TLDR
This episode revisits the case of Thomas Randolph, a Las Vegas man convicted of orchestrating the 2008 murder of his sixth wife Sharon and the subsequent killing of handyman Mike Miller to cover it up. Randolph had six wives total, four of whom died under suspicious circumstances, and he collected life insurance payouts after each death. After two trials and an overturned conviction, Randolph was ultimately sentenced to at least 60 years in prison in 2024.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
Randolph collected life insurance money after his wives' deaths even when he was the prime suspect, including nearly $500,000 after Becky's death despite police believing he murdered her.
Randolph directed and filmed his fifth wife Francis's video will himself, in which she stated she wanted to be cremated and for him to raise her daughter — Francis was not terminally ill at the time.
After being acquitted of Becky's murder, Randolph sued the police departments that investigated him and they settled, paying him off despite believing he was guilty.
Randolph had a girlfriend, Elizabeth, throughout his entire marriage to Sharon, and he pressured her to take out a life insurance policy naming him as beneficiary before they ever married.
The ski mask Miller allegedly wore during the 'break-in' had no bullet holes or blood on it, contradicting Randolph's claim that Miller was wearing it when shot.
Key takeaways
Thomas Randolph married six women over three decades, and four of them died — Becky (1986), Leona (cancer), Francis (2004), and Sharon (2008) — with Randolph collecting substantial life insurance payouts after each death.
Randolph followed a consistent pattern: he would marry a woman, take out multiple life insurance policies on her, then attempt to recruit acquaintances to kill her, successfully doing so with handyman Mike Miller for his sixth wife Sharon.
The 911 call and walkthrough video revealed critical inconsistencies: Randolph claimed he heard a gunshot on the 911 call but later said he heard nothing; forensic evidence showed most bullet casings and blood were in the garage, not the hallway where Randolph said the confrontation occurred.
Randolph waited 10-15 minutes after shooting Miller before calling 911, during which time his wife Sharon bled to death, and he only attempted CPR after the dispatcher instructed him to.
Two men — Eric Tarantino and Glenn Morrison — independently testified that Randolph had asked them to kill his wives (Becky and Francis respectively) years before the Sharon Miller plot, establishing a pattern of murder-for-hire attempts.
Randolph was acquitted of Becky's murder in 1988 but later pleaded to witness tampering for trying to have Eric killed; he sued police departments and won settlements, using the money to fund his lifestyle.
The first trial in 2017 resulted in a death sentence, but it was overturned in 2020 because the judge ruled Becky's case shouldn't have been admitted; a 2023 retrial without that evidence still produced a guilty verdict on all counts.
Randolph represented himself as a charming, adventurous partner but was described by ex-wives and investigators as controlling, narcissistic, and financially motivated, with a history of drug use and infidelity.
Notable quotes
“The ordinary rules of human behavior don't apply to him.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:09“Nice guy. I'm I'm cocky, but certainly doesn't make me a murderer.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:22“In the end, I'm going to win.”
▸ Notable quotes · 0:30“He wanted Kathy to do exactly as he said, and he did not like when things didn't go his way.”
▸ Notable quotes · 5:54“Tom had asked him more than once if he would kill someone if he knew that he could get away with it.”
▸ Notable quotes · 6:31“He told her that he was sick of listening to her talk about killing herself and that if she wanted to do it so badly, she should just go for it. He even offered her some rope.”
▸ Notable quotes · 56:54Chapters
0:35 — Introduction and Netflix documentary: Annie Elise introduces the episode, explaining she's revisiting the Thomas Randolph case after Netflix released 'The Widower: Till Death Do Us Part,' and notes significant evidence was left out of the documentary.
3:52 — Sharon's murder and the 911 call: Details the night of May 8, 2008, when Randolph called 911 claiming an intruder, Mike Miller, shot his wife Sharon and he killed Miller in self-defense.
10:30 — Inconsistencies in Randolph's story: Police walkthrough reveals contradictions: Randolph's shifting account of hearing gunshots, forensic evidence placing the shooting in the garage not hallway, and the 15-minute delay before calling 911.
34:44 — Randolph's pattern with previous wives: Investigation uncovers Randolph's five prior marriages: Kathy (divorced), Becky (shot, ruled suicide), Leona (divorced, died later), Gayna (fled after gun incident), Francis (died suspiciously after heart surgery).
40:40 — Murder-for-hire pattern emerges: Two men — Eric Tarantino and Glenn Morrison — testify Randolph asked them to kill his wives Becky and Francis, establishing a pattern of recruiting hitmen.
52:40 — Arrest, trials, and appeals: Randolph arrested in 2009; first trial in 2017 yields death sentence; overturned in 2020; retrial in 2023 convicts him again; sentenced to 60+ years in 2024; appeal denied in 2024.
Speakers
Annie Elise — Host/Narrator
Tom Randolph — Subject/Defendant
Detectives — Investigators