

TLDR

Bill Kristol and Andrew Egger analyze the midterm elections one week out, finding polling trends strongly favoring Democrats across Senate races. They discuss key contests in Texas (Talarico vs. Paxton with Elon Musk's heavy spending), Iowa, Michigan, and stretch-goal states Mississippi, Kansas, and Florida. They also examine the DOJ's flimsy prosecution of James Comey and why Senate control is the critical prize for checking judicial appointments.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

Elon Musk has spent more on the Texas Senate race ($180+ million) than Trump's own super PAC, making him the single largest outside spender in a Senate contest this cycle.

•

Cindy Hyde-Smith's 'pick another protein' gaffe on beef prices has become the centerpiece of her opponent's campaign ad — 'Pick another protein? I'd rather pick another senator.'

•

The DOJ filed charging documents against James Comey without securing a grand jury indictment, using a procedural maneuver to reset the statute of limitations clock — a move so weak it couldn't even get a grand jury to sign off.

•

Trump's first-term judicial appointments were largely delegated to the Federalist Society without personal loyalty screening, resulting in many Trump-appointed judges who now rule against his administration's overreach.

Key takeaways

•

Polling averages show Democrats leading the generic ballot by 8.5-9 points with no reversion to the mean, and early voting data confirms a wave election environment that could yield a 'good to terrifically good' Democratic year.

•

In Texas, James Talarico has pivoted to attacking Elon Musk as the face of outside money, running ads accusing Musk of spending $180 million to buy a Senate seat for corrupt incumbent Ken Paxton — a fresh angle that cuts through ad fatigue.

•

Iowa and Michigan showcase contrasting Democratic strategies: Josh Turek runs as an explicit centrist in red Iowa, while Abdul El-Sayed runs as a progressive in swing Michigan; both lead narrowly, suggesting candidate authenticity matters more than ideological positioning.

•

Mississippi has unexpectedly become competitive due to high Black turnout driven by voting rights backlash, while Kansas is a toss-up thanks to agricultural economic pain from tariffs and diesel prices, and Florida may revert to its 2018 competitiveness if the wave is large enough.

•

The DOJ's last-minute charging document against James Comey — filed without a grand jury indictment to beat a statute of limitations — exemplifies politically motivated prosecutions that courts keep rejecting, but which still intimidate lower-profile officials.

•

Senate control is the single most important outcome on election night: a Democratic Senate would block Trump's judicial nominees (including loyalists he now prioritizes), while a Republican Senate would enable rapid confirmation of ideologically aligned judges across the federal bench.

•

Rob Sand's commanding lead in the Iowa governor's race (11 points in recent polling) stems from his unique anti-corruption brand and personal authenticity rather than ideological positioning, outperforming the Senate candidate in the same state.

Notable quotes

“If it's confirmed by other things like Trump's approval and and his approval, which is pretty catastrophic and which hasn't changed, continues to drift out if anything. And the early vote, which people can get into reading the entrails too much, but it is real. The more than 30 million people have voted.”

▸ Notable quotes · 0:55

“The average of the polls, so that's always more reliable than any one poll, and 538 plus one, which is a good aggregator and does a little waiting for the more, you know, for the latest ones and also it's a sophisticated aggregator, has gone from basically six at the beginning of Labor Day generic ballot seven and a half about three four weeks ago, now eight and a half to nine actually, a little above nine and right now.”

▸ Notable quotes · 1:18

“He's almost single-handedly bankrolling in effort to install Ken Paxton in the US Senate. But why is the world's first trillionaire doing this? Elon wants to buy up our land. He wants to buy up our water. And now he wants to buy his own personal US Senator.”

▸ Notable quotes · 7:39

“You know, people don't like kind of like what you've done a lot of it and you're not going to change their mind in the last week of election campaign. So, maybe you should just cool it on saying what you've been and hitting your own themes and just do some other stuff, you know.”

▸ Notable quotes · 10:30

“ICE has done In that respect, I think yeah, you're right to make the distinction. One is corrosive to our institutions internally, but less dangerous in the actual effects on human beings, you know, out there. ICE is as corrosive, but actually has had a really horrible effect on actual people and communities.”

▸ Notable quotes · 37:29

“Democratic Senate, Republican Senate is one of the biggest, you know, deltas, one of the biggest differences it will make over the next 2 years.”

▸ Notable quotes · 40:46

Chapters

•

0:00 — Election overview and polling analysis: Kristol explains why polling averages, Trump's approval ratings, and early voting data all point to a strong Democratic wave, while acknowledging superstition about predicting outcomes.

•

4:00 — Texas Senate race and Elon Musk's role: Talarico's campaign pivots to attacking Elon Musk's $180M spending for Ken Paxton, framing it as a billionaire trying to buy a Senate seat for a corrupt politician.

•

13:00 — Iowa and Michigan Senate contrasts: Two Democratic candidates take opposite ideological approaches — Turek as centrist in Iowa, El-Sayed as progressive in Michigan — both leading narrowly, while intra-party recriminations begin prematurely.

•

26:00 — Stretch-goal states: Mississippi, Kansas, Florida: Mississippi becomes competitive due to Black turnout surge from voting rights backlash; Kansas is a toss-up from farm economy pain; Florida may revert to 2018-level competitiveness if the wave is large enough.

•

33:30 — James Comey prosecution and DOJ overreach: The DOJ files a charging document against Comey without a grand jury indictment to beat a statute of limitations, exemplifying politically motivated prosecutions that courts keep rejecting.

•

39:00 — Judicial confirmations and Senate control stakes: Senate control is the key prize: a Democratic Senate blocks Trump's loyalist judicial nominees, while a Republican Senate enables rapid confirmation of ideologically aligned judges across the federal bench.

Speakers

•

Bill Kristol — Co-host, political analyst

•

Andrew Egger — Co-host, writer

⋮