Alex Murdaugh Hearing Creates A Real Problem - Will This Delay The Trial?

Original Media · 1h 24m · English · YouTube · Lawyer You Know

TLDR

The defense moves to dismiss Alex Murdaugh's indictment without prejudice, arguing lead investigator David Owens presented false blood spatter evidence to the grand jury. SLED's lab confirmed no human blood on Murdaugh's shirt in August 2021, yet the prosecution hired expert Tom Bevel who reversed his initial 'no spatter' opinion after viewing Photoshopped images, and this false evidence was leaked to the press and presented to the grand jury as the key piece placing Murdaugh at the murders. The prosecution concedes errors but argues the evidence wasn't false, the expert still stands by his opinion, and ample other evidence (kennel video, timeline, motive) supports the indictment. The judge's question about re-presenting to a grand jury by April 5th suggests she may grant the motion.

For you

PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.

Sign in to unlock

Surprising Insights

•

The SLED lab analyst accessed the 'no human blood' report on April 18-19, 2022, and the AG's office met with the lab on April 20, yet the grand jury was still presented with the blood spatter evidence in July 2022.

•

The defense obtained the critical HemTrace report only by bypassing normal discovery channels — filing a motion to compel directly to SLED — because the report never made it through the evidence.com channel to the AG's office.

•

Tom Bevel's final report claimed six other experts peer-reviewed his conclusion, but he never identified them, and the defense never got to cross-examine him on who they were or what they did.

•

The shirt, after being sprayed with LCV (Leucocrystal Violet), gradually turned entirely purple like tie-dye, making visual analysis impossible — yet Bevel based his reversed opinion on Photoshopped JPEG images of this degraded shirt.

•

Creighton Waters personally intervened to prevent mailing the shirt to Bevel, insisting an agent maintain physical custody — a procedural rigor that contrasts with the earlier failure to review the exculpatory lab report before grand jury testimony.

Key takeaways

•

The defense argues the grand jury heard categorically false testimony: that high-velocity blood spatter from Paul Murdaugh was found on Alex Murdaugh's shirt, when SLED's own confirmatory HemTrace test had already reported 'no human blood' six weeks earlier.

•

Lead investigator David Owens testified to the grand jury that Paul's DNA was found in the alleged spatter areas on the shirt, but the lab report actually stated 'no conclusion could be reached' due to the interrelatedness of family DNA contributors.

•

The prosecution's blood spatter expert, Tom Bevel, initially reported the stains were consistent with transfers, not back-spatter; after a meeting with agents and viewing Photoshopped JPEG images (not the raw photos he requested), he reversed his opinion to claim over 100 spatter stains, still without being told the HemTrace results were negative.

•

The defense cites State v. Thrift and State v. Colucci, arguing that even without intentional prosecutorial misconduct, an indictment must be dismissed if false evidence substantially influenced the grand jury or creates grave doubt about the decision to indict.

•

Prosecutor Creighton Waters argues the blood spatter evidence was not false because the expert still stands by his opinion, and that even if there were mistakes, the 'competent evidence' standard (citing US v. Moore) allows the indictment to stand given the kennel video, timeline, motive, and other evidence presented.

•

The judge's only substantive question — asking if the state could re-present to a grand jury by April 5th — signals she is seriously considering granting the dismissal without prejudice, which would reset the grand jury process but not end the case.

•

The defense contends the blood spatter was the 'only direct evidence' placing Murdaugh at the murder scene at the time of the killings, making its falsity structurally significant regardless of other circumstantial evidence.

•

The prosecution's own witness, Creighton Waters, admitted the state did not use the blood spatter evidence at trial, and the expert's false-negative experiment was rejected by SLED's own lab, undermining the state's claim that the grand jury testimony was reliable.

Notable quotes

“What the grand jury heard and what SLED's lab had found. The DNA in the areas of spatter were identified as belonging to Alex, Maggie, and Paul. Not true. Not true.”

▸ Notable quotes · 42:07

“Going in front of the Colleton County grand jury is Alex got Paul's death blood on his shirt that you could only get by being there when his head is blown off.”

▸ Notable quotes · 43:03

“As long as there's some other competent evidence to sustain the charge, the charge should not be dismissed.”

▸ Notable quotes · 63:45

“The standard isn't would they have found probable cause without this? That's not the test.”

▸ Notable quotes · 79:54

“If you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it done and all ready to go April 5th?”

▸ Notable quotes · 81:52

Chapters

•

0:00 — Introduction & Motion Overview: Host Peter Tragos introduces the hearing on the defense's motion to dismiss the indictment without prejudice, framing the core issue: false blood spatter evidence presented to the grand jury by lead investigator David Owens.

•

1:18 — Jury Selection Challenges: Brief discussion of the extreme difficulty of seating an impartial jury for a second trial given pervasive media coverage, documentaries, and prior convictions, comparing it to the Karen Read case.

•

3:58 — Defense Argument: Blood Spatter Timeline: Griffin details the timeline: SLED's HemTrace test (Aug 2021) found no human blood; prosecution hired Bevel (Feb 2022) who first said no spatter, then reversed after viewing Photoshopped images; false evidence leaked to press (Apr 2022) and presented to grand jury (Jul 2022).

•

22:00 — Defense Argument: Lab Reports & Digital Evidence: Griffin shows SLED audit logs proving the 'no human blood' report was accessed 10 times before indictment, including by the analyst on April 18-19, and that Owens's grand jury notes referenced DNA results from the same report he claimed not to have seen.

•

44:16 — Defense Argument: Shotgun Shell Testimony: Griffin argues Owens also falsely testified that shotguns at Moselle were loaded with the same mixed buckshot/turkey loads used in Paul's murder, which Owens later admitted was mistaken.

•

45:16 — Prosecution Response: Grand Jury Process & Evidence: Waters distinguishes Colucci, argues all evidence was litigated at trial, and walks through the investigation timeline: LCV testing, Bevel's evolving opinion, kennel video discovery (Apr 2022), voice identification, FBI telemetry, and the decision to indict only after the timeline crystallized.

•

54:00 — Prosecution Response: Blood Spatter & Expert Credibility: Waters concedes Bevel's initial 'no spatter' report but emphasizes his final opinion stands, supported by his own experiment claiming LCV causes HemTrace false negatives; notes the state did not use this evidence at trial.

•

71:00 — Judge's Questions & Final Rebuttal: Judge probes the LCV process, photo evidence, and report access timeline; Griffin rebuts that the blood spatter was the only direct evidence placing Murdaugh at the scene, and the judge asks if re-indictment by April 5th is feasible, indicating she may grant the motion.

Speakers

•

Peter Tragos — Host/Commentator

•

Griffin — Defense Attorney

•

Creighton Waters — Prosecutor

•

Judge — Presiding Judge

⋮