TLDR
This episode covers the 2016 murder of Lynelle Barszakh in Palmdale, California. Initially, her boyfriend Lewis was the prime suspect due to their troubled relationship and a staged crime scene, but receipts and surveillance proved he was 90 miles away in Los Angeles at the time of the killing. The investigation then turned to Lynelle's supposed best friend Lorraine, who had discovered the body. Forensic evidence revealed Lorraine had actually met Lynelle only months earlier on Craigslist, became obsessed with her, and murdered her after Lynelle ended their brief intimate relationship. Lorraine fled to Belize but was captured a year later after an America's Most Wanted episode aired, and was sentenced to two 25-years-to-life terms. Lewis was exonerated and later rebuilt his life.
For you
PRO members can sign in and request more information — or their own version of this digest, tuned to what they care about.
Sign in to unlockSurprising Insights
The 'best friend of 10 years' narrative was completely fabricated — Lynelle's own mother had never met Lorraine.
Lorraine tried to call her flight to Belize a 'vacation' during interrogation.
The murder weapon (9mm Smith & Wesson) was registered to Lorraine, but the database didn't show it initially due to a system lag from her recent purchase.
Lewis, the wrongly accused boyfriend, hugged and thanked detectives when they released him, explaining that in Haiti arrest means you 'throw away the key.'
Lorraine had two bullets in her purse when she first spoke to police — a major red flag that was initially overlooked.
Key takeaways
Lynelle Barszakh was a dedicated nurse and kind-hearted person who helped immigrants integrate into American life.
Her boyfriend Lewis was initially arrested but had an ironclad alibi: receipts and surveillance placed him in LA at the time of the murder.
The crime scene was staged to frame Lewis, including a fabricated 'Dear John' letter and cleanup attempt.
Lorraine, the woman who reported the body and claimed to be Lynelle's 10-year best friend, was actually the killer.
Lorraine and Lynelle had only known each other a few months, meeting via a Craigslist 'women seeking women' ad.
Lorraine became obsessed with Lynelle, adopting her middle name 'Crystal' and claiming her BMW as her own.
Forensic evidence conclusively tied Lorraine to the crime: her fingerprint, DNA, footprint, handwriting, and a gun registered to her.
Lorraine fled to Belize and was only caught after the case was featured on America's Most Wanted.
Notable quotes
“This is not a thriller book. This is not fiction. This is someone's real life and her life is now over.”
▸ Notable quotes · 1:28“She was the glue to their family... she was really the peacemaker in the home.”
▸ Notable quotes · 4:07“I don't know. Someone shot her. Oh my god. That's not me. That's not me. That's not me.”
▸ Notable quotes · 22:05“Ding, ding, ding. Lorraine. Oh, Lorraine, Lorraine, Lorraine. What a damn fool, okay?”
▸ Notable quotes · 25:51“These two women were not best friends for the last 10 years. Anything but that, in fact.”
▸ Notable quotes · 29:32“The jury found her guilty as hell but definitely guilty. And she was sentenced to two 25-years-to-life prison terms.”
▸ Notable quotes · 33:19Chapters
0:04 — Introduction and Sponsor: Host introduces the case of Lynelle Barszakh's murder and thanks sponsor Raycon.
3:29 — Lynelle's Background: Details about Lynelle's life: born 1980, middle child of five, nurse, kind-hearted, helped immigrants.
6:38 — Relationship with Lewis: Lynelle met Haitian immigrant Lewis at nursing school; they bought a home but grew apart over finances and ambition.
12:33 — Day of the Murder: June 10, 2016 timeline: argument over secret phone, Lorraine leaves for park, returns to find body.
17:08 — Lewis Arrested and Released: Lewis becomes prime suspect but receipts and surveillance prove he was in LA; he is released and thanks police.
25:49 — Lorraine Revealed as Killer: Investigation shifts to Lorraine: fake friendship, obsession, forensic evidence, staged crime scene to frame Lewis.
33:19 — Capture and Conviction: Lorraine flees to Belize, caught after America's Most Wanted episode, convicted and sentenced to two 25-to-life terms.
34:40 — Conclusion and Reflection: Host reflects on Lynelle's impact, justice served, and the trauma for loved ones.
Speakers
Kendall Ray — Host/Narrator
Lewis (Louis) — Victim's Boyfriend
Lorraine — Murderer
Bobby — Victim's Mother
Marcel — Victim's Friend
Ike — Victim's Secret Partner
Detectives — Investigators